Live data from Hacker News

The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

arstechnica.com

41–50 of 85 posts

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#41

What's wrong with this? Isn't it great that miniaturization can achieve this? It's the screen size that dictates the amount of room. I also prefer a larger desktop PC case to have spare room to make it easier to work in it.

> What's wrong with this? Missed the opportunity to put in a bigger battery

But for increased cost to the consumer. I'm sure they businessed the idea.

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#42
I think this design make sense when you treat the tablet as a home fixture that happens to be able to move around. Of course you could take it with you but it isn't what the product is designed around.

The larger screen makes sense when it is used as stationary cast target while docked and allows for larger home control touch targets when your hand is floating above a stationary display.

The smaller and lighter battery makes sense because the device gets maximum value when its always returned to its dock so that its available to serve its smart home control purpose. Is it really worth having a heavier device to go beyond 12 hours straight video playback without ever going back to the dock?

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#43

I'm a bit puzzled by the tone of the piece in that the author frames it as a critique yet also points out how much easier it is to repair. I was anticipating some literal 2.5" SSD-like empty husk.

No need to actually read any Google articles by Ron Amadeo. They are all cut from the same smug, snarky dismissive cloth.

Ars can and should try harder.

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#44
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In most tablets the extra space is filled with more battery, better cooling, bigger speakers, SD card slot, more ports… lots of possibilities. Here’s what the inside of a 2020 iPad Air (10.9”) looks like for example. Still a little empty space, but much more full. https://i.ibb.co/hRKhPRP/IMG-2853.jpg

The OG IPad: https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Image/meta/y5HAM4cflO64B3QH

But it's Apple so it's perfect!

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#45

I'm a bit puzzled by the tone of the piece in that the author frames it as a critique yet also points out how much easier it is to repair. I was anticipating some literal 2.5" SSD-like empty husk.

I couldn't get through the first two paragraphs, this tried so hard to make a problem out of nothing. "Miles between", "never seen" - why do I care what this guy has seen before? The specs are what they are, it's not a scam (well, the article is anyway).

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#46

I'm a bit puzzled by the tone of the piece in that the author frames it as a critique yet also points out how much easier it is to repair. I was anticipating some literal 2.5" SSD-like empty husk.

Tech news sites post shitty takes. More news at 11.

Really though, in Poland spidersweb.pl is a meme just from it inception a decade ago. It's the same everywhere.

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#48
post #9

Isn’t the reason for the empty space just because it’s a tablet — by which I mean that the dimensions are determined by a large screen? Phones are dense inside because they have to be small.

In most tablets the extra space is filled with more battery, better cooling, bigger speakers, SD card slot, more ports… lots of possibilities. Here’s what the inside of a 2020 iPad Air (10.9”) looks like for example. Still a little empty space, but much more full. https://i.ibb.co/hRKhPRP/IMG-2853.jpg

The iPad's aluminum-alloy case probably conducts heat much better than the Pixel Tablet's plastic case. For all we know, the designers of the latter left voids around the components to improve thermal management.

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#49
post #17
post #6

Is the sparse interior really that strange, or just a result of components getting more compact and the screen remaining the same size?

Yeah, I never viewed this as a "flagship device". Everything you could stuff into those voids is a choice with poor tradeoffs. - Bigger battery: More cost, more weight. And who has battery issues with a tablet anyway? Mine lasts forever. - Performance: More cost and doesn't actually require much more volume - Storage, RAM: Much more cost and not really how Pixels operate, sadly. - Better camera: Who does this on a ta…

And to add to that list:

- Different versions with any combinations of those things: I'm sure they did the analysis and determined the market wouldn't support that.

Re: The Pixel Tablet is just a few spare parts in a half-empty body

#50
post #47

It reminds me of the original iPhone. That didn't have much empty space, but it did look like a box of random junk haphazardly slapped together.

I'll grant you that it's not as packed as current iPhones but it still looks pretty dense and layered https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPhone+1st+Generation+Teardo...
Post reply on HN