Live data from Hacker News

Review: A Dive into Mikrotik's Weird SmartNIC (2022)

alyx.sh

1–10 of 47 posts

Re: Review: A Dive into Mikrotik's Weird SmartNIC (2022)

#3
The only odd thing is the price:

Given it is the cheapest NIC in its class it should be a mass market product in high demand. The fact you get a free router built in is a cherry on top for the few who need it. If so why is it in such limited supply?

Alternatively it is a way to save rack space for people who need to squeeze in a router that doesn't fit. But if this is a niche marker router why is it so cheep?

Re: Review: A Dive into Mikrotik's Weird SmartNIC (2022)

#6
post #4

>suggest using it in a file server and a workstation, with a copper DAC in between What is dac in this context? I'm guessing it isn't digital analogue converter.

Direct Attach Cable, ie an end-to-end copper cable.

https://www.servethehome.com/what-is-a-direct-attach-copper-...

Re: Review: A Dive into Mikrotik's Weird SmartNIC (2022)

#7
post #4

>suggest using it in a file server and a workstation, with a copper DAC in between What is dac in this context? I'm guessing it isn't digital analogue converter.

Direct attached cables - vs. an optics module with fiber that you then plug into it, or an rj45 module you plug a cat 5/6/7 cable into.

Re: Review: A Dive into Mikrotik's Weird SmartNIC (2022)

#8
post #7
post #4

>suggest using it in a file server and a workstation, with a copper DAC in between What is dac in this context? I'm guessing it isn't digital analogue converter.

Direct attached cables - vs. an optics module with fiber that you then plug into it, or an rj45 module you plug a cat 5/6/7 cable into.

Ok, my only other guess was digital audio cable.

TLAs (three letter acronyms) are hard.

Re: Review: A Dive into Mikrotik's Weird SmartNIC (2022)

#9
post #3

The only odd thing is the price: Given it is the cheapest NIC in its class it should be a mass market product in high demand. The fact you get a free router built in is a cherry on top for the few who need it. If so why is it in such limited supply? Alternatively it is a way to save rack space for people who need to squeeze in a router that doesn't fit. But if this is a niche marker router why is it so cheep?

> why is it so cheap

Using a high volume Amazon chip. Sadly the software stack is not what this thing deserves. It's a full blown DPU used with something very minimalistic SW wise.

Re: Review: A Dive into Mikrotik's Weird SmartNIC (2022)

#10
post #8
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Direct attached cables - vs. an optics module with fiber that you then plug into it, or an rj45 module you plug a cat 5/6/7 cable into.

Ok, my only other guess was digital audio cable. TLAs (three letter acronyms) are hard.

In the network world context it's quite obvious and I guess that is what it is written for. For those not in that context I guess it's quite understandably confusing.
Post reply on HN