Live data from Hacker News

Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 74 posts

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#11
post #4

Because bitcoin worked out so well. Have fun with that, dude.

There are many hard startup problems (autonomous robotics, craigslist competitors) which have had people crash upon the rocks in pursuit them. Does that automatically make them stupid to try? Bitcoin's failures don't mean all non-state issued digital currencies will fail.

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#12
post #9

a little unfair to tack this response on to this particular post, but it reminds me (again) how much time people spend on the outward appearance of apps around alternative currency without addressing the part that's actually hard.. how do you give an alternative currency real value?

>how do you give an alternative currency real value?

That's not your job. People either will, or they won't.

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#13
post #10

What dmix & potatolicious said, plus: - The killer app in this space is whether you have an answer to "Why can a startup displace the incumbents?" and "How are you going to get people using this?" The answer to the second must be understandable by my dry cleaner, who would not trust bitcoin even if it were issued by the US Treasury. The prototype at this stage is probably about as useful as PayPal's first prototype (…

On that second item, writing & proofing: it might help to use a word-processor that includes a grammar-checker. Spell-check alone is not sufficient to catch things like

"It's killer app will be in" => should be "Its"

"Their going to (at first) offer them" => should be "They're"

"along side" => should be "alongside"

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#14

What dmix said. Why are you using a throwaway account? A co-founder relationship is very important, and my willingness to join you on this venture has less to do with your idea and more to do with you . Specifically: - Who are you, and what have you done? - What is your professional and personal experience, and what does it bring to the table in a general sense of running a startup, and in a specific sense, this idea…

It's a good point - I added some details under dmix's comment. Thanks!

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#15
post #10

What dmix & potatolicious said, plus: - The killer app in this space is whether you have an answer to "Why can a startup displace the incumbents?" and "How are you going to get people using this?" The answer to the second must be understandable by my dry cleaner, who would not trust bitcoin even if it were issued by the US Treasury. The prototype at this stage is probably about as useful as PayPal's first prototype (…

Thanks! Fixed some grammar items, you're right about that.

For your dry cleaner I would say: How much do you pay now per transaction for credit cards? Would you like to pay x instead?

They probably won't care or think about digital currency, but they might think "low fees". There is value even if only a few people use it at first. Obviously that is just the tip of the iceberg, but for anyone interested happy to talk more.

Thanks for the feedback.

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#16

I agree with potatolicious and dmix. Also, what's the difference between "Bitbank", Paypal, Stripe, etc. What makes this idea unique?

Paypal, Stripe, Square etc all use credit cards which cost 2.x% plus 30 cents. Bitbank uses a digital currency with low or no fees. It's more competing with Visa/Mastercard than with Paypal, Stripe, etc. Those companies could become partners actually if they decided to support it as another payment method.

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#18

What dmix said. Why are you using a throwaway account? A co-founder relationship is very important, and my willingness to join you on this venture has less to do with your idea and more to do with you . Specifically: - Who are you, and what have you done? - What is your professional and personal experience, and what does it bring to the table in a general sense of running a startup, and in a specific sense, this idea…

The irony is he's using a throwaway even though his identity is not concealed. If you visit the website address in the screenshots, click "help" and then take the name listed and google it you have a full profile on the guy...

[deleted]

Re: Apply with me to YC in the next 3 days and change the world

#20
Paypal had enormous problems with fraud that almost killed them (and did kill their competitors).

I think Bitcoin is awesome, but it offers users no protection - it's more of a cash replacement than a credit card replacement. This is something that might end up being difficult to handle (something to make sure users will understand).

Post reply on HN