Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 91 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#72
Pretty happy with my existing workflow. It started out with a photo organization script a couple of years ago that I ran manually and has now developed into a fully automatic system.

1. syncthing uploads photos from my phone to my NAS (receive only)

2. scheduled systemd service (hourly) on my NAS reads newly received photos, renames them by date, moves it to my photos catalog

3. photoprism starts a scan of the photo library (triggered by systemd when 2. finishes)

4. weekly systemd service syncs the library to backblaze

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#73
I use imagemagick for that

cd myphotodir

montage -geometry 1024x768+0+1 -tile 4x3 -background Dim\ Gray *.JPG myresume.jpg

Take care of not having a file named 'myresume.jpg' in that dir or it will be overwritten. Modify the parameters to suit your needs.

To remove duplicates or n-plicates in the current directory tree use rdfind

rdfind -deleteduplicates true .

All photos are renamed with perl to include the timestamp in the filename. Thus If I want to see for example all photos of 27 sept in any year, a simple bash command connecting find with eog will do the job. I can pass then the list of photos to imagemagick. Very useful to see grow changes in the garden or in children birthdays for example.

And then perl is connected with postgresql

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#74
post #57

I don't take many photos, because the act of taking a picture removes me from being present for whatever it is I'm taking the picture of, and thus reduces my enjoyment of things. But my wife takes a gazillion photos of everything. I organize them in a directory hierarchy by date, on my NAS. I also run a private wiki at home, and have pages of "special collections" of certain photos by subject matter/event/ whatever t…

I think that's an interesting point about being present. I actually love the act of taking photos, adjusting the colors and lighting to capture how it looked, and then I rarely look at them again. My wife thinks it's bizarre, but it's not the reflection on the past, but the act of photography I like. I've turned some into prints and have a digital picture frame to scroll them through, but sitting down to reflect and look through them rarely happens.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#75
Yes, I think it's digital clutter. I expect this is not a widespread behavior, but I haven't taken a photo in 15 years except when required to in order to make a home insurance claim and I snap the parking lot at the airport every time I travel in order to remember where I parked. I'm not going to forget my kids and, frankly, I think they deserve some level of autonomy and privacy not often granted to children. You have no idea how embarrassed they may be in the future and whether they really want those pictures to exist. But when I said this publicly to a friend who was constantly spamming naked photos of her twins to social media, she became no longer a friend, so I understand it's a sensitive subject.

You said yourself you never look at these. People storing multiple terabytes to a NAS and cloud backups likely don't have the time left in their remaining lifespan to ever look at everything they're storing. It's digital hoarding.

On the other hand, I don't think it's completely valueless to at least record a few special occasions. I appreciated a few Christmases back after my mom digitized all of the Betamax tapes from when I was a kid that she had taped my sister's birthday where one of my very first friends was present and singing along and playing with us, since that friend died when we were 12 and I haven't seen her in three decades. One video was enough, though. I don't need a number of photos I couldn't look through if I had until the heat death of the universe.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#76
I had the same problems as my elderly parents living abroad are not social media users.

So I decided to create a sort of private Google photos meeting Google drive.

It is called Memories (I realised FB have the same idea) and it can be found at https://m.emori.es

I would be happy to provide beta access in return for constructive feedbacks.

If you are interested, send me an email to alain AT aoware DOT co DOT uk

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#78
I just get a phone with big storage, right now using an iphone with 1 TB.

And I discover I actually use the photos a lot: - through the geo-location map of all photos - when I am trying to remember something, show somebody a specific memory, nudge my memory about a place or region I have visited, a hiking trail that I've followed, that view from that LA trip, etc. - through iOS photo search - it is not perfect but in 60% of the cases I actually find what I am looking for - random highlights that the OS gives me - I sometimes deep dive with Show in all photos and look at what I was doing back then

All my photos are synced in the cloud but I spend lots of time in the mountains, in the wilderness or travelling, so I prefer to have them all on my phone for the moments when internet connection is missing.

With all of these I actually feel very connected to my whole photo library.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#79
Big cardboard box, hdds, thousands of photos, sd cards, dvds, ect.

The Cloud is no solution at all, they're a revisionist nightmare.

I'd honestly prefer all my most valuable memories, from my family tree, on physical media, buried in a filing cabinet with a sign that says 'beware the tiger' in the basement of some forgotten farmstead, built on rock, a million miles from Jeff Bezos.

It's safe there. Everything else is just constant churn.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage photos, philosophically?

#80
post #32

Somewhat less philosophically: there is a huge technological problem in keeping photo archives. We entrust our photos to companies like Apple and Google with the attention span of a fruit fly — nobody seems to give any thought to long-term archival. Solutions appear and disappear within several years. Also, all current photo library solutions are deficient and built mostly for a single flashy keynote presentation, no…

Current Photos app can actually import these libraries. Click on “import” and select the aperture file. It should keep all the albums, metadata, etc.

Photos has no concept of a "stack" of versions.
Post reply on HN