Live data from Hacker News

Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?

gizmodo.com

1–10 of 119 posts

Re: Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?

#4
Reading through the several answers, it seems like the TL;DR is

1. Maybe there is toxic material IDK who wants to touch that instead of some rock

2. The industry actors who would do it only regard landfills as shiny metal reserves, and don't want/can't get the other materials one might extract from it, raising cost floor

Re: Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?

#6
post #2

Some day once we strip the entire planet of its accessible natural resources and turn it into trash the landfills will be the only place left to scrounge for rare materials.

If mining landfills was profitable, recycling would be profitable even before that.

Re: Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?

#7
I've wondered why they haven't implemented a compromise between recycling and tossing, which would just be segregating certain materials for later sale or recycling. If they put all the plastic bottles in one section of landfill, all the glass, etc it would be a bet toward there someday being a change in technology, materials science, or market prices that might make it worth mining. It would also be cheaper because the same trucks could pick it up (some cities have this, put your recyclables in a blue bag and throw them in the regular trash). One of the asinine things about recycling (to me) is that they have another has guzzling truck. There should be better accounting done on recycling so we can eliminate feel-good practices and only do things that actually help the environment. Sorting trash (at the landfill) would be a great step forward for this.

Re: Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?

#8
post #2

Some day once we strip the entire planet of its accessible natural resources and turn it into trash the landfills will be the only place left to scrounge for rare materials.

If mining landfills was profitable, recycling would be profitable even before that.

I thought recycling was sometimes profitable? At least for metals

Re: Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?

#9
Some years ago, Switzerland completely stopped using landfills. All garbage is incinerated. The resulting slag is then processed to reclaim nearly all metals as well as some other important elements.

Of course, the burning creates CO2. However, you don't have to mine and refine metal ores, and the incinerators also generate electricity and district heating. So the ecological balance is actually pretty good.

As a final bonus, you don't have literal square miles of landfills that occupy land and eventually will leak lovely chemicals into groundwater. The slag is far less problematic, and there is a lot less of it to deal with.

Post reply on HN