Earlier quoted context omitted.
This demonstration is respectful. It’s funny. It’s obvious parody. But, the tech can be used to make disrespectful content. Look forward to: David Attenborough narrates porn. I don’t know what we can do. Ain’t no easy answers. But do we want courts and $Lawyers deciding what is respectful?
I believe Tom Hanks already had some one deep fake him into endorsing some medicare scam product. I'd be more worried about that than the unsavory narration which most people probably would assume was fake.
Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
91–100 of 195 posts
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#92Earlier quoted context omitted.
I feel like the novelty will wear off sooner or later. I certainly got bored of doing "X but as Y" pretty fast.
I'm excited to see the first brand new content from an existing series. I really love the 80's cartoon Inspector Gadget. There are about 100 episodes and they are all pretty repetitive (so hopefully easy to train AI with). I would be enthralled if someone could create new episodes with: - AI generated storyline - Deepfake the original actors voices - Deepfake the animation, which should(?) be easier (more realistic)…
It's not even unique to AI really. The whole genre of games that depend on procedural generation are similar. Who cares if there are a thousand planets in Starfield if they're all just the output of RNG? There's no actual handicraft involved to set one environment apart from another. There's more music on Spotify than anyone could listen to in a lifetime; it just makes it harder to find new stuff that is actually good or else you stick to what you know.
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#93When I see a lot of this voice replication I am reminded of something. (Dune series spoiler) For example, Duncan Idaho keeps being brought back with cloning tech, over and over, for centuries, because Leto II just likes him. Over and over, the same man keeps being put by the (nearly) immortal emperor's side... I ask: are we stuck as a monoculture, not making new, interesting things, but simply replicating older ones?…
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#94I think I'll be using a Christopher Walken clone as my documentary narrator.
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#95When I see a lot of this voice replication I am reminded of something. (Dune series spoiler) For example, Duncan Idaho keeps being brought back with cloning tech, over and over, for centuries, because Leto II just likes him. Over and over, the same man keeps being put by the (nearly) immortal emperor's side... I ask: are we stuck as a monoculture, not making new, interesting things, but simply replicating older ones?…
I like the stories of unique art/music that was created because someone was trying to clone something exactly... but despite their best effort, they just couldn't get it right and ended inventing something new that people loved anyway.
We just have to make sure we are pretty bad at the cloning!
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#96Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#97When I see a lot of this voice replication I am reminded of something. (Dune series spoiler) For example, Duncan Idaho keeps being brought back with cloning tech, over and over, for centuries, because Leto II just likes him. Over and over, the same man keeps being put by the (nearly) immortal emperor's side... I ask: are we stuck as a monoculture, not making new, interesting things, but simply replicating older ones?…
Mark Fisher didn't create this word, but he wrote a lot in the 2000s about our inability to imagine a new future after the failure of our previous visions.
Using electronic music - a "future-looking" genre - as an example, he wrote (second paragraph explains it more generally):
"...Twenty-first-century electronic music had failed to progress beyond what had been recorded in the twentieth century: practically anything produced in the 2000s could have been recorded in the 1990s. Electronic music had succumbed to its own inertia and retrospection. It was also clear that this was more than a moment in a familiar pattern, in which, as one genre wanes, another emerges to take its place at the leading edge of innovation. There was no leading edge of innovation any more. In music, as elsewhere in culture, we were living, in Franco Berardi’s suggestive phrase, after the future.
...
What haunts the digital cul-de-sacs of the twenty-first century is not so much the past as all the lost futures that the twentieth century taught us to anticipate. The futures that have been lost were more than a matter of musical style. More broadly, and more troublingly, the disappearance of the future meant the deterioration of a whole mode of social imagination: the capacity to conceive of a world radically different from the one in which we currently live. It meant the acceptance of a situation in which culture would continue without really changing, and where politics was reduced to the administration of an already established (capitalist) system. In other words, we were in the "end of history" described by Francis Fukuyama. Fukuyama’s thesis was the other side of Fredric Jameson’s claim that postmodernism — characterized by its inability to find forms adequate to the present, still less to anticipate wholly new futures — was the "cultural logic of late capitalism.""
I don't know if I completely buy it or if it was Mark's (and other's) inability to cope with their ideals for the future not panning out. But it is interesting to think about, and I do see glimpses of it in most art forms. I don't know enough history to know how common this repetition of, and nostalgia for, the past is though. Perhaps a flurry of imaginings of a "new future" was the anomaly.
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#98Earlier quoted context omitted.
I'm excited to see the first brand new content from an existing series. I really love the 80's cartoon Inspector Gadget. There are about 100 episodes and they are all pretty repetitive (so hopefully easy to train AI with). I would be enthralled if someone could create new episodes with: - AI generated storyline - Deepfake the original actors voices - Deepfake the animation, which should(?) be easier (more realistic)…
I'd actually find that quite disappointing. If you can generate practically infinite variations of a show using AI, it completely eliminates scarcity and makes the result meaningless. It's not even unique to AI really. The whole genre of games that depend on procedural generation are similar. Who cares if there are a thousand planets in Starfield if they're all just the output of RNG? There's no actual handicraft inv…
one of the reasons I don't like modern animation is the lack of effort in the actual animating. South Park looks like it was drawn by 5-year-olds who traced the outline of a salt shaker for the characters. Inb4 "it's supposed to be that way, it's all computer assisted and has been for 20 years", yes I know that. The point is there's no art involved in it. 80's and 90's stuff was hand drawn (AFAIK) and often outsourced to animators in Japan, and yeah it's primitive, but its literally handicraft. The only scarcity of shows like southpark is people with squeaky annoying voices. Even the writing is so repetitive and predictable. It was novel and funny in the 90's-early 2000's, but "kid saying adult thing in exuberant voice" is tired and old. Simpsons were doing it in 1989 ffs.
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#99One area where this kind of technique would be a game changer, I imagine, is for blind people to have their surroundings narrated in real time. For example, through a pair of glasses with a camera for input, and an earphone to listen to the continuous narration. I heard about an online service where people can sign up to help the blind by describing visual scenes that they capture on their mobile. There must be compa…
Re: Unauthorized "David Attenborough" AI clone narrates developer's life, goes viral
#100Earlier quoted context omitted.
I'm not sure that's true. Look at the printing press. Sure, Shakespeare is a classic, but most of the rest of what we read as "classics" probably centers around the mid-1800s (at least in English-speaking countries)
Yes, that's exactly some of the time periods I was thinking of. The mid 1800s was a time when literacy was rapidly increasing and new serial magazines became popular. This new medium paved the way for the fame of authors like Dickens and Bronte, the sort you may be thinking of.
If anything this claim merely shows the effect of “time compression” in which distant events feel like they happened around the same time.