Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 62 posts

Re: Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

#31
I used to think that people at FAANGs are some of the smartest. That's the usual narrative anyways.

After working with a lot of them, I realize that they have a long tail of brilliant people (it's a good place to rest/vest and retire) but most of them are average cogs that are only good at grinding leetcode and average on everything else.

I have seen way smarter people in startups that will never accept to work at places like FAANGs.

Re: Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

#32

Doctors

After my last bunch of medical issues, I lost confidence in this field almost entirely. Doctors (or at least most of them) are not critical thinkers. They simply repeat the knowledge they have seen in textbooks or in other patients. As soon as what you have is out of the common path, you are on your own. I had to do my own research to figure out the cause of my symptoms and bring those to my doctors that agreed with…

It happens, I've seen a lot of doctors mess up. But they're still better equipped than you to discern medical fact from non fact during research. The sweet spot is a doctor that involves you in the decision making process, is transparent and intellectually honest. I've had doctors that admitted to me they didn't know what's wrong with me but gave me a list of probable options and a series of possible tests to undergo.

Re: Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

#34

I've bounced around a few companies, and all the smartest people I know are in the semiconductor industry. Some of them - self-proclaimed hardware engineers - would write better code than what I've seen come out of lifelong software devs. They have crazy deep, specialised knowledge on so many fields it boggles the mind. There's no real divide between startups and corporations in terms of talents from what I perceived…

Isn't the pay poor in the semiconductor industry?

Re: Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

#36

By pure IQ: The smartest people I know very likely work in pure maths at universities.

pure maths folks at the highest level seem like organic compute machines that sleep

Rényi declared "A mathematician is a machine for turning coffee into theorems."

Re: Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

#37

I've bounced around a few companies, and all the smartest people I know are in the semiconductor industry. Some of them - self-proclaimed hardware engineers - would write better code than what I've seen come out of lifelong software devs. They have crazy deep, specialised knowledge on so many fields it boggles the mind. There's no real divide between startups and corporations in terms of talents from what I perceived…

Isn't the pay poor in the semiconductor industry?

the very smartest may not always seek the highest paying jobs.

it is at least true in sweden that the highest earners are not necessarily the smartest: https://fortune.com/2023/02/17/smartest-not-paid-most-wages-...

(i think this was on the front page recently)

Re: Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

#39
The smartest people I knew in school didn't seem interested in regular web dev jobs (front end/back end), like that was too easy. A lot of them interned at FAANG doing that kind of stuff but didn't return.

The ones I know are now either at quant firms, doing PhDs in stuff like ML, or working but in some other niche area of software (for example graphics or robotics)

I've worked at a FAANG and there are pockets of interesting stuff (mainly the research orgs) but IMO the average SDE job is pretty boring/unsatisfying, its mostly just wiring services/libraries together, shuffling data around, and fiddling with infra/deployments.

Re: Ask HN: Where do the smartest people you know work?

#40
The smartest people I know work in government, education, and agriculture. Some in music and other arts. One at FAANG, but they might not be happy there.

Also depends on how you define smart. M-W dictionary says intelligent, which itself has many definitions. I'm currently biased towards considering healthspan, environmental health, and (related) health of society over the next millennia; what behaviors will help us humans know the story of life on earth more deeply and continuously? It's smart to consider the long-range narrative). For background, I only dabble in software development as a hobby and sometimes to make something for work (currently at a government entity for public infrastructure).

Post reply on HN