Live data from Hacker News

Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

mwmbl.org

51–60 of 129 posts

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#51

This and the other engines seem to implement all the components of crawling, indexing, and searching strung together. Is there a reason for this? Wouldn't an option of, let's say, crawling + indexing made available separately, where others could built a search algorithm on top of, or just the crawling as a service made available. Are there stuff like these already available? Or is it just not a viable option?

[deleted]

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#53
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't need to remember it, just bookmark and tag however you like (it's anyway a waste of keystrokes to manual type the full domain for such a frequently used site like a search engine)

That is not how a large part of the citizens on the internet works. Hell, a not insignificant number of people will still "search" for Google in their address bar before they get to the actual googling

Except I'm not talking to a large part of the citizens, but to a single one. Do you type 'google.com' in your address bar to search?

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#54
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

really? like mumble? [0] [0] https://mumble.info

According to government records, the only names not yet trademarked are "Popplers" and "Zittzers"

Not for long! Someone ought to make a Popplers fastfood chain.

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#55
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m from Wales and it almost seems like a transliteration of the word “Mumble” - actual translation is “mwmial”

Welsh has the unfortunate combination of being unfamiliar to most English speakers, and not exotic enough to score diversity points.

On that topic I love the Welsh-English encounter of civil servants thinking they understood each other[0]

[0] http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7702913.stm

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#56
post #15

I wondered if this approach would be feasible for a distributed crawler: https://github.com/mwmbl/mwmbl#crawling Also, your own posting appears to be missing from the index: https://mwmbl.org/?q=mwmbl+ycombinator (and, yes, another vote for changing the domain name; you can have a quirky project name, but if I can't remember the cat-walking-on-keyboard domain, I'm not going to use it)

I’m from Wales and it almost seems like a transliteration of the word “Mumble” - actual translation is “mwmial”

But Mumble brings back fond memories https://www.mumble.info/

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#57

This and the other engines seem to implement all the components of crawling, indexing, and searching strung together. Is there a reason for this? Wouldn't an option of, let's say, crawling + indexing made available separately, where others could built a search algorithm on top of, or just the crawling as a service made available. Are there stuff like these already available? Or is it just not a viable option?

Crawling can be done collaboratively, but there's not a lot of point to doing this. Crawling is the cheap and easy part.

As for the rest, in order to perform well, the indexer needs to be built specifically tailored to the what the search engine is doing. Often you're scrounging for places to cram in individual bits to encode some additional piece of information about the term.

If a DBMS tries to support every use case, a search engine index does the opposite, it supports a singular use case and cuts every corner imaginable and then some to make that happen with as much resource frugality as possible.

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#58

This and the other engines seem to implement all the components of crawling, indexing, and searching strung together. Is there a reason for this? Wouldn't an option of, let's say, crawling + indexing made available separately, where others could built a search algorithm on top of, or just the crawling as a service made available. Are there stuff like these already available? Or is it just not a viable option?

There is common crawl: https://github.com/commoncrawl

Kinda sucks that it's stuck in AWS with no easy way of exfiltrating the data from the Amazon ecosystem. Last I tried I got like 100 Kb/s on their HTTP mirror. At that rate, the download would take 12 years.

Re: Mwmbl: Free, open-source and non-profit search engine

#60
A lot of the terms I searched for returned no hits. The Firefox add-on crawls pages linked from Hacker News which is amusing perhaps but seems unlikely to crawl a representative selection of the web. Perhaps the user should be able to suggest pages to be crawled.

But when it does find something it is very quick! So I'll give it a go.

Post reply on HN