Live data from Hacker News

Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

variousbits.net

41–50 of 63 posts

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#41

I have Supernote. It has some pretty nifty organization features that the Remarkable doesn’t have- you can create a table of contents as well as tag and star pages. It makes it easier to find the notes you need.

Yes yes and yes!

I have been using a small Supernote (A6X) for a long time now and it has become indispensable.

The hardware is good, the writing experience is excellent, a good calendar application, the battery lasts a long time, etc...

But all those are not the coolest thing. The coolest thing is that the guys who write the software actually listen to their customers and implement features and optimisations regularly.

I do embedded device software for a living and I know that the most expensive, recurring part of development for a gadget is the software updates and support long-term, where "long-term" means more than a few years.

Not many companies will support the same hardware device with fresh updates (and new features) regularly over a long(ish) period of time, and that is what Supernote does, and that is why I like their product.

Apple is rather good at this; companies with Android devices, not so much.

Reading myself I realize I sound like a Supernote fanboy... actually I am a big fan of maintained software, and that is a rarity nowadays.

Of course, when your device is _liberated_ and runs open-source software, you can finally hope for actual good software support for more than a couple of years ... but that is a topic for another time.

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#42

Have had a Remarkable 2 for a couple years now. My general impressions have been consistently favorable but the use case is limited. I’m in academia, so it excels specifically because: * it is basically an infinite shelf of notebooks that I can keep organized however I want * it is great for reading journal articles at full size There is a lot I wish it did, but it does work well for these!

Also in academia, subject to constant FOIA requests.

The ability to tag was added relatively recently, and has been a lifesaver. I can just hammer the email button and send legal counsel my raw notes instead of re-typing handwritten notes. It has saved me literally hundreds of hours in the last few years.

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#43
post #26

The remarkable2 is a highly opinionated device. Like most strongly opinionated people, if your needs / incentives / perspectives align, you'll get on perfectly. If not, you'll have a strong repulsion to the device. They have an intentionally slow development cycle, which stays very true to Remarklable's interpretation on how to use the device. I find that I align perfectly with the workflow imposed by the device (not…

Hey thanks for sharing your experience with their customer service. This alone is dissuading me from purchasing the tablet.

I wonder if there's a chance of compensating for this terrible service by getting good contents insurance with the product?

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#44
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It does render epubs and PDFs flawlessly indeed and the reading experience is great. I don't know what OP is talking about. Bonus: reading black and white comics on a remarkable feels even better than on paper.

Which books do you read that you're not bothered by the slow page turning, or not quite fitting a4ish size? Perhaps the epub experience has improved - but I've mostly used it with White Wolf rpg pdfs (granted, they are terrible - almost unreadable even in print) as well as other rpg books - typically large format, two columns - and its awful on the rm2.

Yeah rpg sourcebooks (mine are also WW) are not a good fit for the remarkable.

In general, only short PDFs are bearable, epubs feel like they should work but they take an incredibly long time to render, which frustrates me every time.

That being said, it's absolutely incredible for writing, but I don't need that as much as I used to (take less notes now as I'm more of an IC than my former team lead/PM/IC hybrid).

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#45
I intentionally gave up the chase to marry “real” feeling writing/reading with modern tech to avoid the inevitable uncanny valley these tools tend to get stuck in, and it seems like I was right to do so.

I fear, immensely, the idea that I might get stuck in how I operate to such a degree that I’m no longer open to new experiences, and to me that’s who remarkable2 is for; people stuck in the “paper is best” mindset but who realize technology is important to try to keep up with.

Getting comfortable with a tablet for these tasks is the real solution. Remarkable2 is a crutch.

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#47
post #11

the main downside of the Remarkable 2 for me is I need to use my glasses to read on it. Resizing PDFS etc. always end up being too large and not fit in screen, the screen is too dark to give sufficient contrast. This was not a problem for my Kobo, Kindle or Pocketbook readers. I got it really for reading and thought it was a nice size for what I wanted, but amazingly enough the bigger Remarkable is worse for reading…

Wait, reading PDFs on a Kindle is better than reading them on a remarkable?? Does Kindle have some fancy PDF reflow stuff going on?

the main benefit of Kindle I've used is that the screen is not as dark.

I have to zoom in several times to have a chance to read the pdf on remarkable, sometimes even have to zoom to read with glasses, because screen is darker than other ereaders I've used and as such has less contrast. For someone who's vision is going that makes it much worse.

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#48
I own Remarkable 2, bought it on release day and received it from the second batch. The fill and design is awesome. I use it lightly for daily work notes. But the hardware and software is aging and becoming outdated - no light, slow ereader.

Remarkable needs to release updated device, not sure if they have money for that. I’m so sorry to see them wasting their money on ads - promoting outdated device.

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#49

Remarkable used to be such a good option, but they instantly became unrecommendable when they added the shitty cloud subscription. The device isn’t worth it without it, and isn’t worth it with it.

Yeah. I bought one where a lifetime subscription was included, but for any new customer, I would advice against the remarkable 2. Because of my disappointment I have to rant a little.

Still their cloud stuff (even without subscription) is pretty much forced on you. I would have rather used syncthing or a nextcloud/webdav integration, where you can host the server yourself, because I don't trust their servers with secrets, potentially company or customer secrets.

For the price a RM2 cost, I would have expected to just pay for the hardware, not having their cloud stuff forced onto me, if I want to use all features, like sharing screen the desktop app or syncing files.

I am also a bit disappointed that they don't really cooperate and provide interfaces for third party developers and the community to integrate their applications. This is something for instance Pocketbook does better. In RM2 this has to be hacked into by reverse engineering RM2 libraries in order to access the display.

And now they released a $200 keyboard for the RM2, that is not even using expensive hardware switches, and it missing keys compared to a normal keyboard (the '\ |' is missing). So I would say this is not worth the money. I sort of understand exploitable business mechanisms when you use free stuff (free-to-play with micro transactions) but with a expensive full-priced hardware forcing you to upload all your files to their servers and monopolizing the storage and sync features is just bad, IMO.

Either they provide cheap hardware, that is bound to the vendors cloud and I have to pay for extra services or they provide expensive hardware where I am free to use it however I like, even with a self-hosted server. I just cannot justify products that are expensive and where the vendor has monopoly over the back-end, for which they also want more money, then I would pay to host it on a comparable VPS.

Re: Thoughts on the Remarkable 2

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can sync with Dropbox, Google drive, onedrive, or just use a cable.

I'm pretty sure all those options require a subscription, no? EDIT: I'm not sure now -- I might experiment a bit with this to see if it'll save my notebooks from the device to other clouds. It looks like you can use it as a quick way to get PDFs to your device, but if you use it as a journal you are SOL.

I don't think you need a subscription, however you need to upload the files to their cloud and from there it is uploaded to other providers. You cannot sync directly to your services. IIUC.

Their subscription is just required if you want to store files for a longer period of time.

Post reply on HN