Live data from Hacker News

Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

arstechnica.com

141–150 of 195 posts

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#141

I loved this when he posted it. Taking this a step further, and being facetious, I'm thinking of starting my own network! It's all me, all the time. Sometimes I'll be a nature show, sometimes I'll be in a spy movie, sometimes I'll have the guys from Mystery Science Theater 3000 cracking jokes at how dumb I am. Can't be that hard to do what this guy did, only in twenty-four different genres, one for each hour of the d…

[deleted]

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#142
Voices are not copyrighted and do not require "authorization". If my nephew wants to go around sounding like Goofy all the time (as he does) he is free to do so, though it may cost him invitations to dinner - it'd be the same if he was using Attenborough's voice.

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe Tom Hanks already had some one deep fake him into endorsing some medicare scam product. I'd be more worried about that than the unsavory narration which most people probably would assume was fake.

Teaching people to distrust celebrity endorsements wouldn't be the worst outcome.

There are millions of years of evolution conditioning humans to trust things that are familiar. It's naive to think we'll adapt effectively and quickly to extreme manipulation.

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#145

When I see a lot of this voice replication I am reminded of something. (Dune series spoiler) For example, Duncan Idaho keeps being brought back with cloning tech, over and over, for centuries, because Leto II just likes him. Over and over, the same man keeps being put by the (nearly) immortal emperor's side... I ask: are we stuck as a monoculture, not making new, interesting things, but simply replicating older ones?…

Duncan got significantly upgraded from time to time. Sometimes as a mentat. Or as a sex machine.

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is it different than someone making a funny video where they impersonate David Attenborough? Those aren’t generally considered disrespectful, right? Like, I get the potential scale is different. But this is some joke video, not someone trying to actually replace David Attenborough or something.

I agree and the difference is commercial rights and intent. Parody, jokes, etc are fine. Using this to replace him on a documentary, not okay. Fair use already covers this all they have to do is extend copyright protections to peoples likeness and voices

> copyright protections to peoples likeness and voices

What happens when you look or sound like someone (more) famous though?

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#147
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, their creation is held behind legal walls in order to create, by definition, an artifical scarcity from which it derives its monetary value. If it was not protected by such a wall, and was not scarce, it would have no monetary value. No, I don't think the inherent value in their talent is artificial, but I _do_ think that the monetary system we've built around such things as a necessity to survive in our modern…

>Sure, their creation is held behind legal walls in order to create, by definition, an artifical scarcity from which it derives its monetary value. If it was not protected by such a wall, and was not scarce, it would have no monetary value. That's... not artificial scarcity. By definition (and using your own words) it is actual scarcity. A person's performance -- which is more than just their voice reading lines -- i…

> It's literally limited by the hours in the day

If a textbook isn't available because it's still being written by the author, then true, that's the real scarcity of the author's time. But if a textbook is finished but isn't available because effort is put into preventing the information from being freely shared, then that's artificial scarcity.

Restricting access subject to payment is currently the most common method for extracting profit to incentivize creation, but it's not the only method and for digital goods it's incredibly inefficient.

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#148
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you tried to get a GPT to write a joke? It’s got a ways to go.

I read this recently. I can't vouch for the source and I haven't researched it. https://time.com/6301288/the-ai-jokes-that-give-me-nightmare...

That article is pretty incredible.

The movie industry is going to be a wild ride over the next few years.

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#149
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Sure, their creation is held behind legal walls in order to create, by definition, an artifical scarcity from which it derives its monetary value. If it was not protected by such a wall, and was not scarce, it would have no monetary value. That's... not artificial scarcity. By definition (and using your own words) it is actual scarcity. A person's performance -- which is more than just their voice reading lines -- i…

> It's literally limited by the hours in the day If a textbook isn't available because it's still being written by the author, then true, that's the real scarcity of the author's time. But if a textbook is finished but isn't available because effort is put into preventing the information from being freely shared, then that's artificial scarcity. Restricting access subject to payment is currently the most common metho…

None of that is relevant to this discussion. We are talking about someone who spent time growing a skill and is charging people who want him to use that skill for whatever they are hiring them for.

Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral

#150

When I see a lot of this voice replication I am reminded of something. (Dune series spoiler) For example, Duncan Idaho keeps being brought back with cloning tech, over and over, for centuries, because Leto II just likes him. Over and over, the same man keeps being put by the (nearly) immortal emperor's side... I ask: are we stuck as a monoculture, not making new, interesting things, but simply replicating older ones?…

This reminds me of something I noticed: disproportionately, the classics in a given field (ie, the work agreed upon to be particularly important, influential, etc) are disproportionately the ones that were made shortly after a new medium or technique was invented. For example, It's almost as if we default to tending towards imitation and recycling, and only each time a totally new technology changes what is possible…

Or just the earlier works have been forgotten. It tends to surprise people when I mention the 1939 Wizard of Oz movie (one of the first(?) to showcase color and still known for that because of the transition) was an adaptation of just the first book of an older series.
Post reply on HN