Live data from Hacker News

Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

github.com

11–20 of 40 posts

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#11
post #7

"Just fill out this form with the very information you're trying to take down and submit it to our servers! It's not like we run a quasi-legal service based around monetizing this exact type of data!" What reason is there to trust that the more shady brokers aren't just updating your record with IP address + 'sent an opt-out request' flag, making the data even more valuable?

This! Plus some forms require an ID and I'm not trusting those people with that kind of documents

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#12
post #7

"Just fill out this form with the very information you're trying to take down and submit it to our servers! It's not like we run a quasi-legal service based around monetizing this exact type of data!" What reason is there to trust that the more shady brokers aren't just updating your record with IP address + 'sent an opt-out request' flag, making the data even more valuable?

one could change small things and tie the name to the service. It doesn't help much if you aren't a researcher.

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#14
post #7

"Just fill out this form with the very information you're trying to take down and submit it to our servers! It's not like we run a quasi-legal service based around monetizing this exact type of data!" What reason is there to trust that the more shady brokers aren't just updating your record with IP address + 'sent an opt-out request' flag, making the data even more valuable?

What reason is there to trust any provider when you don't have direct read access to their servers?

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#15
post #7

"Just fill out this form with the very information you're trying to take down and submit it to our servers! It's not like we run a quasi-legal service based around monetizing this exact type of data!" What reason is there to trust that the more shady brokers aren't just updating your record with IP address + 'sent an opt-out request' flag, making the data even more valuable?

I remember Twitter asking me to send them my photo ID to remove a tweet with my personal details (someone doxxed me). It's not like it wasn't obviously doxxing.

I won't miss Twitter one bit.

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#16
post #8

Out of curiosity I tried a few of the services on this list. They all follow the same textbook dark pattern, with fake progress bars, making the process of looking up someone artificially take several minutes, then only at the end do they ask for your email and payment information.

There's a few actually free sites that give you most of the info that the others charge you for. All the good ones I'm aware of are listed here. Free, no signup, instant search results.

The truly free ones tend to have a tab to search by just a phone number, and you'll never get a fake loading bar.

At one point they accurately listed every address I've ever lived at, relations, phone numbers, email addresses, and even some usernames I can only assume were linked to me as part of some database breach. A few years ago I went through and "opted out" of a bunch of these services for myself and a few of my family members. Looks like I'm still unlisted/removed 2-3 years later.

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#17
A lot of these have scary warnings like "If you ask us not to stalk you, YOU WILL NEVER QUALIFY FOR ANYTHING AGAIN!!!!!!11111one"

That sounds like puffery. Has anyone ever suffered a documented consequence along those lines?

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#18
post #3

I would pay three figures for someone to do this for me, for all these brokers. (I'm well aware that outsourcing the job carries its own risks... nonetheless there's an opportunity here.)

Check out Optery (YC Alum) removes ~250 data brokers (continuously). https://www.optery.com

Re: Big Ass Data Broker Opt-Out List

#19
post #7

"Just fill out this form with the very information you're trying to take down and submit it to our servers! It's not like we run a quasi-legal service based around monetizing this exact type of data!" What reason is there to trust that the more shady brokers aren't just updating your record with IP address + 'sent an opt-out request' flag, making the data even more valuable?

A lot of them let you look up the info they already have on you.

I don't see the harm in pasting in the info I can see they already have, in a request to remove it.

Post reply on HN