Live data from Hacker News

Atlassian prepares to abandon on-prem server products

theregister.com

1–10 of 205 posts

Re: Atlassian prepares to abandon on-prem server products

#3

One day the pendulum will swing back in the other direction. Until then, those of us who disagree with putting absolutely everything into the cloud will just have to sit back and bide our time.

> will just have to sit back and bide our time

I doubt that day will ever come without a significant number of potential customers stubbornly opting to go it alone with DIY on-prem alternatives (or at least somewhat SaaS-less - e.g. turnkey-on-IaaS or similar) in the interim. Though I guess that "stubborness" might become more likely as more & more stagnation & inflexibility of cloud SaaS reveals itself to customers over the coming years.

My company's recently been pushed off JIRA on-prem to their cloud offering & the migration has already been an absolute travesty. Any gaps there might have been in the near-universal hatred of JIRA have been thoroughly wiped out by now.

Re: Atlassian prepares to abandon on-prem server products

#4

One day the pendulum will swing back in the other direction. Until then, those of us who disagree with putting absolutely everything into the cloud will just have to sit back and bide our time.

37signals is certainly looking in the other direction: https://once.com/ .. though more at the smaller end of the market, not enterprise apps.

Re: Atlassian prepares to abandon on-prem server products

#5
post #3

One day the pendulum will swing back in the other direction. Until then, those of us who disagree with putting absolutely everything into the cloud will just have to sit back and bide our time.

> will just have to sit back and bide our time I doubt that day will ever come without a significant number of potential customers stubbornly opting to go it alone with DIY on-prem alternatives (or at least somewhat SaaS-less - e.g. turnkey-on-IaaS or similar) in the interim. Though I guess that "stubborness" might become more likely as more & more stagnation & inflexibility of cloud SaaS reveals itself to customers…

I'd agree, lock-in and subscriptions are too tasty a target to give up voluntarily

Re: Atlassian prepares to abandon on-prem server products

#7

One day the pendulum will swing back in the other direction. Until then, those of us who disagree with putting absolutely everything into the cloud will just have to sit back and bide our time.

37signals is certainly looking in the other direction: https://once.com/ .. though more at the smaller end of the market, not enterprise apps.

But they have also announced that Basecamp will always be a subscription product, which doesn’t fit well with their once.com story.

Re: Atlassian prepares to abandon on-prem server products

#9
post #3

One day the pendulum will swing back in the other direction. Until then, those of us who disagree with putting absolutely everything into the cloud will just have to sit back and bide our time.

> will just have to sit back and bide our time I doubt that day will ever come without a significant number of potential customers stubbornly opting to go it alone with DIY on-prem alternatives (or at least somewhat SaaS-less - e.g. turnkey-on-IaaS or similar) in the interim. Though I guess that "stubborness" might become more likely as more & more stagnation & inflexibility of cloud SaaS reveals itself to customers…

Or, you know, a SaaS cloud company could go belly-up and lose a ton of customer data with absolutely no backup or other compensation plan. "Suing the corpse" only works if the corpse hasn't already been looted. If that happens five or six times, it might swing the public perception.

Re: Atlassian prepares to abandon on-prem server products

#10
Last year I was second guessing myself if migration to Gitlab EE from Jira, Bitbucket and Jenkins would be worth it, as it was a massive shift for my org. Maybe purchasing a DC version of Atlassian products would be a better alternative, but after short look into invoices and licensing it was decided to go forward with Gitlab. Still not a big fan of how stiff Yaml pipelines feel in Gitlab CI and that tickets for what seems like a simple feature [1] hang around for years, but it is nice. Developers like it, and i am happy that they are happy.

[1] https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-runner/-/issues/2658

Post reply on HN