Live data from Hacker News

A Pinterest spammer tells all

dailydot.com

41–50 of 118 posts

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#41

As Google is killing more and more content farms, it makes sense spammers are moving towards sites that have tons of authority, and spamming there. Can't get "buy car insurance" to rank for your spamblog? No problem, create a fake question in Yahoo Answers with the keywords in your title, and a fake answer with your affiliate link. Repeat in Pinterest, Amazon Askville, Quora, etc.

Affiliate links are filtered out of Yahoo Answers, or at least they were 4 or 5 years ago when I posted one.

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#43
post #6

An easy way to find Pinterest spammers. http://pinterest.com/source/amazon.com/ I think the spammer moved his affiliate tag to womansdesign-20.

How are they not picking it up as spam? The same affiliate link from multiple accounts... The description also looks like a snippet of one the product reviews on Amazon

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#44

Frankly this sounds like what Pinterest should be doing for revenue. Isn't basically what promoted tweets are for Twitter?

Promoted tweets are a fucking scourge, at least so far. I've seen two - both times for something totally irrelevant to me. (What the hell is the Shell Houston 2012 Open? I have zero idea, and less than zero interest.)

The few promoted tweets I have seen were frighteningly targeted.

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#45
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It sounds like he only has one Amazon Associates account. Identifying all his accounts would be trivial, then -- find all accounts that have posted an Amazon link with the same associate ID in the URL.

Most of the experienced spammers fake the referrer. They'll have a scrub site setup which will appear as any blog. The spammer will spam links to the blog page (often using a url shortener); however the link will contain a id. If you visit the page with the id it will selectively redirect traffic to their amazon affiliate link, without the id link it will appear as a normal blogpost. Amazon will think the traffic com…

All they'd have to do is add a captcha to the submit. Trivial to implement and it would reduce the spammers.

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#46

So-called "skimming" of links does not strike me as being terribly wrong (or different from what Pinterest does itself), but the practice likely still undercuts their bizmodel because they don't skim links that already have affiliate ids attached to them.

It seems to me that it's pretty dumb to leave the affiliate ids attached. If anything, I think their initial idea of replacing affiliate links with their own affiliate smart. People don't like it, they can use another site.

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#47
post #31

Does anyone know if Steve's actions are legal under United States law?

I don't think it violates any specific law, but I'm guessing that a prosecutor could come up with some charges if the website hired good enough lawyers. Charges similar to the ones you see for denial of service or computer fraud.

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#48
post #31

Does anyone know if Steve's actions are legal under United States law?

I don't think it violates any specific law, but I'm guessing that a prosecutor could come up with some charges if the website hired good enough lawyers. Charges similar to the ones you see for denial of service or computer fraud.

There's also FTC disclosures to worry about, although I'm not sure if it covers posting affiliate links to another site.

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#49

> we found tons of bots that traced to your Amazon affiliate account This suggest a trivial fix for the problem on Pinterest's side, doesn't it?

I think he is using URL shorteners or custom URLs that looks like a blog but are a redirect to an affiliate URL. Now they'd have to start examining the URLs in detail, which is a lot harder. Especially if he cloaks for access that looks to be coming from Pinterest themselves.

Re: A Pinterest spammer tells all

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It sounds like he only has one Amazon Associates account. Identifying all his accounts would be trivial, then -- find all accounts that have posted an Amazon link with the same associate ID in the URL.

Amazon Associates allows you to create unlimited, unique affiliate IDs, tied to one AA account.

Partly true, but they're not unlimited; there's a maximum of 100 per account, and once created they can't be deleted, so it's 100 lifetime.
Post reply on HN