Live data from Hacker News

Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

robkhenderson.com

101–110 of 396 posts

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#101

    > When I was growing up in foster homes, or making minimum wage as a 
    > dishwasher, or serving in the military, I never heard words like “cultural 
    > appropriation” or “gendered” or “heteronormative.”
    > 
    > Working class people could not tell you what these terms mean. But if you 
    > visit an elite university, you’ll find plenty of affluent people who will 
    > eagerly explain them to you.
I figured out as soon as I saw the link title that the author's examples for "luxury beliefs" would just so happen to be associated with a feminist and anti-racist outlook.

    > But unlike luxury goods, luxury beliefs can have long term detrimental 
    > effects for the poor and working class. However costly these beliefs are 
    > for the rich, they often inflict even greater costs on everyone else.
This is certainly true for a high number of luxury beliefs, such as "trickle down economics", "small government" advocacy and "catallaxy", none of which come up often among dishwashers; and all of which freshman students at Yale, who just read their first essay on Friedrich Hayek, will gladly explain to you.

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#102

Seems like the rich are spending lots on fancy cars and big houses. I’m not sure saying you support x or y belief is quite the same signal as a sports car.

TBH to me it feels like all the money in this world is spent on fancy cars, houses, and yachts. Anything funded from taxes, insurances, or contributions is basically "the limits are exhausted, the waiting times are in months, your case is not covered". Meantime all the cars and houses I see while driving and walking around? Wow.

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#103

"a vulnerable poor person in a crime-ridden neighborhood can’t afford to support defunding the police" [citation needed because the vulnerable poor person is police's first target]

Agreed; the article completely skirts the obvious point that the Black Lives Matter movement was not founded by upper-class white students at an urban college, but by working-class black people who are directly affected by the issue at hand.

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#104

"a vulnerable poor person in a crime-ridden neighborhood can’t afford to support defunding the police" [citation needed because the vulnerable poor person is police's first target]

"Crime is number one concern for black adults. Police doesn't even make the list." https://x.com/PeterMoskos/status/1515170739791568899

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#105

"a vulnerable poor person in a crime-ridden neighborhood can’t afford to support defunding the police" [citation needed because the vulnerable poor person is police's first target]

Agreed; the article completely skirts the obvious point that the Black Lives Matter movement was not founded by upper-class white students at an urban college, but by working-class black people who are directly affected by the issue at hand.

[deleted]

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#106
Let’s consider the contrary. Do poor people sometimes hold highly questionable beliefs, promulgated by institutions, and does professing these beliefs in expensive and flamboyant ways confer status?

Religion ticks all these boxes.

In some contexts, so does patriotism, racism, worship of the military, publicly dumping cases of Bud Light, etc etc etc. In some ways, even disdain for education is a sort of expensive status display.

The author is just describing what people of all kinds do. Yes, there are very silly beliefs which sometimes seduce educated elites. But that just makes them like everybody else.

Also, the author is picking on some trendy ideas which are currently held by some of the elites, but so what? It would be truly surprising if a decade-plus of higher education and immersion in data and discourse did not produce a different consensus. The author offers no evidence that “defund the police” is an inherently absurd idea, no more than other formerly radical ideas like universal suffrage or abolishing slavery. In my town, the police absorb over 20% of the city budget, have doubled their spend in the past decade, and are unaccountable to the people. So I think it’s at least a topic worthy of interest!

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#107

"a vulnerable poor person in a crime-ridden neighborhood can’t afford to support defunding the police" [citation needed because the vulnerable poor person is police's first target]

"Crime is number one concern for black adults. Police doesn't even make the list." https://x.com/PeterMoskos/status/1515170739791568899

because getting shot by the police is neither violence nor crime?

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#108

Starts off with an interesting premise and makes me think, hey, maybe I should re-examine my priors, let's see the evidence. And then the evidence turns out to be something about people who "make more than $100K," and goes on to assert that they "live in gated communities" and "can afford private security." In 2023, "making over 100K" just means that you're usually on-time with your monthly housing payment. Author ma…

If we're talking a security firm paying minimum wage hired by the HOA to do rounds at a gated townhouse complex, that's not some unattainable luxury for someone making "just" $100K.

it's funny contrasting California expectations with the rest of the country.

Re: Luxury beliefs are status symbols (2022)

#109

Reminds me of one of my favourite quotes by Huxley: "If you’re to do anything reasonable in this world, you must have a class of people who are secure, safe from public opinion, safe from poverty, leisured, not compelled to waste their time in the imbecile routines that go by the name of Honest Work. You must have a class of which the members can think and, within the obvious limits, do what they please. You must hav…

It sounds like you're talking about an aristocracy, and the quote even uses that word, so I wonder: do you think the aristocracy is responsible for most of the progress in the world? I'd argue rather that, historically, progress has generally involved removing or disempowering the aristocracy.

Depends what you mean by progress, but the flourishing of the arts and music in Vienna was possible because of the patronage of the Habsburgs.
Post reply on HN