Live data from Hacker News

Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

usatoday.com

121–130 of 138 posts

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For a highly trained astronaut that "oops" in the video seemed extremely careless.

Highly trained astronaut doesn't mean much. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Nowak Nobody's perfect and nobody is infallible and that includes highly trained astronauts. Short of this being done on purpose (hard to believe to begin with) I'd just chalk it up to an accident.

You're comparing an emotional breakdown to not securing a toolbox?

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#122
post #25

Anyone got a link to an official report detailing what happened? The article is kinda light on details, but I assume this is a major mishap that can only happen if multiple things go wrong simultaneously? Everything m they do up there is a precisely choreographed dance so it would be interesting to read a technical report on that.

Yes it's a bit light on details. But they do point out the most important facts, namely what gender the astronauts are and that it has not been officially confirmed whether the tool box contained a 10mm wrench. Personally, that's everything I needed to know about the situation.

Was the wrench for conventional or opposite-threaded 10 mm nuts?

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#123

Military officers, brilliant scientists, physically fit and operating in perhaps the most demanding environment we've asked of the human body... and all anyone remembers is they dropped the spanner.

Beats combing the desert.

Did they find anything?

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#124

> "The white, satchel-like tool bag slipped away from two astronauts during a rare, all-female spacewalk." Could have left that in drafts

So could have the NY times couple of years ago with > Why NASA's First All-Women Spacewalk Made History And we have articles in space.com just a week ago >Watch 2 NASA astronauts conduct 4th-ever all-female spacewalk today If all female walks are news, then fuck ups during all female space walks are also news worth pointing.

I sort of agree, if it was merely matter of fact

This doesn't read like that though

It reads like “looll some women did something incompetent! get a load of this guys”

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Highly trained astronaut doesn't mean much. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Nowak Nobody's perfect and nobody is infallible and that includes highly trained astronauts. Short of this being done on purpose (hard to believe to begin with) I'd just chalk it up to an accident.

You're comparing an emotional breakdown to not securing a toolbox?

No, I'm trying to illustrate - apparently unsuccessfully - that astronauts are people and as fallible as everybody else.

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Highly trained astronaut doesn't mean much. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Nowak Nobody's perfect and nobody is infallible and that includes highly trained astronauts. Short of this being done on purpose (hard to believe to begin with) I'd just chalk it up to an accident.

You're comparing an emotional breakdown to not securing a toolbox?

"An emotional breakdown" is an odd way to describe burglary, assault, attempted kidnapping, and battery that had been planned out and prepared for following two months of Lisa stalking someone who was sleeping with a guy she'd previously had an affair with.

I'm not suggesting that it's similar in any way to losing a toolbox. Lisa's entire situation was clearly something very different, you're right about that, but an emotional breakdown (while not a precise medical term) is typically used to describe an episode or outburst caused by too much stress/pressure. It's strange to see it used for a series of premeditated crimes that took months, involved lots of planning, careful packing, and a journey of 900 miles by car to reach the victim.

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So could have the NY times couple of years ago with > Why NASA's First All-Women Spacewalk Made History And we have articles in space.com just a week ago >Watch 2 NASA astronauts conduct 4th-ever all-female spacewalk today If all female walks are news, then fuck ups during all female space walks are also news worth pointing.

I sort of agree, if it was merely matter of fact This doesn't read like that though It reads like “looll some women did something incompetent! get a load of this guys”

And the original articles are also not stating a matter of fact.

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So could have the NY times couple of years ago with > Why NASA's First All-Women Spacewalk Made History And we have articles in space.com just a week ago >Watch 2 NASA astronauts conduct 4th-ever all-female spacewalk today If all female walks are news, then fuck ups during all female space walks are also news worth pointing.

I sort of agree, if it was merely matter of fact This doesn't read like that though It reads like “looll some women did something incompetent! get a load of this guys”

> It reads like "looll some women did something incompetent! get a load of this guys"

I don't think the article was written that way, but I think that it's clear that's how many people would take it.

It'd have been nice if the article had listed multiple examples of things being lost during spacewalks and not just the other time a woman did it - assuming there are other previous examples anyway. Searching for that kind of information now is difficult since search engines just want to push whatever the latest story is. A google search for the word "astronauts" alone returns links to news articles about this incident.

Re: Astronauts drop tool bag into orbit that you can see with binoculars

#130
post #49

I know what the historical present is but its use here is confusing. Just use "dropped." If the headline needs the present use "leave".

I don't understand what's confusing about saying "drop" and to me the headline makes perfect sense. What is it you dont like?
Post reply on HN