Live data from Hacker News

The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

fastcompany.com

11–20 of 82 posts

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#11

The problems with voluntary layoffs like that is the most competent people are always the first ones to quit.

Is this new information that CEOs dont know? Or just oft-repeated pablum?

The whole “article” is based on a surmise. Its basically a blog post.

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#12
The real reason CEOs want people back in office is 100% because they are broadly part of the same socio-economic class that owns the vast majority of commercial real estate around the world. They and their friends and family own all the commercial real estate, and high vacancy rates are are hurting their bottom lines and reducing the rate at which their property values increase, so they want people back in the office to prop up their property values and keep the commercial real estate graving train flowing.

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#13
post #12

The real reason CEOs want people back in office is 100% because they are broadly part of the same socio-economic class that owns the vast majority of commercial real estate around the world. They and their friends and family own all the commercial real estate, and high vacancy rates are are hurting their bottom lines and reducing the rate at which their property values increase, so they want people back in the office…

I'd say there are many reasons, but I agree this is one of them.

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#14
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The problems with voluntary layoffs like that is the most competent people are always the first ones to quit. Rather, the ones who have the easiest time finding a new job will often be the first ones to quit. These are not necessarily the most competent ones because, for example, people who are better at self-promotion often do have it easier to find a new job, without necessarily being more competent.

> Rather, the ones who have the easiest time finding a new job will often be the first ones to quit. Doesn't that mean the layoff is as humane as possible? It means you inflict the least amount of suffering you could.

It definitely leaves the people who are competent in the org in a lurch.

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#16
post #12

The real reason CEOs want people back in office is 100% because they are broadly part of the same socio-economic class that owns the vast majority of commercial real estate around the world. They and their friends and family own all the commercial real estate, and high vacancy rates are are hurting their bottom lines and reducing the rate at which their property values increase, so they want people back in the office…

I've heard this before, but would the actual collusion mechanics be to make this happen? Like, my landlord buddy golfing just won't stop pestering me about getting my company to return to office so I convince the board of my company to do it?

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#17
post #12

The real reason CEOs want people back in office is 100% because they are broadly part of the same socio-economic class that owns the vast majority of commercial real estate around the world. They and their friends and family own all the commercial real estate, and high vacancy rates are are hurting their bottom lines and reducing the rate at which their property values increase, so they want people back in the office…

I've heard this before, but would the actual collusion mechanics be to make this happen? Like, my landlord buddy golfing just won't stop pestering me about getting my company to return to office so I convince the board of my company to do it?

There's probably no real mechanism, it's just that the circles they all run in agree "yes, yes, office life is important", the same way you're more likely to support some social issue if your friends do.

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#18
post #12

The real reason CEOs want people back in office is 100% because they are broadly part of the same socio-economic class that owns the vast majority of commercial real estate around the world. They and their friends and family own all the commercial real estate, and high vacancy rates are are hurting their bottom lines and reducing the rate at which their property values increase, so they want people back in the office…

That's maybe 10% of it. The other 90% is that they are narcissistic sociopaths that need people around them worshiping their every move.

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#19

"My advice to the many CEOs tasked with this decision? Just own it." It would be nice if we could get this level of honesty from CEOs - but let's not pretend that firing people is the only driver for RTO. Some other motivations include: - We took a tax break that specifies some level of in-office time per employee and we already spent the money - We're getting pressured from local governments to bring customers into…

> We took a tax break that specifies some level of in-office time per employee and we already spent the money

> We're getting pressured from local governments to bring customers into the city to spend money at local businesses

Extremely interested in any examples if you have them handy.

If I'm in the office simply because of a tax break, then I feel I'm productive and revenue-generating by doing absolutely nothing while in said office. I mean they could hire homeless people to do that and solve a lot of problems at once.

Re: The reason CEOs want workers to RTO is because they want you to quit

#20

"My advice to the many CEOs tasked with this decision? Just own it." It would be nice if we could get this level of honesty from CEOs - but let's not pretend that firing people is the only driver for RTO. Some other motivations include: - We took a tax break that specifies some level of in-office time per employee and we already spent the money - We're getting pressured from local governments to bring customers into…

Is it crazy to think that working from an office is just more productive? Especially if you’re a big company and have a lot of new grads/inexperienced hires that are harder to train up remotely?
Post reply on HN