Live data from Hacker News

The Tyranny of the Marginal User

nothinghuman.substack.com

601–610 of 840 posts

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#601

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Now, let's find any single company/product that actually is successful by encouraging us to become better versions of ourselves.

In apps: Ten Percent Happier and Headspace? In meatspace: Nike, Adidas?

Sport gear companies? Just selling you a lifestyle and an identity. Meditation apps feel more like someone exploiting a fad than some with an actual interest in your wellbeing.

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#602
post #587
post #575

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I first got online the average user’s IQ was no joke north of 120. Now of course it’s around 100. Someone needs to come up with a pithy term for how a subpopulation’s average value for any attribute approaches the population’s average value for same as the subpopulation’s size approaches that of the population. It’s conceptually a simple, even trivial, notion, but it’s cumbersome to talk about. That’s also why u…

Isn’t that just Eternal September? At least in the internet

Smartphones was the final nail, after that close to 100% of young adults are active online participants.

The good thing is that things aren't getting worse at least, all the idiots are already online.

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#603

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find I comment and write much less on mobile than on a computer, because the writing experience on mobile is still very sub-par.

This is very true. And now think of all the people who's only Internet experience is on mobile. They exist entirely within that sub-par writing universe.

I actually feel really bad for the younger generation, actually. There's a whole bunch of teenagers who have no idea how good and useful computers can actually be, because all they ever have known is the shitty watered down mobile version of computing. Even desktops aren't as good as they used to be (thanks, Electron), but they're still a damn sight better than mobile. But if one grew up thinking that a phone/tablet is the end-all of computing, they have no idea what they're even missing.

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#604
post #478

This is a hilarious read but I think the author is too optimistic about the state of humanity. Marl isn't the "marginal" user, Marl is the "average" user. If the average user actually cared about deep and meaningful content, then any A/B test that throws her under the bus in order to please Marl will show bad data, and the proposed change would be killed. Yes, the author tries to hand-wave this away as "product is st…

The penultimate paragraph of the article says almost exactly this

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#605
Is the problem more fundamental? Investor controlled/focused businesses are just bad for users and companies in the long run? Especially if investors have short term goals. Some of the easiest ways to make more money is to squeeze the users(more ads) or reduce product quality to the bare minimum as long as it lasts long enough to meet contractual needs. All this at the cost of the user/company.

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#606
post #587
post #575

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I first got online the average user’s IQ was no joke north of 120. Now of course it’s around 100. Someone needs to come up with a pithy term for how a subpopulation’s average value for any attribute approaches the population’s average value for same as the subpopulation’s size approaches that of the population. It’s conceptually a simple, even trivial, notion, but it’s cumbersome to talk about. That’s also why u…

Isn’t that just Eternal September? At least in the internet

Can we reverse Eternal Eptember? Can we create IQnet just for nerds?

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#607
post #587

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn’t that just Eternal September? At least in the internet

Smartphones was the final nail, after that close to 100% of young adults are active online participants. The good thing is that things aren't getting worse at least, all the idiots are already online.

Only about half the humans are on the internet.

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#608
post #177

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a very good point that I think some commenters here should take to heart. No matter how enlightened we think we are, we're all part of the masses and behave this way at one point or another.

The reason it works is because they've done the research to make it work. It isn't a coincidence DAUs increase. I think it is important to recognize that it can impact you, and take steps to account for that, even if - or especially if - you don't want it to. You are not immune to propaganda, and all that.

In German the DAU is the "dumbest assumed user", the worst case consideration when designing UI. My impression is that if you try to increase DAUs, you often increase both types.

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#609
post #196

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Alternatively and more seriously, I do hope to see markets emerge that target power users. I'm not optimistic though. What's crazy to me is that 25+ million people on this Earth can program, and how many of them get to decide the UIs that everyone else uses? I myself, suck at UI programming. But that's because UI programming is labyrinthine, arcane, and generally requires becoming an expert in a number of extremely…

>Why can't I rip apart the UI of an app I use every day and rearrange it the way I want? And I mean, far more than toolbars and rearranging drop down menus. (BTW, remember those? Those were great). IMO there's no reason you can't. Just yesterday I was playing with pavucontrol and thought "There needs to be a GNU Radio like view, where I can drop boxes which represent sound generating/taking programs/devices and draw…

From what I hear, PulseAudio inherently lacks the architecture to create arbitrary audio routing graphs. PipeWire can do it for audio with apps like Helvum and QPWGraph, but not for all windows (only webcams and perhaps screen sharing). The view does get confusing as the number of apps/nodes increases though. One point of confusion is that in Helvum, Pulse apps have a playback and monitor node (and the monitor is a copy of the input), but JACK apps have an input and output (where the output is the result of the app applying effects to the input, or an unrelated audio stream altogether). I'm not sure where native PipeWire apps lie.

Re: The Tyranny of the Marginal User

#610
post #352

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple absolutely does do this. I have first hand knowledge of doing it for them.

Sounds like something you probably should not be talking about on the internet with your real name?

I'm allowed to say that much. I know my NDAs very well.
Post reply on HN