Questions:
- Can you do analysis of video captured from Trace cameras?
- Any roadmap for exporting the data for both team and player?
Soccer video analysis from your match videos
31–39 of 39 posts
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#32This is not a valid Show HN - you have to have something more than a signup list for people to try out. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html . I appreciate that you have a demo of the project working on one video, but the title claims that people can try it on their own, and for that the web page seems to just be collecting signups. Most likely it would be best to do a Show HN once it's working in a fo…
I'm so sorry for this, it was my bad. On the website, there is a link to the demo people can try but it is not exactly the link I posted.
This is the link: https://futvis.streamlit.app/. Sorry for not having it accessible to anyone. Unfortunately, it is a button inside the website and I misunderstood the rules.
Again, I apologize for this inconvenience.
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#33Questions: - Can you do analysis of video captured from Trace cameras? - Any roadmap for exporting the data for both team and player?
By now, we're only capable of processing videos with consistent camera angle throughout the video, I believe trace cameras change based on players' positions, right?
I'm interested in adjusting our systems and make it work with trace cameras.
If you want send me a message and we can work to generate some data from your video. It'll help me a lot to improve Futvis.
futvissoftware@gmail.com
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#34This is awesome. Would love access for my daughter's soccer team.
Great, thanks! To have access just fill out this form: * https://forms.gle/U8UeeTwrWiMjiUzZA I'll send you some requirements for the video. I'm providing soccer video analysis at no cost in exchange for feedback.
Ah bummer. Just got this reply...
"To kick things off, all you need to do is share a link to your video on Google Drive, OneDrive, or YouTube, and we'll promptly create a personalized analysis for you at no cost. In return, we kindly ask for your constructive feedback to help us enhance the Futvis experience."
We work with little ones and cannot just send over videos without their parents' consent.
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#35This is great, and I hope people enjoy it, I tried to do something similar years ago commercially, and so I'll ask: please make sure you keep it as a passion project - turning this into a money spinner could lead to disappointment. I was on the winning team for what I believe was the EPL's first and only hackathon at Manchester City back in 2016 or thereabouts. It was a while back. That hackathon used a couple of dat…
> Because of - when you think about it, kinda obvious - timing issues that can mean at 25fps you have 40ms latency/slippage frame to frame, the data suggested the ball was kicked in one game, by Yaya Toure into the back of the opposing team's net at just over 1000m/s - a little over Mach 3.
This error seems too big to have come from the inherent latency of 25 fps.
1000 m/s over the shortest period, a single frame, would be 40 metres in 0.04 seconds. If there was one frame's worth of error on each end, then the lowest speed the real value could be was 40 metres in 0.12 seconds which is still a completely impossible 330 metres per second.
Am I missing something? 25 fps seems like enough to capture the ball location to within a metre for all but the hardest shots.
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#36Earlier quoted context omitted.
Great, thanks! To have access just fill out this form: * https://forms.gle/U8UeeTwrWiMjiUzZA I'll send you some requirements for the video. I'm providing soccer video analysis at no cost in exchange for feedback.
Ah bummer. Just got this reply... "To kick things off, all you need to do is share a link to your video on Google Drive, OneDrive, or YouTube, and we'll promptly create a personalized analysis for you at no cost. In return, we kindly ask for your constructive feedback to help us enhance the Futvis experience." We work with little ones and cannot just send over videos without their parents' consent.
I understand. Since we're still in the process of building the platform, this is the only way to generate insights for you currently. However, in a few weeks, the platform will be completed, allowing you to use it on your own while maintaining ownership of your videos. I'll send you an email when it's done!
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#37There are a couple of other products in the market doing very similar things. Have you done any work on positioning or differentiation? There is space for different options for sure. I'd love to see if you can turn this into an affordable virtual offside system for smaller leagues.
I'm focusing on amateur leagues and amateur teams.
In fact, I'm an amateur player and I'm in a team that plays every single week. We collect the videos on our own and process them to have our analysis and make decisions. It's really low cost since we use our smartphones and don't need the analysis in real-time.
By now we're building a platform where you upload your videos and access your analysis, in contrast to others, we are not focusing on video recording.
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#38There are a couple of other products in the market doing very similar things. Have you done any work on positioning or differentiation? There is space for different options for sure. I'd love to see if you can turn this into an affordable virtual offside system for smaller leagues.
Also, don't forget referee tracking. Higher level referees work hard on being the right places at the right time, so having some data showing their position at KMI as well as some way to measure their ability to anticipate would be valuable.
Didn't think about this! Thanks for this idea! It sounds like it could be extremely useful for referees.
Re: Soccer video analysis from your match videos
#39This is not a valid Show HN - you have to have something more than a signup list for people to try out. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html . I appreciate that you have a demo of the project working on one video, but the title claims that people can try it on their own, and for that the web page seems to just be collecting signups. Most likely it would be best to do a Show HN once it's working in a fo…
I'm so sorry for this, it was my bad. On the website, there is a link to the demo people can try but it is not exactly the link I posted. This is the link: https://futvis.streamlit.app/ . Sorry for not having it accessible to anyone. Unfortunately, it is a button inside the website and I misunderstood the rules. Again, I apologize for this inconvenience.
It's ok! Once you have something that people can try on their own videos, you'd be welcome to do a Show HN about it. Good luck with your work!