Live data from Hacker News

Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

macworld.com

261–270 of 409 posts

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#261

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> They're more likely to buy a budget laptop in the 400-500 range I'd imagine the TCO on those bargain basement laptops is terrible, so I doubt they're really a big sell for corporate buyers.

$299 Inspirons these days come with NVMe storage and 6 core Intel CPUs

You do know what the "T" in "TCO" stands for right? Hint: it's not the price you paid for the hardware upfront.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#262
post #181

I think the best reaction would be shame. Just a big round of shame for a trillion dollar company being so greedy to cripple their top equipment. Tech’s stagnated for over a decade and largely because of greed and at the expense of innovation. Prove me wrong? Do something genuinely new, like a mass produced cpu on germanium. Make a modern OS that’s a successor to unix-and plan9. Edit-Or at least a moddable iphone tha…

> I think the best reaction would be shame. Just a big round of shame for a trillion dollar company being so greedy to cripple their top equipment.

You're not going to shame a company into changing how it does market segmentation.

They do this because it makes them more money, and if you don't like padding their profit margins your best reaction would be to simply not buy their products. There are plenty of other PC vendors out there.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#263

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No it's not. A ton of programs used by regular people (Chrome etc.) are RAM hogs, if you are a dev, then Docker is also an egregious example. If you happen to play games (a big thing for average people), that 8GB will be shared between the CPU and the GPU. Even the Steam Deck, admittedly a budget device, comes with 16GB. It's often mentioned that macOS is more frugal with RAM, a claim which I flat out found to be unt…

If Chrome is the only reason someone feels they need more RAM, maybe what they really need is a new browser. A web browser should never even enter the conversation when talking about hitting hardware limitations.

Once upon a time that was a reasonable position to hold.

But nowadays full dynamic applications are shipped in a browser tab, and a huge number of "desktop" applications are written in JavaScript using electron, so they're essentially an isolated chrome instance for running that app.

People talk about chrome being a resource hog, and maybe it is, but if you have dozens of JavaScript applications running in different tabs, then chrome is just taking the blame for the fact that it's essentially serving as the user application layer of your OS.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#264
post #169

8GB is still good enough for office workers and students. Heck, I used an M1 8GB Air for 1 year as a dev. Although I wish I had more RAM, it still served me well. For $899 (on sale sometimes), the 8GB M2 Air is absolutely a steal. The screen quality, thinness, battery life, build quality, SoC, quietness, coolness, metal enclosure, touchpad, and speakers are simply unmatched by anything in the PC world at that price -…

I think you missed the point - we're talking about computers marketed as "Pro" devices which should be able to handle "Pro" workloads. 8GB on the Airs is a completely different issue as these are not marketed as Pro devices. Consumers place a lot of faith in Apple as a brand so when they go and purchase a "Macbook Pro" they should be able to assume Apple has their back and it's actually going to do what it says on th…

I run a 3d printing business, design, manufacturing, CAD/CAM, designed my own marketing materials, website, etc etc from my 8G M2 Macbook Air, never once did I feel like I needed more RAM.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#265

8GB is still good enough for office workers and students. Heck, I used an M1 8GB Air for 1 year as a dev. Although I wish I had more RAM, it still served me well. For $899 (on sale sometimes), the 8GB M2 Air is absolutely a steal. The screen quality, thinness, battery life, build quality, SoC, quietness, coolness, metal enclosure, touchpad, and speakers are simply unmatched by anything in the PC world at that price -…

No it's not. A ton of programs used by regular people (Chrome etc.) are RAM hogs, if you are a dev, then Docker is also an egregious example. If you happen to play games (a big thing for average people), that 8GB will be shared between the CPU and the GPU. Even the Steam Deck, admittedly a budget device, comes with 16GB. It's often mentioned that macOS is more frugal with RAM, a claim which I flat out found to be unt…

Do you know of any recent benchmarks to back up this claim? It's entirely quantifiable.

Also, it's such a controversial thing you would think if the difference was so stark The Verge, Linus Tech Tips or Max Tech, etc. would, you know, actually measure it.

