Live data from Hacker News

Slack: Our biggest redesign yet came to be

slack.design

81–87 of 87 posts

Re: Slack: Our biggest redesign yet came to be

#81
post #45

Please stop making every update require more screen space. Every time, more chrome, bigger fonts, more padding, more views that take over the whole viewport.

The other side here is that when I've designed apps that more dense, smaller font sizes and UI, people do then complain things are too small. Engineers are generally ok and appreciate density but more mainstream users often don't.

If they exposed an api or used an open protocol, power users could build their own app for slack instead.

I really hate this change too, on my laptop, slack has to be full screen to make sense whereas I can have four screens of terminals and email without issue otherwise. Wish they at least made the design adaptive

Re: Slack: Our biggest redesign yet came to be

#82
post #58

Slack, please! Stop making features. You're bloating your product. It was fine, don't add more things I don't need.

I do question how wise it is for such an essential tool (I am in Slack all day, every day, all the time at work) to be driven by profit. I've always expected the choices Slack has made were because their tests and metrics show they are profitable. I even have a small script I run that hacks the JS source code to remove a feature that infuriates me.

Bigger issue is that you try to catch a big audience first and then turn your platform into crap to become profitable once you have that audience.

Re: Slack: Our biggest redesign yet came to be

#83

I guess the classic reaction to any design change is 'I hate this'... but damn I hate the slack redesign :< I can't see a quick overview of all my workspaces with notifications and have to hover with the mouse to see them - even though most of the rest of slack is designed to be used keyboard-only!

Cmd+Shift+s pops all the workspaces in the side bar like before the redesign. This is a new change after—I am sure—many many people complained about that very thing. Such a stupid change. Just show me the workspaces by default gosh darnit.

wow thanks for this! worked a charm

Re: Slack: Our biggest redesign yet came to be

#84
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The change in the mobile app where pulling down on the channel list focuses a search box and opens the keyboard is quite jarring too, especially when that UX generally means 'get me the lastest updates'

Holy insufferable change, Batman! Why?????

Because when you have 500 devs, they have to build _something_. It's why every single good software product bloats to become a slow, confusing, mess of features.

Software development feature entropy is the 4th law of thermodynamics.

Re: Slack: Our biggest redesign yet came to be

#86
I just want to add That I genuinely love the new update. Mostly because how noticeably snappier the app feels on both desktop and mobile!

It also feels more intuitive to use on mobile, and this is coming from someone who typically hates app design changes

Post reply on HN