Live data from Hacker News

The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

bloomberg.com

461–470 of 619 posts

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#461

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Or, my point in short: cut people some slack That's what we are doing here! But in this case most people seems to be sympathetic to the people that suffered to get you and your wife a diamond? I don't think rich people with frivolous desires need any more "empathy"

Diamonds aren't rich people game, they're middle-class and above game. Hell, probably even below. That's what makes the arguments about being associated[0] with violence fall on deaf ears - approximately everyone in the west is participating. Not the Evil Bad No Good Rich One-Percenters. It's all the 90-percenters. -- [0] - It's always "some of them", "could be". The industry has blood on its hand. The particular roc…

> with violence fall on deaf ears - approximately everyone in the west is participating

That's no excuse to continue.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#462
post #153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They literally paying to go to the clink. Nothing that a marriage license permits you to do that you can’t do without one. Except you can be liable to get sued when the relationship ends. Literally the only differentiator of significance.

You can get a visa more easily.

As an American, it’s pretty much visa-free everywhere - and my comment is directed towards Americans.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#463
post #199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you’re thinking about marriage in terms of leverage you’ve guaranteed you’re going to find out about those courts.

> If you’re thinking about marriage in terms of leverage you’ve guaranteed you’re going to find out about those courts. The reality is that in every relationship (whether marriage, business, friend, sibling, whatever) one person will have more leverage than the other. That's not the problem. The problem is when the party with the leverage uses it! The phrase "happy wife, happy life" is problematic because it normalis…

> (And if you think women have all the leverage in the average relationship, just wait till you get to over 45 and the kids are all old enough).

“It’s cheaper to keep her” is also a saying. So it looks like she still has the leverage.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#464
post #419
post #403

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Marrying is irrational to begin with. A man that relies on rational thought should avoid marriage; the cons absolutely outweigh any advantage.

Having a loving person to share a personal history with is an advantage that's difficult to outweigh.

That's a relationship not a marriage.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#465
post #460

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That depends on where you live. In some places parental rights are linked to marriage.

You have parental rights even without marriage, in America and the western world.

No, that's not true. As I said, that depends on where you live. For example, in Ireland, for children born outside of marriage, only the mother has an automatic right to guardianship. The same is true in the UK unless the father is added to the birth certificate. The same is true in most US States - no automatic parental rights without marriage.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#466
post #298

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yikes, that's quite the binary distinction... Surely there is room between those subjective descriptions of people for "hey, I like this thing even though it's irrational, ok?" Let people live their lives and you do you. People aren't a "provider mannequin" just because they like to make their partner happy.

acknowledgement of irrationality, especially one that isn't accompanied with a wish to better themselves away from that irrationality, would be a major red flag for me personally entering into a long-term relationship. there is also a great distinction between "Yeah I know another helping of chocolate syrup on my ice cream is a bad decision, but it'll make me feel good today.", and "You need to make a 10kUSD+ purchas…

Moissanite is also irrational if we push on this. Why does it get a complete pass?

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#467
post #283

Diamonds are a scam and an ethical minefield, but I disagree with the notion that women are brainwashed or shallow for wanting one. It’s not about the diamond. It’s about wanting a man with enough resources to waste on a diamond. A diamond’s lack of intrinsic value or utility is a feature. The waste is the point. In a sea of potential mates, finding one who can throw away $3000 as though it were nothing, is a great f…

Yeah, it's not brainwashing. That's hilarious if people think any marketing company would go to the effort to brainwash people, if such a thing is even possible. Marketing companies leverage what is already there. Car companies didn't brainwash men into wanting "rugged", "angry" looking "trucks". They merely recognised the slightly pathetic tendency for some men to want to make themselves look bigger and tougher. It'…

>That's hilarious if people think any marketing company would go to the effort to brainwash people, if such a thing is even possible. Marketing companies leverage what is already there.

Just compare today's problems with problems from 200 years ago and you'll see how many of them were created ad hoc.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#468
post #422
post #419

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Having a loving person to share a personal history with is an advantage that's difficult to outweigh.

Marriage is well-known to work counter to that goal. It destroys families.

I have an extremely hard time understanding how marrying my wife made me more likely to break up with her.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#469
post #449

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A large diamond actually looks pretty nice (and very different from mossianite), not sure why that is devaluing the agency of anyone (provided the costs are relatively easy to afford). Even uncut diamond crystals have a very particular "fatty" shine to it that some people might like and enjoy.

I seriously doubt any regular person can tell the difference between diamond and moissanite, or even cubic zirconia. Of course it's bad policy to lie to your wife-to-be but technically I feel safe saying you could buy any of these and still claim it's a diamond - at least until they decide to pawn it but by that time it's also less important for your relationship I guess.

It's not hard to tell the difference between moissanite and diamond, but a lot of normal people won't really know what to put their finger on or if it's a good or bad thing.

Whenever my wife gets comments about her moissanite, people notice it's different. Due to it's refractive index, it breaks light more and leads to a lot more colors seen when reflected back out of the stone. Loads of people just think it's a fancy diamond though since they don't know anything else and it otherwise looks very diamond like.

CZ will look about the same as diamond just not as sparkly on day one. But it's way softer, so if it's a daily wear it'll get all scratched up within several years. After 10 years of wear the difference between CZ and diamond is pretty clear.

Re: The diamond world takes radical steps to stop a pricing plunge

#470
post #3

I would like to take this moment to thank https://diamondssuck.com/ for preventing me from buying my wife a diamond, and getting her a much prettier moissanite instead. It's been on hn's front page several times.

I love diamondssuck.com, but it seems the article they link https://www.theatlantic.com/doc/print/198202/diamond/ is 404-ing (not available).

Likely De Beers did what cartels do and threw their lawyers to take it down?

diamondssuck should instead link to https://web.archive.org/web/20130522104756/http://www.theatl... which is a working link.

The long article is truly worth a read.

Post reply on HN