The only kinda objective side-by-side test I could find, on typical workloads, was this 2 year old video on the M1 which stated the 8gb did well on typical multitask workloads. For Chrome tab test the bottleneck was the internet speed, not RAM. Lightroom and Final Cut Export was slower, but typical multitasking workloads basically matched.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h487I_5xOZU

Obviously things change so where does this stand today?

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#266
The issue I have with the base model Mac's being under-memoried is that the base models are the high volume models that have sales and are easier to get at vendors other than the Apple Store.

iPhone's have been under memoried at significant periods during their life, but most stores carried an upgraded model. I find the non base model Mac's often aren't available at launch, have longer lead times and force you to go to the Apple Store where you won't get any discount of any kind and often find a longer lead time even there.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#267

8GB is still good enough for office workers and students. Heck, I used an M1 8GB Air for 1 year as a dev. Although I wish I had more RAM, it still served me well. For $899 (on sale sometimes), the 8GB M2 Air is absolutely a steal. The screen quality, thinness, battery life, build quality, SoC, quietness, coolness, metal enclosure, touchpad, and speakers are simply unmatched by anything in the PC world at that price -…

the point is that pure greed keeps them from doubling it and giving people a bit more power.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#268

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Macs are luxury goods, price is the price. If you have an issue with it then you are not the market. No one goes to a Lambo dealer and complains about the cost of an oil change. Price is the price for luxury goods.

Apple has an 8% global market share for PCs. In Q42022, they shipped 7 million units. Lamborghini shipped less than 10k units in 2022, total. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/11/apples-mac-market-share-jump... https://www.lamborghini.com/en-en/news/lamborghinis-record-b... https://appleinsider.com/articles/23/01/19/apple-shipped-sev...

Comparing Apple to Lamborghini is laughable. Apple is Audi at best. More like Volkswagen or Honda to me.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#269

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have a 2011 Thinkpad T520 which still works fine, upgraded it to 16GB of RAM. There are high quality Windows laptops out there, but of course they cost as much as a Macbook. I'm okay with laptops being sold with 8GB of RAM, but I'm not okay with artifically shortened lifespan caused by lack of upgradability. Manufacturers should be regulated to force them offer upgradeable RAM. I don't care what new technological i…

> Manufacturers should be regulated to force them offer upgradeable RAM Or just don't buy LUXURY Macs. Yes, they are luxury goods, they are Louis Vuittons of the laptop world. You and a bunch of people don't buy Macs with 8GB and complain a lot and Apple will start selling them with 16GB. But this will never happen because people will keep buying Macs because of the panache and swagger that owning and using a Mac giv…

Bizarre bitterness. You really think nobody is buying Macs on their merit?

Maybe you're European and apple products cost a lot more where you live?

In the states, base model MacBook Airs are frequently ~$800 on sale.

You can get an official refurb MacBook Air or Pro with 16GB/1TB for ~$1300 from Apple's website right now.

Those machines are priced competitively when compared to Dell XPS, new ThinkPads, etc.

They also have much better battery life, screens, and overall build quality compared to those machines.

Also MacOS is, for all its faults, normie-accessible unlike Linux and ad-free unlike Windows.

Re: Apple has a memory problem and we're all paying for it

#270
post #71

8GB is still good enough for office workers and students. Heck, I used an M1 8GB Air for 1 year as a dev. Although I wish I had more RAM, it still served me well. For $899 (on sale sometimes), the 8GB M2 Air is absolutely a steal. The screen quality, thinness, battery life, build quality, SoC, quietness, coolness, metal enclosure, touchpad, and speakers are simply unmatched by anything in the PC world at that price -…

The lifespan of a Macbook Pro will be increased if the RAM is upgraded from 8GB to 16GB, which is very unfriendly to the environment. Ironically, Apple's official website makes a big deal about how low-carbon they are. Note: Customers cannot upgrade the RAM by themselves.

How is increasing the lifespan of the MBP more unfriendly to the environment??
Post reply on HN