Live data from Hacker News

Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

theverge.com

91–100 of 985 posts

Re: Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

#91

The fact that these people aren't currently willing to "rewind the clock" about a week shows the dangers of human ego. Nothing permanent has been done that can't be undone fairly simply, if all parties agree to undo it. What we're watching now is the effect of ego momentum on decision making. Try it. It's not a crazy idea. Put everything back the way it was a week ago and then agree to move forward. It will be like h…

[deleted]

Re: Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it even possible for that to happen? The entity that governs OpenAI is a registered charity with a well defined purpose, it would seem odd for it to be able to just say "Actually, screw our mission let's just sell everything valuable to this for-profit company". A big part of being a 501(c)(3) is being tax exempt, difficult to see the IRS being ok with this. Even if they were the anti-trust implications are huge,…

they already signed it over when their for-profit subsidiary made a deal with Microsoft

[deleted]

Re: Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

#93

Amir Efrati (TheInformation): > More than 92% of OpenAI employees say they will join Altman at Microsoft if board doesnt capitulate. Signees include cofounders Karpathy, Schulman, Zaremba. https://twitter.com/amir/status/1726680254029418972

Wow. That would be delicious for Microsoft...

Re: Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

#94

Isn't Microsoft essentially acquiring OpenAI at almost zero cost? You have IP rights to OpenAI's work, and you will have almost all the brains from OpenAI, and there is no regulatory scrutiny like Activision acquisition.

All the WSJ article claimed was that MSFT had access to OpenAI code and weights. Chances are they don't actually have the right to fork GPT-X.

Re: Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

#95

The fact that these people aren't currently willing to "rewind the clock" about a week shows the dangers of human ego. Nothing permanent has been done that can't be undone fairly simply, if all parties agree to undo it. What we're watching now is the effect of ego momentum on decision making. Try it. It's not a crazy idea. Put everything back the way it was a week ago and then agree to move forward. It will be like h…

Small amount of residual consequences? The employees are asking for the board to resign. So their jobs are literally on the line. That's not really a small consequence for most people.

They are utterly delusional if they think they will be board members of OpenAI in the future unless they plan to ride it down the drain and if they do that they are in very, very hot water.

Re: Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

#97

I'm very unclear on how board members can remove other board members. If Sam, Greg and Ilya are on the same "team" now that's 3.... vs. 3. What's the mechanism at use here for board removal and how quickly does it happen? And who elects the board members. This is silly.

After removing Sam and Greg, there are four remaining. This means no matter what Ilya does, the other three can vote him out, which is why the board removed Mira, stalled on bringing Sam back, etc, since Ilya's vote does not matter anymore. Only if you can move two people over to the other side will you have 3 vs 1, and could bring Sam and Greg back. This Microsoft deal could just be another Satya card, and means: 1.…

There are three of them, and Ilya...

Re: Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO

#100
post #87
post #64

This whole thing is bizarre. OpenAI was the one company I was sure would be fine for the forseeable future!

The amount of money and power their products might offer makes it pretty desirable. Theoretically there should be no limit to the amount and type of shenanigans that are possible in this particular situation.

That's fair lol
Post reply on HN