Live data from Hacker News

I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

youtube.com

121–130 of 456 posts

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am not related to her in any way other than being her subscriber on YouTube, yet my nickname is attached to the HackerNews submission, and with current title I expect that somebody will eventually think that I am she, or that I pretend to be her.

email hn@ycombinator.com and ask dang to change it back, and tell him that reason.

[deleted]

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#122
post #101

Love the iteration story, but like, what about pants? And thick winter coats? And stuff I don't want a weird potential fold line slightly to the left/right of centre? Her example rack only contains the clothes that would be perfect for this. My rack and hangers accommodate all my needs with one simple cheap design.

I normally fold my pants in half vertically and over the hanger. How do you normally do this? Some examples here, most of which should work with her hanger size: https://www.wikihow.com/Hang-Pants

For others' reference: the "one leg over, then the other leg over the other way" is how you hang a bespoke suit's pants. No special hanger needed, the cloth's opposite drag provides enough friction to keep it on. The hangar for the cuffed pants is good for keeping the cuffs in shape (but who wears cuffs?)

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#123

Love the iteration story, but like, what about pants? And thick winter coats? And stuff I don't want a weird potential fold line slightly to the left/right of centre? Her example rack only contains the clothes that would be perfect for this. My rack and hangers accommodate all my needs with one simple cheap design.

in the video on the Kickstarter she show how you can hang pants

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#124
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the very first sentence she says in her video is "I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger". is there something about the title that bothers you? I get when someone complains that a title is misleading, but I don't understand the commentary when the meaning is basically the same and the person commenting didn't even seem to have watched the first 3 seconds of the video.

I am not related to her in any way other than being her subscriber on YouTube, yet my nickname is attached to the HackerNews submission, and with current title I expect that somebody will eventually think that I am she, or that I pretend to be her.

You're totally right. I really dislike the way mods edit titles here...

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#125
post #4

Does anyone know her cancer situation? It almost bummed me out that she got sick as soon as she became popular.

She mentioned it briefly in a few of her tesla videos, she did apparently go through chemo but that was 4 years ago and I don't see it in a more recent one so I'm guessing she's in remission?

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#126

I forgot who she was, so: > Giertz has previously branded herself as "the queen of shitty robots" on her YouTube channel, where she employs deadpan humor to demonstrate mechanical robots of her own creation to automate everyday tasks; despite working from a purely mechanical standpoint, they often fall short of practical usefulness, for comic effect.[9] Giertz's creations have included an alarm clock that slaps the u…

She has tried (and quite successfully imho) to move away from that image and become a respectable creator/inventor. I think the highlights of her maker-career is Truckla, her Tesla she repurposed as a truck and drove to the cyber truck reveal. And her everyday calendar, which is a board of 365 LED and you can click each for everyday you complete whatever your everyday goal is and end the year with a lot board. As I r…

I'm sure the success was partly due to the fact that the "shittiness" of the robots was because they were iterative prototypes, not because she was inept. Part of what's great about her (and other similar creators') content is that you get to actually see the design and development process, including the failures, which is both entertaining and educational.

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#127
post #116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I’m aware you left yourself a bit of wriggle room versus the absolute claim. Doesn’t change how it sounds. No. What happened here is you interpreted it as a insult to your pride. That did not occur. What occurred was a statement of a fact. It was you're own pride and bias that changed how it sounded. >You know how they say the execution matters, not just the idea? So. What's your point? Everybody knows this. Why are…

> No. What happened here is you interpreted it as an insult to your pride. You see, the thing is, I’m not even incidentally or partially Chinese. I just really despise the Western pride and xenophobic judgement people like you cast! I don’t know how you claim to be neutral, but I’m definitely not attempting to be neutral. Anyways, I’m also gonna end my argument here. I see no value.

I'm Chinese by race. A US citizen by birth. As such I hold no pride for either country.

How can I be xenophobic against my own race? Additionally how can I be xenophobic against people in my own country who I grew up with?

You don't realize the extent of true neutrality. I see what is now. You're not all about patriotism or pride. You're on the side of idealized fairness. Where all things are unrealistically equal.

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#128
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But I'm sure she's patented it and amazon wouldn't want to get caught for intellectual property theft so will be diligent about policing sellers. They wouldn't want a bad reputation. And the customs office will destroy any imported product in violation of her patents.

You cannot patent a foldable coat hanger. The only thing she could patent is the specific mechanism she used to enable folding, but I doubt the copycats would use exactly the same design.

Technically, they could patent every variant that was in her bin, which would at least present some challenge to a knock off.

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#129

Pull out retractable closet rod. https://www.amazon.ca/Retractable-Adjustable-Wardrobe-Clothi... Mount under shelf. Use high quality hanger that doesn't damage or crease. No extra folding action. Put nice article of clothing in front and looks very nice. Turning storage 90 degrees for shallow storage solves more problems than folding clothes in half. Having seen tons of these in show rooms, I dare say it's a long sol…

Much goofier looking though.

There are nice looking high end options and plastic aliexpress versions. And everything in between. Bonus, the design works for pants or textiles since it does everything normal hanger does. These "space saving" solutions have been thought through for decades. I like the aesthetic of her design, but it kind of fails at being a good versatile hanger. Seems like it's good for storing a few articles of frequently used clothing where one doesn't need to consider long term creasing, basically a slight upgrade from a few nails on the wall.

Re: I spent 3 years working on a coat hanger [video]

#130

Pull out retractable closet rod. https://www.amazon.ca/Retractable-Adjustable-Wardrobe-Clothi... Mount under shelf. Use high quality hanger that doesn't damage or crease. No extra folding action. Put nice article of clothing in front and looks very nice. Turning storage 90 degrees for shallow storage solves more problems than folding clothes in half. Having seen tons of these in show rooms, I dare say it's a long sol…

Or also just coat hangers that have a rotating top (most with a wooden body and a metal top have that). There were also some really viable solutions displayed on the Google image search that were just glossed over.

The way it's presented in the video it does look really nice, but having to pair it with one of their rods is kind of limiting.

Post reply on HN