Live data from Hacker News

The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

economist.com

11–20 of 141 posts

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#11

In my community: I love the cutsie pootsie Victorians everywhere, the time-capsule 1910s look. Some people want to make it easier to demolish this stuff and build whatever house you want - the rule is you have to keep the facade or whatever - and I sympathize with that. But nobody gives a fuck about the brutalist structures being torn down, like the VA in Chicago or the Federal Building in Boston, because they're ugl…

I'm happy with that bias.

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#12

In my community: I love the cutsie pootsie Victorians everywhere, the time-capsule 1910s look. Some people want to make it easier to demolish this stuff and build whatever house you want - the rule is you have to keep the facade or whatever - and I sympathize with that. But nobody gives a fuck about the brutalist structures being torn down, like the VA in Chicago or the Federal Building in Boston, because they're ugl…

You may not have noticed, but objects literally have no value beyond what people think of them. If a community thinks a building is significant, it is.

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#13

In my community: I love the cutsie pootsie Victorians everywhere, the time-capsule 1910s look. Some people want to make it easier to demolish this stuff and build whatever house you want - the rule is you have to keep the facade or whatever - and I sympathize with that. But nobody gives a fuck about the brutalist structures being torn down, like the VA in Chicago or the Federal Building in Boston, because they're ugl…

It's notable that this tree was probably a few hundred years old. That's not especially old by European or tree standards, and this tree was of no real historical significance. But it's older than any of those structures you describe.

The brutalist structures might one day be beloved. Perhaps a few centuries from now. They're certainly built for it; one problem with them is that they're hard to demolish. (And often lousy air flow, which is hard to retrofit because the walls are literally artificial rock.)

Ugly things can get some sentiment once you see it as "yours". Time can do that. Notions of beauty change, and things go in and out of fashion. Even trees have been seen as ugly at various points, when what people wanted was to tear it all down and build things.

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#14
I wish the tree had not been felled. A very sad and poignant act.

Also, as I pointed out in another conversation here, and in the name of reciprocal repetition will do so again here, it is quite easy to find reports of equally heartbroken locals, the world over, lamenting the deliberate felling of any number of special, beloved, prominent trees, in the name of the routine building of a new road or factory or housing development in humanitys continual march of progress.

With one single tree evoking this much emotion, it is little wonder that in general we struggle to view mass environmental destruction as anything other than an abstract, distant notion. How could we mentally handle it, otherwise??

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#15

Is the motive behind the felling still unknown?

The motive behind many crimes is never found out. Turns out that even if the accused did have a logical motive for committing the crime, they tend to not reveal it to investigators to have a better chance at not going to prison.

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#17
In the old days young people (mostly boys) would to stupid things to make their friends laugh; i can help to feel like that social networks elevate that behavior up to eleven.

People now a days do all kinds of stupid shirt just to get views. I think the destruction of this tree was an example of that.

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#18
post #17

In the old days young people (mostly boys) would to stupid things to make their friends laugh; i can help to feel like that social networks elevate that behavior up to eleven. People now a days do all kinds of stupid shirt just to get views. I think the destruction of this tree was an example of that.

people have been doing shitty things for a very long time.

people have been talking about how "things are worse nowadays" also for a very long time.

not much to do now other than try to science it back into existence, replace it with a similar one, plant a new one and wait or declare it done and move on.

Re: The Sycamore Gap tree held a particularly deep place in people's hearts

#19

In my community: I love the cutsie pootsie Victorians everywhere, the time-capsule 1910s look. Some people want to make it easier to demolish this stuff and build whatever house you want - the rule is you have to keep the facade or whatever - and I sympathize with that. But nobody gives a fuck about the brutalist structures being torn down, like the VA in Chicago or the Federal Building in Boston, because they're ugl…

You may not have noticed, but objects literally have no value beyond what people think of them. If a community thinks a building is significant, it is.

[dead]
Post reply on HN