Live data from Hacker News

No Man's Sky just keeps getting better

polygon.com

11–20 of 176 posts

Re: No Man's Sky just keeps getting better

#13
post #10
post #5

No Man's Sky is one of the biggest gaming disappointments of my life. It was always a grindy, pointless game about exploring a dull, repetitive universe.

Seconded. I was hoping for a persistent multiplayer and modernized Freelancer 2 but i got a very pretty, but mile wide and inch deep game. God what i would give for a modern reimagining of Freelancer 2...

That's also what I was hoping for, but yeah, NMS kinda just culminated into pastel drudgery. For some reason it just doesn't feel like there is either carrot or stick and I suppose the creative avenues offered don't really feel interesting to me in the context of the game. But maybe it'd be more interesting on creative mode or something similar. But the combat has always been really subpar, both in FPS and in-ship which would definitely be my forte.

Re: No Man's Sky just keeps getting better

#14
post #3

To save you a click or perhaps a rage-comment: This is a hype article for people who think No Man's Sky is already a great game. Seems like a fluff piece to me. There's nothing in it that suggests any sort of fundamental change in the quality of the game.

I agree the article was fluff, I expected it to do some sort of analysis of the changes in the game since its crushingly disappointing launch. However, that said, the game has improved dramatically and does so at a blistering pace. For instance there has been several major releases this year alone:

https://www.nomanssky.com/echoes-update/

https://www.nomanssky.com/2023/06/expedition-ten-singularity...

https://www.nomanssky.com/interceptor-update/

https://www.nomanssky.com/fractal-update/

Each is pretty packed with quality of life, gameplay, and content improvements.

I no longer regret my original launch purchase. The game is pretty amazing now, and the rate of change and improvement indicates to me it’s not close to topping out. If you have it and haven’t picked it up again, then, I would actually say wait another year and try it again then. Not that it needs another year, but that in that time it’ll likely be even better than it is now by a substantial margin.

Re: No Man's Sky just keeps getting better

#15
post #5

No Man's Sky is one of the biggest gaming disappointments of my life. It was always a grindy, pointless game about exploring a dull, repetitive universe.

I don’t even mind a grind, but this game just feels… pointless. Why am I here, why do I care? Something about an infinite loop in a simulation? May as well use the “it’s all a dream” card.

I did give it an honest try, and even enjoyed the first 30 hours or so. This was about a year ago, though I did buy the game at launch and promptly give up on it, like many others.

A true mile-wide-inch-deep game. Once that initial spark fizzles out the idea of picking the game up again is painful. Bit of a shame really, because the actual game parts do work well enough.

Just a long way of saying “I hate to say it, but I completely agree”

Re: No Man's Sky just keeps getting better

#17
My review nobody asked for:

If you look at today’s NMS and think, “ooh, that looks like it could be fun!” you’ll probably have a great time. If you look at it and think, “Enh, is it good enough yet?” then you’ll probably have a bad time.

It is what you see and they’ve fixed the incredibly shallow game loop. But it’s one of those games where if it’s not for you, it’s not going to win you over.

I enjoyed it as a “podcast game” where I’m just focused on a tv show or podcast while mucking about, planet to planet.

Re: No Man's Sky just keeps getting better

#18
post #4

I love this game so much. First of all, it's kind of technologically astounding. You can get in your spaceship and take off from a planet and fly to another one and land, all without any loading screens. The planets themselves are sculptable isosurfaces (only to an extent, though; you can't drill a hole through to the other side) and littered with points of interest, unique animals and plants. It's quasi-social -- yo…

I love it too, but after playing KSP so much, it bothers me how compressed space is… although a huge class gripe about NMS is how empty it feels, I actually feel like it’s not empty enough at times. Space doesn’t feel big, and solar systems feel like planets and moons are stacked on top of each other.

Re: No Man's Sky just keeps getting better

#20
No Man’s Sky for me is a very accomplished example of the Boredom Management genre of games. Every individual activity in it is quite boring and starts to grate after a while, but there are enough different things to do that when you get too bored you can switch to some other temporarily less boring task.
Post reply on HN