Live data from Hacker News

How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

wired.com

11–20 of 45 posts

Re: How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

#11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the internet has made a quantitative, not qualitative change to the dynamics of luck. There are still great ideas dying in coffee shops. They're just dying on reddit too.

The point is the size of the audience - there's usually more people in any given reddit forum than in your average coffee shop :) And _that_ is caused by a qualitative change - physical proximity has become way less important.

Yes, but physical proximity has been steadily growing less important for thousands of years.

It used to be that you needed to convince Ugg, the big man of your tribe. Then you had to travel to Babylon -- or instead send clay tablets. Then you could be heard in Alexandria from Rome if papyrus copies of your words were transcribed and shipped. Eventually the printing press, telegraph and regular steam train schedules meant information about your speech in Paris could be news in Berlin in hours.

Today, in a few seconds, I put my hypothesis on the nature of the internet to a few hundred strangers scattered across the globe.

That's what I mean by a quantitative change. At each step, the number of people you could potentially reach has increased; the cost of doing so has fallen. I don't see it as a qualitative change, though, I see it as a series of smaller stepwise improvements.

Re: How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

#13
I've run across Prufrock451 before on the Paradox gaming boards, where he was known years ago as one of the most creative AAR (After Action Report) writers.

Two of his most popular works, both dating from 2002:

- WAAR of the Worlds, in which aliens invade (and are then repulsed by another player who alternated game sessions with Prufrock451). http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?44563-WAA...

- The Great Game Redux - Sibir, whose plot bears a striking resemblance to Rome Sweet Rome. A Englishman in 1909 is transported to Siberia in 1419 and attempts to transform the tribes into a modern country. http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?35699-The...

Both were written against a backdrop of a (heavily modified) game of Europa Universalis 2 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_Universalis_II).

Re: How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

#14
With four or five ideas, Madhouse said hmm.

Come on Wired, you can't use "hmm" as a noun - it at least needs quotes!!

Twenty-five were immediate noes.

I think that's also highly questionable. But I'm not certain.

Of course, like any site that thrives on pseudonymity, Reddit attracts its share of the sick and the deluded. There’s a subreddit, MensRights, “for people who believe that men are currently being disadvantaged by society,” and for years the site admins tolerated subreddits devoted to pictures of underage girls.

What? How is MensRights "sick and deluded"? There really are laws (e.g. child custody law in certain US states) that are highly skewed against men.

Re: How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

#16
post #5

The brief version is: luck. The right idea was in front of the eyes of the right person at the right time. The idea is a staple of light sci-fi, but apparently has not crossed the desk of the right agents in the right mood. So: luck. Which is wildly underestimated as a cause of success.

Luck can be increased with frequency. The more often you put yourself out there, the greater the chance the right people/time/moods will align.

I believe that I should knock on all doors, be overjoyed at those that open, but not be crushed by those that don't. I knock on ALL doors to take my luck and turn it into opportunity.

Re: How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

#18

    By the end of his lunch hour, he had gotten as far as Day 6, but he didn’t want to post all the entries at once; what if no one read them? So he posted Day 2, then returned to his work, taking screenshots of software buttons and labeling them.
    ...
    Erwin dribbled out his story over the course of the afternoon, switching back and forth between Reddit and work.
What a lovely way of adapting the story so he wasn't on reddit all day instead of working.

Re: How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

#19
post #15

This reminds me of the Michael Criton book "Timeline" which was also made into a movie in 2003.

And "Time's Eye" by Stephen Baxter which features a battle between the Genghis Khan and a combined force of late-18th century British soldiers and 21st century UN peacekeepers.

Re: How One Response to a Reddit Query Became a Big Budget Flick

#20
I just see a Hollywood that ran out of ideas a long time ago and is desperate for a fresh story. The big movie pushes I've seen this year are John Carter, based on a character that first appeared a hundred years ago, and the Hunger Games, based on a book series that first appeared less than four years ago. Then I see a new Three Stooges film coming out that, among other crazy things, features an appearance of several Jersey Shore cast members. Many other big budget films this year are sequels: Wrath of the Titans, The Avengers, Men In Black 3, etc.

And here, Prufrock451 is a lucky one. Hollywood is starving for ideas, but even when innovative writers come up with a good idea, Hollywood prefers to go with established money-makers and often red-lights obscure ideas. I think they're so willing to go with Prufrock451's story because it got so popular on reddit. There's lower risk. They see that this story can attract a lot of eyeballs, and are hoping that those eyeballs will translate to box office success.

Hollywood likes to blame its decline on pirating, but in reality there are very few new ideas coming out of Hollywood anymore, and they expect to make money repackaging old ideas, putting them in 3D and charging a premium. Hopefully stories like Prufrock451's become more common and we get to see more original ideas make it to the big screen. I certainly don't want to see more movies with the old stooges and the new Jersey stooges.

Post reply on HN