Live data from Hacker News

CancelQuora

interestingauthors.com

21–30 of 74 posts

Re: CancelQuora

#21

Do people actually use Quora?

A hell of a lot of people, mostly in South Asia (India, Pakistan, Bangladesh). The public perception there about Quora is that it’s a great and informative community. It’s from my experience not regarded as spam.

It used to be there in India, not anymore. It had its peak 7-8 years ago, now it just a place with low quality content and dozens of paywalls.

Re: CancelQuora

#23
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google problem is that appending reddit is the only reliable way to get something different from shitty copywrited SEO trash sites. I don't know when I last saw real independent websites and blogs in the search results, probably ten years ago?..

I agree to this one. Google is often pointing to websites that haven’t been updated in years, or reused their content from 2008 by adding 2023 at the end of the headline

The clear example of quality vs. quantity. Quora definitely wins in terms of quantity.

Re: CancelQuora

#24
post #11

> Quora is a hunk of shit to be avoided. Hopefully it will go under soon. Unlikely. Google recently added more than 100M search traffic to Quora[0] (and Reddit, and LinkedIn and other garbage UGC sites) because they don't know how to address the "people appending reddit" problem. They literally threw legitimate content creators under the bus and are now _forcing_ searchers to go to Quora and all these are low-quality…

People add reddit to searches because it gives high quality answers. That’s not a Google problem. That’s a problem with the Internet. Your average independent website or blog puts up some heavily biased answer that is just limited to that one writer’s perspective.

Spammy low quality websites in a large proportion of searches isn't a Google problem? I'm sure that will reassure them when someone comes along with a search engine that solves that problem and people start moving to it from Google. "Not our problem!" they'll say as their traffic dwindles.

Re: CancelQuora

#25
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google problem is that appending reddit is the only reliable way to get something different from shitty copywrited SEO trash sites. I don't know when I last saw real independent websites and blogs in the search results, probably ten years ago?..

I agree to this one. Google is often pointing to websites that haven’t been updated in years, or reused their content from 2008 by adding 2023 at the end of the headline

At least it's better than how MS handles its documentation. The number of times I've hit "404 fuck you" when looking for info on their products...

Re: CancelQuora

#26
Somehow I ended up on Quora's spam list, and despite my many requests, they refuse to unsubscribe me. What I see come through as the subject of those daily e-mails is a constant trickle of inflammatory pseudo-questions, and not infrequently paedo-/incest-adjacent ragebait, intended to provoke engagement. Someone or some algo that someone owns is curating this crap and believes that it's OK that it goes out as the "face of the company" to whoever is on their spam list.

Examples:

- 3 Sept: "I caught my 13 year old daughter using pads for her period without my permission. What do I do now?"

- 24 August: "My 15-year-old son punched his pregnant baby sitter’s belly and she punched him back. She now has a miscarriage and my son has a bruise. Is she wrong for this?"

- 23 August: "My 15-year-old step daughter told me to wash her back in the shower. What should I do?"

- 21 August: "I caught my 14-year-old son and his friend’s 41 year old dad holding hands. Should I be concerned?"

This site is garbage, and some of its users clearly are, as well. Go ahead and cancel it, for all I care.

Re: CancelQuora

#27

Before Stackoverflow, they were pretty good. Once they started the anti-pattern of requiring registration to view answers, the quality went down hill pretty quick. In the last few years, my workplace added them to their blocklist. I didn't realize that one of the reasons was Quora is very spammy with emails.

Adding the requirement to register in order to see the answers I think was major mistake. I remember multiple times coming to quora from google and after just closing the page because of it.

Re: CancelQuora

#28
In the early days of Quora, it was a lot of fun. I remember asking questions and getting answers from Olympic athletes, college professors, and other true experts.

I actually made friends on Quora.

Then they tried to monetize it in various ways (and I don't mind paying for things!) and it went downhill fast. Just junk questions and answers, and a lot of fringe political ideas and topics, and people promoting their MLM businesses.

Re: CancelQuora

#30
post #11

> Quora is a hunk of shit to be avoided. Hopefully it will go under soon. Unlikely. Google recently added more than 100M search traffic to Quora[0] (and Reddit, and LinkedIn and other garbage UGC sites) because they don't know how to address the "people appending reddit" problem. They literally threw legitimate content creators under the bus and are now _forcing_ searchers to go to Quora and all these are low-quality…

People add reddit to searches because it gives high quality answers. That’s not a Google problem. That’s a problem with the Internet. Your average independent website or blog puts up some heavily biased answer that is just limited to that one writer’s perspective.

> Your average independent website or blog puts up some heavily biased answer that is just limited to that one writer’s perspective.

That also describes each individual Reddit comment. Reddit's magic is that it places them all next to one another for easy comparison.

Post reply on HN