Live data from Hacker News

Bitcoin Core 26.0

github.com

11–20 of 55 posts

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#11

The Bitcoin Core GitHub repo was long ago hijacked by the for profit company, Blockstream. Every update made since their takeover has hurt the core principal of Bitcoin, which is to be peer to peer digital cash, a replacement for Visa-like daily payments.

bitcoin has no usecase as 'digital cash' anyway. plenty of other coins fill that role better for years now.

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#13
I have read the whitepaper and followed discussions about the protocol for quite some time, but never looked into the actual software landscape.

Bitcoin Core is a "Node", right? A software you run if you want to have the whole history of all Bitcoin transactions of your own hard drive? Therefore I would think it is only used by researchers and analysts?

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#14

GitHub should start introducing energy labels to repos so that they understand the impact they have on the environment.

How do you expect them to do that? Also I highly suspect a large portion of people on Github are aware that Bitcoin and other crytpo projects use a lot of energy.

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#15
post #13

I have read the whitepaper and followed discussions about the protocol for quite some time, but never looked into the actual software landscape. Bitcoin Core is a "Node", right? A software you run if you want to have the whole history of all Bitcoin transactions of your own hard drive? Therefore I would think it is only used by researchers and analysts?

isnt it necessary to run full node to mine bitcoin?

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#16
post #13

I have read the whitepaper and followed discussions about the protocol for quite some time, but never looked into the actual software landscape. Bitcoin Core is a "Node", right? A software you run if you want to have the whole history of all Bitcoin transactions of your own hard drive? Therefore I would think it is only used by researchers and analysts?

isnt it necessary to run full node to mine bitcoin?

At least one party in a mining pool has to do so, I guess, but not everyone (nor every computing device) who participates.

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#17
post #13

I have read the whitepaper and followed discussions about the protocol for quite some time, but never looked into the actual software landscape. Bitcoin Core is a "Node", right? A software you run if you want to have the whole history of all Bitcoin transactions of your own hard drive? Therefore I would think it is only used by researchers and analysts?

It's run by anyone who wants to support the consensus mechanism with more decentralization. I run it on my laptop.

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#18

I see a lot of resentment here for this software. But it’s perfectly possible to make your own implementation of the bitcoin protocol. Like Luke, who made Knots. And other versions exist too. The real pain comes from the choices in the past to keep bitcoin inclusive. Smaller blocks mean the ability to download and verify on simple cheap hardware. Have a look at ETH, SOL or EOS. What kind of server park do you need to…

Stop spreading FUD about Ethereum (SOL and EOS, valid).

Ethereum shares the same philosophy of ensuring that clients are capable of being used on lower end hardware to ensure diversity of nodes.

Ethereum nodes can and are being run on Raspberry PI's + SSD drives.

You can even validate the Ethereum network on a Raspberry PI.

In Ethereum you "validate" instead of "mine" like in bitcoin, this is what keeps the network secure and validating is much more power efficient (99.995% less power use than Bitcoin for). See Proof of Stake vs Proof of Work.

My question to you is: Look at BTC. What kind of specialized, expensive, environmentally unfriendly, ASICS do you need to secure the chain?

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#19

GitHub should start introducing energy labels to repos so that they understand the impact they have on the environment.

even better idea, github should charge repos that have huge environment impact shit load of money, and subsidize those who are good(and probably vote for the right people)

Re: Bitcoin Core 26.0

#20

The Bitcoin Core GitHub repo was long ago hijacked by the for profit company, Blockstream. Every update made since their takeover has hurt the core principal of Bitcoin, which is to be peer to peer digital cash, a replacement for Visa-like daily payments.

Could you decide whether you want cash or visa-like payments?

Cash transactions are more or less irreversible. Visa is very much not final until at least months after the fact.

Post reply on HN