Live data from Hacker News

Playstation removing previously purchased Discovery content

playstation.com

21–30 of 182 posts

Re: Playstation removing previously purchased Discovery content

#21
post #4

With DRM you never purchase _content_. You only purchase a _license_ to access it. Words do matter. I sense possible legal grounds for reimbursments if it wasn't crystal clear to the layman.

Is this not also true with, say, a VHS tape? In what sense do you "own" it? You aren't legally allowed to copy it or whatever. It's still just a license.

Re: Playstation removing previously purchased Discovery content

#24
post #21
post #4

With DRM you never purchase _content_. You only purchase a _license_ to access it. Words do matter. I sense possible legal grounds for reimbursments if it wasn't crystal clear to the layman.

Is this not also true with, say, a VHS tape? In what sense do you "own" it? You aren't legally allowed to copy it or whatever. It's still just a license.

You're allowed to copy a VHS tape, you're just not allowed to distribute copies of VHS tapes.

You still own the physical tape itself, and you have a perpetual right to play, copy, and modify the tape as much as you like, for personal use.

Re: Playstation removing previously purchased Discovery content

#26
post #23
post #22

If you want to really own something, buy physical media. Simple as.

I just pirate. I'll stop when my rights are respected, promise.

I’ve heard many “pirates” say similar things, and when their condition is met, they find a new demand. Why would an IP rights-holder believe you?

Why not just buy physical media where available, and abstain where an acceptable legal option is not provided?

Re: Playstation removing previously purchased Discovery content

#28
post #26
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just pirate. I'll stop when my rights are respected, promise.

I’ve heard many “pirates” say similar things, and when their condition is met, they find a new demand. Why would an IP rights-holder believe you? Why not just buy physical media where available, and abstain where an acceptable legal option is not provided?

You misunderstand, I'm not trying to convince rights holders. I hope they go out of business, and I hope my piracy is what does it. It's just that, knowing myself, I know I wouldn't bother with the hassle of pirating if there were a better alternative, like I stopped pirating games and just buy them on Steam now.

Re: Playstation removing previously purchased Discovery content

#29
post #2

Piracy at it again.

This is not piracy. Piracy is duplicating content, this is theft. From what I was told by mafiaa, this should be punished harshly.

I think GP's sardonic point was that this sort of thing is more analogous to actual piracy than torrenting is -- people are actually being deprived of things they purchased here.

Re: Playstation removing previously purchased Discovery content

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can very well choose different platforms. That's the entire reason I don't buy iPhones or consoles. You don't need EU mommy to regulate the entire industry and make it harder for the next ios / android alternative

You can definitely live like a hermit, but the problem is that more and more things don't have open alternatives. > make it harder for the next ios / android alternative If the regulation prevents an alternative from being malicious I see that as a good thing?

> You can definitely live like a hermit, but the problem is that more and more things don't have open alternatives.

This site is called "Hacker News", and not "Technology Hipster News". Since you likely are a hacker, you should have a pretty good idea what to do ... :-)

Post reply on HN