Live data from Hacker News

A Texas semiconductor boom on the horizon?

news.utexas.edu

61–65 of 65 posts

Re: A Texas semiconductor boom on the horizon?

#61
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not really, hysteresis is definitely a thing for hugely expertise and capital intensive projects like ramping up bleeding edge semiconductor fabrication.

I get "[economic] boom on the horizon [near future]". But the phrase "boom on the horizon" invokes imagery of mushroom clouds.

Not really

Re: A Texas semiconductor boom on the horizon?

#62
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why is it ridiculous for an intro-level course to not require people to manually compute integrals? I'm open to the idea that maybe I'm wrong about this being reasonable, but "I had to do it so everyone else should have to too" is not a very convincing argument. To be clear, I had already placed out of the calculus course that would have taught how to evaluate these integrals, so I wouldn't have been disadvantaged by…

For the same reason not grinding out the code by hand and copying from your LLM is going to result in you being a less competent programmer in the long run. I really believe there is something to be said for putting yourself through the mental strain of evaluating the integrals (or code) and that doing so contributes to you having a better feel for how it works on a conceptual level as well, you don't just get better…

I guess I just fundamentally disagree with you on this one. To me, spending time manually calculating integrals in a timed exam is less similar to copying code from an LLM and more similar to manually translating the source code you write into machine code instead of using a compiler; it might have value, but the amount of work it would take a student in an intro class to do that would drown out their ability to retain anything else.

Re: A Texas semiconductor boom on the horizon?

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They just had a big power crisis (summer AC, maximum GWh usage) and survived.

Is that supposed to be reassuring? Why not choose a state with better energy management, so "recently survived an energy crisis" isn't even part of the conversation?

Because there aren't any of those. New York utilities have multiple similar events per summer, for example, as does California.

https://www.caiso.com/Documents/intensifying-heat-leads-to-a...

Re: A Texas semiconductor boom on the horizon?

#64
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They just had a big power crisis (summer AC, maximum GWh usage) and survived.

They've had multiple power crises recently in which survival was in question, so the particular outcome in the last one says less than the expected frequency for more borderline events in the future.

There will be more such events because temperatures that used to top out at 103 now top out at 110 F.

There is some silliness with the state government around renewable power, but it isn't like they've banned it. And if they did it would take #2 California a long time to catch up.

https://insideclimatenews.org/news/09032023/inside-clean-ene...

The question then is really whether Texas has a better chance of expanding capacity fast enough to meet its needs than other states that are famously more restrictive around new construction and environmental impacts. I don't like the politics here and I still think the answer to that is clearly yes for this purpose.

Whoever mentioned water has a point though.

Re: A Texas semiconductor boom on the horizon?

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, even before LLMs, the more advanced TI calcs like the TI-nspire can have Calc and Physics apps loaded on them that make tests trivial to cheat on.

That's why they were banned back when I took the tests. Have they loosened the restrictions on the n-spire? The standard back in the early 2010s was still definitely TI-84 being about the most powerful calculator you could use for most tests that mattered. Those calculators are intentionally kept slow by TI because of these requirements. My impression of the n-spire was that it had always been marketed much more towa…

No, they're still banned, but I got one early on when they were first released before they were consistently banned, and I realized shortly after that you could load some apps on there that basically allowed you to plug questions in and get the answer, since many problems are formulaic.
Post reply on HN