Live data from Hacker News

Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

arunraghavan.net

61–70 of 241 posts

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#61
post #48
post #16

There is also a specific subset of this problem named "USA conferences on themes from Technology Alert List" with common examples being information security conferences like DEFCON or BlackHat. Just mentioning such conference during visa application may already give you headache, and usually you work in this field if you go to such conference - working in critical field automatically gets you an administrative proces…

Sounds as if the current Cold War II situation keeps on escalating, people from a growing number of countries straight up won't be able to get visas for those conferences anymore.

Maybe fewer people being able to attend in person will force more conferences to take accessibility seriously. WWDC seems to have taken this to heart, for example.

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#62
post #15
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Side note: EU is planning to retaliate, and just as US is requiring ESTA from EU citizens traveling to US, in 2024 EU will start to require a similar application caller ETIAS, from US citizens traveling to EU. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Travel_Information_an...

Should it be seen as retaliation, or just rational decision to prevent illegal or unwanted migration?

According to that Wikipedia page, this looks very similar to the ESTA.

Having had to apply for that last year, it's not at all clear to me how that could help prevent any kind of illegal or unwanted migration. It's not rocket science to say that "yeah, you're only visiting for a few days and that yes, you intend to go back".

So I think it absolutely is a political circus, aka retaliation.

Just like during COVID, when at one point cases started taking off in France again, some country (can't remember which, might have been the UK) started asking for a negative test before entering. Wouldn't you know it, the next day it became mandatory for people coming in the other way. Cases hadn't moved in that other country.

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#63

There is another side to this. Whenever I have organized conferences, I end up receiving lots of requests for invitation letters, typically from researchers in India, for Visa purposes. I absolutely understand this, and I have always done my best to accommodate these requests. But this is time-consuming, and it is very annoying when those researchers (who are sometimes also scheduled to speak) never show up, and neve…

Make them pay in advance and reimburse the fees if they show up. Problem fixed.

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#64
post #41

From the map at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visa_requirements_for_Indian_c... looks like Mongolia and the Caribbean are optimal places to organize conferences.

> looks like Mongolia and the Caribbean are optimal places to organize conferences The colour scheme of that map is attrocious, but perhaps you have a better monitor or better colour vision than me? I think Mongolia is "Visa available both on arrival or eVisa", which is presumably not as good as Kazakhstan's "Visa not required", for example.

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/colorfish-col...

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#65
post #40

Yup. I was once invited to an US conference that was going to happen two weeks from my invitation. Even getting an appointment with the embassy within that timeline was impossible. Later I went for a different reason and if I recall the time to actually getting a visa was around 2 months.

Honestly, unless it's some critical customer/business thing (which I have had), anyone who wants me to speak at an international conference with two weeks notice is going to get told "My schedule is packed."

That was a long time ago and it was Linden Lab inviting me to some sort of Second Life open source discussion group.

I wouldn't have done much good there anyway so it was no big loss for anyone -- My spoken English was barely understandable at the time, I think most of the talk was related to the protocol which I wasn't even working with at the time.

Kind of a pity it didn't work out because I think it'd have been an entertainingly awkward experience for everyone involved, and I wouldn't have minded the English practice.

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#66
post #20

Or, even better, don't accept invites from U.S. based conferences, and you will never have any unexpected issues. Best not to cross their borders at all.

Great advice for any PhD student or researcher! Do you have any other valuable advice? How about just give up and quit your job? It would have the same effect.

> How about just give up and quit your job? It would have the same effect.

If by "it would have the same effect" you mean that it will be ignored, then maybe. But if you are saying that not attending international conferences is the same as not getting a job as a researcher in the first place, then I find this an exaggeration. Especially considering that one can participate in the scientific process by submitting their papers to journals, and that every country, including those in the Global South, can have their own conferences.

What you may refer to is prestige. But that's a separate matter altogether.

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#67
post #17

If you're an American university with a teaching or research Reactor, make sure your conference organisers know attendees from China, Iran, Cuba, Venezuela, Syria may be required not to be within a statutory minimum distance. It's hugely confronting and embarrassing for invited speakers, paper authors to arrive and then get excluded and escorted off campus.

The four designated State Sponsors of Terrorism are Cuba, the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (North Korea), Iran, and Syria, and due to OFAC sanctions you'll need to be very careful if you plan on inviting any of these to the US. However, China and Venezuela are not on this particular shit list. https://www.state.gov/state-sponsors-of-terrorism/

>The four designated State Sponsors of Terrorism are Cuba,

Out of curiosity what's the latest terrorist attack sponsored by the Cuban state?

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#68
It’s very easy to forget how annoying Visas can be, if you are from a privileged country. I’m a German married to a South African, but before that we were long-distance dating. Me visiting her was effortless. Fly there, stand in line, get my stamps, done.

Her visiting Germany? A lot of paperwork and appointments in both countries and usually paying for a 36h document courier to get her all the documents in time because it always takes longer than expected …

And that’s not even talking about them marriage itself as SA is not one of those countries where you can (ab)use easy Danish marriages because she then would have to fly back to SA as she’s not allowed to change visas while not in her home country.

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#69
post #55
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can't find any documentation. Was an iranian engineer whose paper was accepted and they were then escorted off campus. Maybe it was some point of confusion or during heightened tensions US-Iran because I can't find any confirming documents online. The most likely situation is an over cautious interpretation of https://ofac.treasury.gov/sanctions-programs-and-country-inf...

I’ve never heard of this happening the way you describe it. US Universities often have many international students. Public universities often are large open public spaces. It seems highly unlikely it would happen just because of the person’s country of origin… all by itself.

The grandparent comment is referring specifically to campuses (there are a few) who have nuclear research reactors

Re: Conferences are inadvertently excluding many attendees from foreign countries

#70

There is another side to this. Whenever I have organized conferences, I end up receiving lots of requests for invitation letters, typically from researchers in India, for Visa purposes. I absolutely understand this, and I have always done my best to accommodate these requests. But this is time-consuming, and it is very annoying when those researchers (who are sometimes also scheduled to speak) never show up, and neve…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN