Live data from Hacker News

Dot by New Computer

new.computer

31–40 of 120 posts

Re: Dot by New Computer

#31
I immediately recognized this as either inspired from or actually from the same creators of the mercuryos concept https://www.mercuryos.com/. Turns out it's the latter.

I love the Mercury OS concept and think it's design both elegantly and sort of subversively packs a myriad of potentially breakthrough ideas.

I have been stewing with ideas around the same vision for years. The idea of a new type of UI where the UI seams to dematerialize, where you directly manipulate the object in your current context (like multi-touch's direct manipulation but at a higher layer of abstraction powered by deep api integrations, intelligent self-assembling relational graphs, and of course ai). For over a decade I've had this thought "the data becomes the UI" like an emergent UI from whatever given data, task or context you are currently in. When I came across the mercuryos concept I immediately smiled.

Conceptually, strategically and technically there are so many challenges to introducing such a new ux paradigm but I'm very happy to see the mercuryos concept has seemed to evolve to New Computer's Dot and I wish them the best!

For those immediately turning to negative sentiment based on privacy or "it's just a gpt4 wrapper" I can see why that could be the knee-jerk reaction but I wouldn't underestimate a sturdy design-philosophy approach like this one. I'd go as far as to make comparisons to Next Computer's NextStepOS. NextStep introduced so many groundbreaking UX concepts and to a large extent I think their personal computing contemporaries underestimated what potential it packed. And, yes, I know the business model and many other factors played into an inevitable doom for Next Computer but there's belief that Steve Jobs may have never intended for Next to become a dominant computing player and instead knew it'd be an irresistible acquisition target in a latent space of UX innovation. It's possible he saw the next evolution of personal computing UX and hedged his bet on not compromising on it. Yet another comparison could be that NextStepOS needed more cpu, graphics and connectivity power to truly display it's heightened level of UX much in the same way something like Dot or mercuryOS would inherently need to leverage cutting-edge computing to truly enable it's vision (obviously LLM's, Vector DB's, etc).

Ok, I'm done, lol.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#33
post #30

I wonder how does it perform on things long-before (outside gpt context). Do they just do the normal tricks like vector db?

I'm guessing it'll hallucinate things about you that it doesn't know. This might be a mixed blessing: it could introduce you to things you weren't aware of, but it could also be annoyingly inaccurate.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#35
post #33
post #30

I wonder how does it perform on things long-before (outside gpt context). Do they just do the normal tricks like vector db?

I'm guessing it'll hallucinate things about you that it doesn't know. This might be a mixed blessing: it could introduce you to things you weren't aware of, but it could also be annoyingly inaccurate.

well humans also hallucinate or assume things they dont know or on how they remember it so that's alright.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#36
> Dot remembers Mei’s interest in singing and proactively sends her suggestions for music clubs at school.

Imagine having so little agency and motivation within your own existence on this earth that you need an app to remind of what you once found life—affirming.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#37

Something like this is most certainly going to become the mainstream interface for computing. I think the most likely thing that will hit mass market adoption will look much more like the voice interface in Her than a chat app. I couldn't imagine my mom getting much utility out of an app like this but if the AI is good enough I could certainly see her chatting with her phone as if it was a person.

I see a great opportunity for chat interfaces like this one among younger audience. Every one knows how chat works, they are everywhere. And file systems or even tags are not so ubiquitously understood.

Re: Dot by New Computer

#38

Interesting. I just signed up for the waitlist. It seems similar to Pi ( https://pi.ai ) in terms of audience and general use case though.

The UX was quite different as it seemed the ambition. Pi.ai just seems like a fine tuned chatgpt that’s aimed at being “supportive,” no?

Re: Dot by New Computer

#40

> Dot remembers Mei’s interest in singing and proactively sends her suggestions for music clubs at school. Imagine having so little agency and motivation within your own existence on this earth that you need an app to remind of what you once found life—affirming.

Yeah, imagine how they feel.
Post reply on HN