Live data from Hacker News

Dot by New Computer

new.computer

51–60 of 120 posts

Re: Dot by New Computer

#51
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The UX was quite different as it seemed the ambition. Pi.ai just seems like a fine tuned chatgpt that’s aimed at being “supportive,” no?

Like ChatGPT, sure, but Pi uses internally developed, novel language models, not OpenAI's.

Not clear to me what their main differentiating factor is there. Seems a lot like chatgpt but without any name brand recognition.

Experience wasn’t particularly helpful at helping me with problems.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They say in their about page: "We will never monetize your data. We will never monetize your attention. And we believe that the only way we can build towards the future we envision is through the continuous reinforcement of mutual trust and respect. Currently, we leverage best-in-class cloud-hosted models, including ones from OpenAI, Anthropic, and a selection of open-source options. Over time, we plan to reduce exte…

How do they intend to make money?

"After the untimely passing of her oil tycoon father, Mei finds herself with more money than she knows what to do with. Dot helpfully suggests transferring a few hundred thousand dollars to New Computer as a thank you for Dot's continued existence."

Re: Dot by New Computer

#53

This is the most likely-to-be-Sherlocked[1] thing I've seen in a while. And when Apple does it, the processing will be done on-device. [1] https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=sherlocked

Same could have been said of Workflow — which Apple acquired and rebranded as a first-party app.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#54
FYI to the website designer: on desktop, this website does not have a scrollbar. In addition to that being an accessibility issue, I closed the website after I got tired of paging and/or using the scroll wheel.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#55
post #23

In a year, Dot app is discontinued and you lose everything.

If new technology and products don’t have a chance for optimism on HN, where do they?

The kind of tech that underpins this gets a pretty good reception here.

But this page looks slick to a fault. The user story approach feels pandering and I lose interest fairly quickly. Is this closed source? IOS only? I see a waitlist - Why don't they want a general audience to see it?

Re: Dot by New Computer

#57

Something like this is most certainly going to become the mainstream interface for computing. I think the most likely thing that will hit mass market adoption will look much more like the voice interface in Her than a chat app. I couldn't imagine my mom getting much utility out of an app like this but if the AI is good enough I could certainly see her chatting with her phone as if it was a person.

Would be curious if a study was done on this form of interaction after Siri/Alexa became big.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#58

Their privacy policy lists OpenAI as one of their partners for data processing, which indicates that this is happening not on your device, and data is also shared with third parties. For me this is the main counterargument against apps like these. I want to feel free to post any information into this without thinking about who may read or use it. Local is the only way to go for software like this in my opinion.

Yeah reading this web page I just keep thinking “Mei has trusted a cloud based service to be her personal confidant for all aspects of her life including text and documents. This will end poorly for Mei.”

Re: Dot by New Computer

#60

"Dot is, at its most simple, an app you chat with on iOS. You can send it words, voice memos, pictures, PDFs, and it’s thrilled to search the web for you, too. Communicating through written text (Dot’s voice is coming next year)" [0]. It looks quite "ambitious"[1]: - Automated File Management: Dot creates, organizes, and retrieves both structured and unstructured information. - Adaptive Intelligence: It learns from p…

I'm a bit perturbed by the, uh, inflation here. Looks like a product manager wishlist for a team of 1000 over 7 years
Post reply on HN