Live data from Hacker News

Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

chrlschn.dev

11–20 of 286 posts

Re: Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

#11

Leetcode being asked in an interview is a marker of an incompetent organization.

Especially when they don’t pay FAANG money. If I were capable of looking good during the only experience in my adult life that feels like having a solo in a middle school strings recital, I’d be applying to those places, not yours.

I don't know if this is what you meant, but to me this reads as: "I don't know anything about data structures or algorithms".

Re: Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

#12

I like this idea, but still think that time and people watching you will add pressure. Most coding challenges that non-FAANG companies give aren't terribly hard; they mostly want you to work through your process out loud, ask questions, interact. These soft skills are as important as technical aptitude in determining whether or not you'd be a good fit with the organization.

But you will have people watching you work and you will be under time pressure in normal work as well, so if you just turn to spagetti at interview are you actually going to perform any better at day to day?

Re: Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

#13
post #4

Leetcode being asked in an interview is a marker of an incompetent organization.

I agree, but it's near-universal. Not sure what that says about our industry.

There is research into how an interview should be done to find who will be a good or bad employee. Most companies (not just our industry!) don't appear to have even looked at it. (I'm not sure how useful the research is for real world hiring)

Re: Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

#16

For take home reviews, I wonder what the impact of generative AI would be. I can see a lot of people feeding the code segment into an AI and using it's comments instead of generating their own. Of course, people will do that with programming questions as well, so I suppose it's up to the hiring manager to decide on the best method to handle this situation. What strategies do people leverage to avoid purely AI answers…

Time will tell, but there optimists are already predicting that in just a few years great programmers will feed requirements into AI and then review the code it produces, not write code themselves. I'm not sure I believe it, but given that someone who can make AI produce good results is worth a lot more than a great programmer without an AI.

Re: Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

#17
post #10

I like this article a lot and have had great success with this tactic (as a hiring manager) over the years. I often give a page or two of code as a take home assignment to discuss at the interview. They get a chance to look at it and research it on their own. And they also get a bit of the crucible of face to face thinking and reacting on their feet while you discuss it with them in the interview.

why opting for an "home assignment" instead of doing that as part of the interview?

Possibly because many quality candidates work / think better when not being watched. It is also likely far more natural for most people.

Re: Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

#18
post #10

I like this article a lot and have had great success with this tactic (as a hiring manager) over the years. I often give a page or two of code as a take home assignment to discuss at the interview. They get a chance to look at it and research it on their own. And they also get a bit of the crucible of face to face thinking and reacting on their feet while you discuss it with them in the interview.

why opting for an "home assignment" instead of doing that as part of the interview?

Better simulates the conditions of the job. I never have to write code on-demand in front of my boss with my job on the line. I get assignments and I do them asynchronously. Less pressure that way and I can do it right.

Re: Interviews in the Age of AI: Ditch Leetcode – Try Code Reviews Instead

#19

I like this idea, but still think that time and people watching you will add pressure. Most coding challenges that non-FAANG companies give aren't terribly hard; they mostly want you to work through your process out loud, ask questions, interact. These soft skills are as important as technical aptitude in determining whether or not you'd be a good fit with the organization.

But you will have people watching you work and you will be under time pressure in normal work as well, so if you just turn to spagetti at interview are you actually going to perform any better at day to day?

When was the last time you had to nail out a fully working nlog(n) longest valid bracket sequence in to prod within 45 mins, without spending 3 weeks in meetings, design doc reviews, capacity plannings and allocations and alignments with the said bracket owners?
Post reply on HN