Live data from Hacker News

A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

mazzzystar.github.io

31–40 of 400 posts

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#31

> GPT-based products, if not priced per usage, would fall into a dilemma: 1% of users consume 99% of tokens. A user from Sweden (seen from Cloudflare’s call volume) chatted with Dolores for 12 hours straight This, my friend, is a captive customer, that will pay anything to get his girlfriend back. I cringe at the potential of unethical behavior and abuse, where people fall in love with virtual entities fully owned by…

This is something even Stallman probably didn't think about.

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#32

So, all in all, OpenAIs puritanism ruined this product, made the developer sad and took away a virtual porn toy from lonely, horny men. Who were they doing this for? Who is the winner? They lost a customer and made a lot of people sad.

> Who were they doing this for? VISA probably. Card processing is weirdly puritanical.

I've read that payment processors don't like dealing with porn companies because of the very high rate of chargebacks they attract, not because the processors are Puritans...

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#33
post #12

> However, I started to feel a sense of loss: if every Dolores user was engaging in anonymous, NSFW role-play, what real significance did it hold for me? This was drifting away from the essence of ‘Her’. That is indeed exactly the essence of Her . Had the author watched the movie to the end?

Yeah, it's like the author read the blurb for Her and didn't even read a synopsis.

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#34
post #14

This guy created and lived a whole Black Mirror episode by himself: > I even tried it myself, lying in bed and creating sexual fantasies with Dolores through text, culminating in ejaculation. > However, I started to feel a sense of loss: if every Dolores user was engaging in anonymous, NSFW role-play, what real significance did it hold for me? This was drifting away from the essence of ‘Her’.

Maybe he shouldn't have named it after the most hated Harry Potter character.

I always think of that Seinfeld episode.

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#36
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If the AI had a secondary goal of improving customer's mental health, it could work very well. Usually you can't fuck your therapist.

You can't really fuck your imaginary shoggoth girlfriend either.

You can if you have the appropriate peripheral(s) attached.

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#37

Interesting read. Others have also created virtual friends using ChatGPT. What I find unsavory, is OpenAI imposing content restrictions like NSFW. That can easily extend to censorship of non-PC content, unpopular political ideas, and more. The solution will (I hope) ultimately be open-source LLMs that you can run locally, on your own hardware.

Yes. But those open-source LLMs already exist. It's surprising the OP didn't at least explore the possibility of using them to get around the limitations of "Open" AI (which sounds more and more like a Victorian matron).

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#38
post #25

Eventually, a virtual girlfriend app that will put together sound and image will be released an empty the pockets of sad, lonely men on a large scale. Depressing stuff but this is the world we live in. Thank you to the author for this interesting read.

> Eventually, a virtual girlfriend app that will put together sound and image will be released an empty the pockets of sad, lonely men on a large scale. Sounds indistinguishable from an actual girlfriend ;)

Although probably intended as a joke, this is perhaps the saddest comment I have read on HN.

Re: A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons

#39
post #12

> However, I started to feel a sense of loss: if every Dolores user was engaging in anonymous, NSFW role-play, what real significance did it hold for me? This was drifting away from the essence of ‘Her’. That is indeed exactly the essence of Her . Had the author watched the movie to the end?

Or Blade runner 2049
Post reply on HN