Live data from Hacker News

Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

youtube.com

11–20 of 117 posts

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#11
post #9

Frankly, I can't imagine a reason not to buy an iPhone instead of whatever Android device happens to be around besides ideological differences. The customer experience is so vastly superior to these bloatware filled, borderline spyware Samsung/Xiamoi/OnePlus devices.

What Samsung did is actually more of an Apple move. Total control, even the source shop of your phone.

Parent isn’t talking about control.

Their comment is off-topic, but correct.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#12
Samsung and the other manufacturers shot themselves in the foot so hard on this one. When this news trickles down to the average Mexican (ie someone not in the tech industry), the message they will get won't be "don't buy grey market phones, buy official phones", it will be "don't by Samsung, ZTE, etc, they will lock your phone".

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#13

We need a law, and that"s coming from a libertarian. If the owner of a hardware device is using it, that person has total control over the device. Nothing can be blocked. Nothing can be hidden. All data must be available in plain language. That owner/user should have the right to inspect and modify everything in the device in plain language. With today's memory / storage capacities and with today's LLMs, that should…

> We need a law, and that"s coming from a libertarian.

> easily implemented by starting over and reprogramming everything.

Press X to doubt. Theoretically a free market would/should solve this. That's been the dream of Free Software and hardware. Today you can run GNU/Linux on a PinePhone, or GrapheneOS or similar de-Googled Androids on a Pixel.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#14
post #9

Frankly, I can't imagine a reason not to buy an iPhone instead of whatever Android device happens to be around besides ideological differences. The customer experience is so vastly superior to these bloatware filled, borderline spyware Samsung/Xiamoi/OnePlus devices.

What Samsung did is actually more of an Apple move. Total control, even the source shop of your phone.

And yet it is Samsung that we are talking about and that did the "move". Not Apple.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#15

Frankly, I can't imagine a reason not to buy an iPhone instead of whatever Android device happens to be around besides ideological differences. The customer experience is so vastly superior to these bloatware filled, borderline spyware Samsung/Xiamoi/OnePlus devices.

Most of the world simply can't afford an iPhone.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#16

Frankly, I can't imagine a reason not to buy an iPhone instead of whatever Android device happens to be around besides ideological differences. The customer experience is so vastly superior to these bloatware filled, borderline spyware Samsung/Xiamoi/OnePlus devices.

I'm not buying after the client scanning debacle. That they would even come up with something like troubles me greatly, and I was tempted to ditch Android at that point.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#17

Frankly, I can't imagine a reason not to buy an iPhone instead of whatever Android device happens to be around besides ideological differences. The customer experience is so vastly superior to these bloatware filled, borderline spyware Samsung/Xiamoi/OnePlus devices.

I realize this makes me sound black-pilled, but mobile platforms (Apple included) are so user-hostile with regard to privacy I’m not even sure the battle is worth fighting.

IMO it’s better to just hold your nose, limit what you use your phone for as much as you can, and do everything important/sensitive on a computer that you have root access on.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#19

Samsung and the other manufacturers shot themselves in the foot so hard on this one. When this news trickles down to the average Mexican (ie someone not in the tech industry), the message they will get won't be "don't buy grey market phones, buy official phones", it will be "don't by Samsung, ZTE, etc, they will lock your phone".

I see a lot of ZTE phones in the stores here in Cancún. I’ve not seen that brand before coming here.

Some of them are pretty cheap even.

I thought about buying one so that I could leave my iPhone in the hotel room some days and only carry a cheap phone when I am outside walking in some parts of the city.

We are leaving Cancún soon, so now there is not so much point in doing that anyways. But I was thinking that I could do so when we get to Panama in a few days, or the next time I come back to South America.

After your comment I am rethinking buying a ZTE phone ever. However, I didn’t hear ZTE mentioned in the video. Is ZTE somehow connected to Samsung?

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#20
post #15

Frankly, I can't imagine a reason not to buy an iPhone instead of whatever Android device happens to be around besides ideological differences. The customer experience is so vastly superior to these bloatware filled, borderline spyware Samsung/Xiamoi/OnePlus devices.

Most of the world simply can't afford an iPhone.

If Apple releases mid-tier phone after this, they will win the market for sure.
Post reply on HN