Live data from Hacker News

Are People Finally Getting Bored with the Tech-Blog Circle Jerk?

blogs.sfweekly.com

71–74 of 74 posts

Re: Are People Finally Getting Bored with the Tech-Blog Circle Jerk?

#71
post #38

I always saw Silicon Valley inevitably being covered and cared about as much as the Hollywood insidery cabal of power and influence. As much as we believe in the ideas, teams, executions, it's still very much an old boys network. Don't fool yourself otherwise. The community upturns its nose constantly about gossip or fluff. But you don't get it, that's all there really is. Gossip and fluff. Tech reporting is as dry a…

In the tech industry we definitely make celebrities of the wrong people. I can't recall a single other industry where journalists are the top-tier talent attraction, and I can't explain why that is. The closest in influence is perhaps the top editors in fashion - but otherwise we are in a league of our own (I have seen small-time contributors to Techcrunch get mobbed at tech events). I have watched new tech bloggers…

"I can't recall a single other industry where journalists are the top-tier talent attraction"

Back in the last bubble analysts like (the disgraced) Henry Blodget and Mary Meeker just to name two got plenty of celebrity.

Added: Ok they weren't journalists (Blodget is now) but it was similar in that they became part of the dot com success story by creating it.

Re: Are People Finally Getting Bored with the Tech-Blog Circle Jerk?

#72
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the tech industry we definitely make celebrities of the wrong people. I can't recall a single other industry where journalists are the top-tier talent attraction, and I can't explain why that is. The closest in influence is perhaps the top editors in fashion - but otherwise we are in a league of our own (I have seen small-time contributors to Techcrunch get mobbed at tech events). I have watched new tech bloggers…

I think you mean "tech journalism industry" maybe? My perception from back when i was reading lots of tech blogs is that tech journalists are just not good journalists, almost all of them (I can't think of an exceptional case, no offense intended). They almost never do real world research, just rely on google, big newspapers, press releases, the random dude who calls to promote his new website and lately on HN / redd…

Yes, I did mean the tech journalism industry

I have found that more recently some of the most interesting writing has been done by part-timers on their personal blogs. Security and privacy investigations, analysis of markets and startups. HN is a good way of aggregating the best of those posts.

Re: Are People Finally Getting Bored with the Tech-Blog Circle Jerk?

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In other words, hate the game not the playa.

Yeah man, respect the playa and keep Black Rock City weird.

I was making a point not a joke, but I guess it went over peoples heads.
Post reply on HN