Live data from Hacker News

A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

hackaday.com

21–30 of 87 posts

Re: A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

#21

I could not find out how much a stone CNC milling machine costs. Does anyone know? It would be amazing to build a house with decorative elements like this. I've considered it for wood before -- but external carved stone would be amazing.

On Alibaba they starts from 40k USD. So I would bet the costs are at least $100k.

Plus these things basically require an extra building to house. But i guess people who are space poor should not build monasteries :)

Re: A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

#22
post #18
post #12

Having read Anathem recently, I'm disappointed that they aren't taking it upon themselves to learn how to do it by hand.

Exactly. The whole point of doing replica of something so old especially for religious reasons is the struggle. It doesnt matter how long it would take or hard it would be. It might never get finished and in this case that would be fine too. Instead this seems closer to concrete/plaster Disneyland for monks wanting to roleplay times long gone.

It is probably still a multi generational project.

Re: A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

#25

I was told we can't build like that anymore.

Shocker, the Bauhaus graduates didn’t want people thinking different. ;)

Brutalism is yet another form of socialism that managed to make the world a bit sadder.

Re: A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

#26

Where do monks get the money to build this beast?

The real question is "why"? And why would anybody think that's a good idea?

Because many people believe that making beautiful things is a way to praise their God. Hopefully they're entitled to spend their money the way they like.

Re: A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

#28
post #18
post #12

Having read Anathem recently, I'm disappointed that they aren't taking it upon themselves to learn how to do it by hand.

Exactly. The whole point of doing replica of something so old especially for religious reasons is the struggle. It doesnt matter how long it would take or hard it would be. It might never get finished and in this case that would be fine too. Instead this seems closer to concrete/plaster Disneyland for monks wanting to roleplay times long gone.

I don’t think that’s entirely true. Gothic architecture was the state of the art when it arrived on the scene, as were the building techniques involved. Sure, the labor involved dedication, perhaps it was penitential for some, but no one was maximizing for labor and exertion. Labor also cost money.

Re: A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

#29

I was told we can't build like that anymore.

Well, technically, at the scale to house urban populations - no, because a) it’s expensive b) the talent is super scarce c) it’s so much cheaper and easier to source concrete buildings

I’m sure one could source enough talent for few baroque villas or such but I have no idea what the budget would be.

Obvious example is Gaudi’s La Sagrada Familia - don’t know how much of that is ’traditional’ vs ’non-traditional’ though.

Re: A medieval Gothic monastery built using CAD / CAM

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shocker, the Bauhaus graduates didn’t want people thinking different. ;)

Brutalism is yet another form of socialism that managed to make the world a bit sadder.

Brutalism-as-an-aesthetic-choice is cool, as-mandated-dogma just god awful.
Post reply on HN