Live data from Hacker News

Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

farewell.bostonunitygroup.com

211–220 of 465 posts

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#211

Unity really showing the world how to tank a business by letting a few MBA’s at the top make a decision for profit.

Expect MBAs to show up here condemning the derogatory use of MBA

FWIW, I have an MBA and Unity's behaviour doesn't make sense to me either.

Oh... and... "Not all MBAs"

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#212
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Have never seen a company so quickly and completely just throw away all of their public good will. Over the past year Docker and D&D/Wizards of the Coast come to mind...

What happened with Docker? (WotC have been killing goodwill for years at this point, but I guess the MtG folks have a bad case of Stockholm Syndrome.)

"Docker is sunsetting Free Team organizations"

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35154025

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Have never seen a company so quickly and completely just throw away all of their public good will. Over the past year Docker and D&D/Wizards of the Coast come to mind...

Let’s not forget Reddit

Can't believe I omitted reddit and possibly stackoverflow...

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#214
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Have never seen a company so quickly and completely just throw away all of their public good will. Over the past year Docker and D&D/Wizards of the Coast come to mind...

What happened with Docker? (WotC have been killing goodwill for years at this point, but I guess the MtG folks have a bad case of Stockholm Syndrome.)

[deleted]

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#215
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Have never seen a company so quickly and completely just throw away all of their public good will. Over the past year Docker and D&D/Wizards of the Coast come to mind...

What happened with Docker? (WotC have been killing goodwill for years at this point, but I guess the MtG folks have a bad case of Stockholm Syndrome.)

WotC’s trust bonfire was about D&D, revoking the perpetual license OGL. That said I don’t contest that MtG players have Stockholm Syndrome.

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#216
post #5

"More importantly, we've seen how easily and flippantly an executive-led business decision can risk bankrupting the studios we've worked so hard to build, threaten our livelihoods as professionals, and challenge the longevity of our industry. The Unity of today isn't the same company that it was when the group was founded, and the trust we used to have in the company has been completely eroded." Profoundly sad, and c…

And the dumb thing is that if they had listened to the engineers who were telling them the customer base was going to freak out at this, the company could have avoided large parts of the drama, since a few of their fixes were not even really a change in plan, so much as better more clear wording. The big drama causes 1. People assuming unity was going to add additional telemetry to track installs. (Reality: Unity see…

And that's why people like Jonathan blow and Casey Muratori have for so many years now warned game devs about this and learn how to make a game engine from scratch. Hopefully some listened.

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#217

Best thing about this divisive action by Unity is all the attention it's giving Godot. It's a project that deserves far more attention, and I hope in a few years that it's far more common in popular game development.

Am I understanding correctly that due to licensing Godot can never support consoles?

If true that makes it so limited as to never be a replacement for Unity.

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#218
post #77
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But isn’t that as it should be? Just like you never step in the same river twice, you never do business with the same company twice. Staff and executives change over time, and companies shift for better or worse. Should we hold grudges against brands for things totally different people did 10? 20? 50? years ago? That seems weird to me. Unity specifically deserves loss of trust and all the pain they get. But in 5 year…

Does it depend on the company culture, which can persist awhile? For example, the first company that comes to mind has seemed to have shameless underhandedness deep in its DNA, and to exhibit its malevolent side each new chance it gets, as much as it can. This has repeated over the course of decades, and over multiple top leadership changes. If it's true that certain kinds of underhandedness are in that company's DNA…

The only fix is to burn Oracle to the very ground and sow the remnants with salt to ensure it doesn't regrow.

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#219

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I used to be able to buy amazing handmade items for reasonable prices and reasonable shipping from actual people running small storefronts on Etsy. Now it’s just another e-commerce site that’s been completely and utterly overrun with marked up Aliexpress junk and low quality copies of anything novel that gains the slightest bit of popularity. The few remaining authentic sellers now charge so much it’s laughable unles…

Where do you find authentic sellers?

I'm assuming you're being sardonic, but remarkably it's still a great place to buy live cuttings of succulents and other plants from enthusiasts.

In contrast to buying seeds off Amazon or eBay, where the plants that sellers are claiming they're shipping you seeds for are often just random weeds rather than the hilariously photoshopped or non-existent flowers/fruits shown in the product listing.

e.g. https://www.amazon.ca/Glamaours-Climbing-Strawberry-Deliciou...

or

https://www.amazon.ca/Rosepoem-100pcs-rainbow-vegetable-Non-...

Re: Unity's oldest community announces dissolution

#220
post #5

"More importantly, we've seen how easily and flippantly an executive-led business decision can risk bankrupting the studios we've worked so hard to build, threaten our livelihoods as professionals, and challenge the longevity of our industry. The Unity of today isn't the same company that it was when the group was founded, and the trust we used to have in the company has been completely eroded." Profoundly sad, and c…

Yes they threw it all away when they could just have continued subsidising video games and losing millions every year
Post reply on HN