Live data from Hacker News

Apple iPad & Samsung Galaxy Note – The Great Stylus Debate

soft32.com

21–26 of 26 posts

Re: Apple iPad & Samsung Galaxy Note – The Great Stylus Debate

#21
Check out the Jot Pro for iPad. It simulates a full finger press using a disc the size of your fingertip, but the disc is clear, so visually, you're looking at the tip of a pen.

http://adonit.net/product/jot-pro/

It's fantastic with any iPad notebook app with wrist rejection. (Only downside: write in cursive otherwise it clacks.)

Re: Apple iPad & Samsung Galaxy Note – The Great Stylus Debate

#23
post #15

Here's the #1 problem with a stylus: I'll lose it.

i had stylus with psions and several palms and palm clones. over 10 years of use and never lost a single stylus. make a standard stylus and it becomes easy to keep a spare in your bag.

I'll match your anecdote with mine - I lost the stylus several times (and even once the PalmIIe that some kind lady from France mailed back to me in the US after my trip - something that I would never have expected).

I hate the stylus. When I'm using it, I feel I need to "work" with it. The finger is natural and playful. Humans have been using their fingers to paint and draw long before they used brushes or pens.

A stylus is a powerful tool. To require it is folly. You have to create a platform that either ecompasses both inputs or chooses one. Simplicity would dictate the latter, and the finger is just more human.

Re: Apple iPad & Samsung Galaxy Note – The Great Stylus Debate

#25
post #23
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i had stylus with psions and several palms and palm clones. over 10 years of use and never lost a single stylus. make a standard stylus and it becomes easy to keep a spare in your bag.

I'll match your anecdote with mine - I lost the stylus several times (and even once the PalmIIe that some kind lady from France mailed back to me in the US after my trip - something that I would never have expected). I hate the stylus. When I'm using it, I feel I need to "work" with it. The finger is natural and playful. Humans have been using their fingers to paint and draw long before they used brushes or pens. A s…

and there we run into the problem of one size fits all design. you hate the stylus and i prefer them. it comes down to what you are using your mobile tech for.

with the psions keyboards i could get 30-40 wpm typing. with a stylus i was down to around 20wpm. typing on touch screens is a chore and stuggles approach 20wpm.

but with stylus i also had the option of doodling info on screen. at higher resolution than a finger can achieve. i could get signatures, scribble a hasty note in freehand.

i don't think it should be a requirement but rather an option. but without the option i would lose interest towards a device that has a stylus option. but even then i prefer a keyboard more and currently use a samsung galaxy pro.

Re: Apple iPad & Samsung Galaxy Note – The Great Stylus Debate

#26
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd hardly call £5 obscene.

It's their scheme that's obscene, not the prices themselves. Pay-per-brush? Pay-per-feature? I'm not surprised iPhone/iPad apps are moving in this direction, but it still feels like being nickel-and-dimed.

I guess it might have been better to not use the pay-per-brush model and just offer a single upgrade price to get everything. Still, you get to try it for free.
Post reply on HN