Live data from Hacker News

Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

arstechnica.com

11–20 of 87 posts

Re: Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

#12
post #8

I wonder if this is just due to something internal at Google or if there has been some more global change that has made them uninterested in continuing this? Normally I'd guess the former given Google's legendary propensity for getting rid of services, but a couple months ago Amazon did something similar [1] which makes me wonder if the two are connected somehow: > Effective September 4, 2023, Amazon is no longer sel…

I think it's just a coincidence. The Kindle team has been gutted with job losses so almost everything non-core is being cut.

This magazine business just never made anyone any money, so it's an obvious thing to cut.

Re: Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

#13
Much like the phrase around crypto about "not your keys? not your crypto" goes, similar applies to all digital things: Not your local content? not your content"

Things like Kindle Unlimited (which at least say they're subscriptions to content access) digital streaming and so many other services that let you "buy" things that you don't keep on your own device in your own chosen format are all bullshit waiting to happen if you like to really own your digital stuff. Same for Google's News service. At least in this case Google offered downloadable PDFs for some editions.

That so many people fall for this only to be later surprised is almost laughable. What should anyone assume less from so many companies that take hostility to users as nearly a default position?

Re: Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

#14
post #9

Guess the last member of whatever team implemented magazine subscription just got promoted out of that team.

s/promoted/laid off/ https://www.cnbc.com/2023/10/18/google-cuts-dozens-of-jobs-i...

Hahaha... laughed so hard... even for Google this is pretty comical.

> The company has been downsizing in recent months to reckon with slowing growth and uncertain economic conditions.

What happened to becoming better through overcoming problems? "Slowing growth" and "Uncertain economic conditions" means now "Close down immediately".

> The cuts at Google News come as big online platforms are pressured to provide the public with accurate information on the Israel-Hamas conflict and Russia’s war in Ukraine.

I guess at the scale of Google it is easier to completely close down your news arm than try to provide accurate information or admit you have problem with producing truth?

Re: Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

#16
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

s/promoted/laid off/ https://www.cnbc.com/2023/10/18/google-cuts-dozens-of-jobs-i...

Hahaha... laughed so hard... even for Google this is pretty comical. > The company has been downsizing in recent months to reckon with slowing growth and uncertain economic conditions. What happened to becoming better through overcoming problems? "Slowing growth" and "Uncertain economic conditions" means now "Close down immediately". > The cuts at Google News come as big online platforms are pressured to provide the…

Nobody should be expecting accurate information on either conflict. Sometimes accurate information is hard to come by.

I'm not sure the problem is that platforms are being "pressured to provide the public with accurate information", though. I would guess there's far more pressure to provide information that favors certain viewpoints, whether that information is accurate or not.

Re: Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

#17
post #6

[flagged]

I'm 99% sure that they won't come to collect my trusty Pixel 3a any time soon :)

They did disable bootloader unlocking on my pixel 2, so while I still have it, it's basically e-waste now.

Re: Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hahaha... laughed so hard... even for Google this is pretty comical. > The company has been downsizing in recent months to reckon with slowing growth and uncertain economic conditions. What happened to becoming better through overcoming problems? "Slowing growth" and "Uncertain economic conditions" means now "Close down immediately". > The cuts at Google News come as big online platforms are pressured to provide the…

Nobody should be expecting accurate information on either conflict. Sometimes accurate information is hard to come by. I'm not sure the problem is that platforms are being "pressured to provide the public with accurate information", though. I would guess there's far more pressure to provide information that favors certain viewpoints, whether that information is accurate or not.

I think people should expect accurate information.

Kinda the same as with justice. We know justice is served by people in nice togas and juries of peers who are really a nice name for your neighbours. And yet we still demand and hopefully will continue to demand justice, even if those people make mistakes or sometimes behave fraudulently.

The problem with Israeli-Hamas conflict isn't that the accurate information isn't available. It is that too many people decided to side with either belligerent and are selectively accepting information. It is that both sides of the conflict decided to use misinformation to bolster their media presence and their right to defend themselves. It is that the people who have open and measured view of the situation are not feeling safe expressing their views and feel pressured to support either side or shut up.

I am personally suspicious of radical opinions, but I feel no way to express any support to more moderate and rational opinions without exposing myself as target for both sides.

This problem in turn is result of some more general socio-politic changes, poor education and capture of media by organisations who discovered it is better to serve extreme views on any matter because it lets them steal more of the focus of consumers by exploiting our natural biases.

Because of the polarisation, you have to choose a lesser evil. If you don't like "trumpism", you have to side with "radical left". If you don't like "radical left", you have to side with "trumpism". This is how masses of people can be captured by extreme views, which should not be the norm, in my opinion.

Re: Google News is shutting down purchased magazine content, offering refunds

#20
post #8

I wonder if this is just due to something internal at Google or if there has been some more global change that has made them uninterested in continuing this? Normally I'd guess the former given Google's legendary propensity for getting rid of services, but a couple months ago Amazon did something similar [1] which makes me wonder if the two are connected somehow: > Effective September 4, 2023, Amazon is no longer sel…

Something happened. There are a lot of consolidations in the industry, and as content contracts expire and get renegotiated this happens. On September 21:

We regret to inform you that the magazine(s) you received through ZINIO will no longer be available. Please find below a voucher with a value equal to the remaining balance of issues for your subscription(s) to use in a special selection we have created for you based on your interests.

This was in regard to The Economist, which is now available on Pressreader and happens to be free from my Library. So for me cost wise, this is awesome.

Post reply on HN