Live data from Hacker News

My Overkill Home Network

blog.networkprofile.org

411–420 of 464 posts

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#411

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not about the energy for me. A lot of these posts make networking and homelabs seem like a dark art that only folks with tons of space, capital, and time can get into. Networking is anything but, it's about sending a packet of data over a wire! But when we glorify these elaborate, expensive setups, we not only lose focus on what the goal of a network should be (to satisfy needs for its users), we also discourage…

Or -- hear me out -- you entice newcomers who want a big ol' rack of boxes and wires. Like me.

I guess that wouldn't have enticed me at all. The minimalism of networking is what interested me in it in the first place decades ago as a kid.

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#412
post #207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you want to isolate the internet connection with fiber you can use an ethernet to fiber box. Something as simple and cheap as this would do: https://www.tp-link.com/us/business-networking/accessory/mc2...

+1 for the TP-link, I've got one running fiber to my AV equipment :) It was a lot easier to run a pair of fiber-optic cables there than it would've been to do the same with cat6. Also I got to play around with fiber for the first time. Never thought of isolating my modem from the rest of my gear though, I need to look into that.

Side effect of introducing less noise into AV equipment is a nice bonus!

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#413
post #370

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> My NAS … consuming ~35 kWh/month Translates to 50W.

Thank you. I spent a good few moments trying to wrap my head around this measurement.

Honestly, I thought it made more sense to measure it that way if you're trying to work out the electricity bill.

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#414

I wish every apartment would have at least some units of at least half-depth of rack space. Fitting anything (even a basic setup of a PaspberryPi + the PON modem + a minuscule switch + a PoE inhector) into the tiny space behind hatch where the cables from all the wall sockets end in my condo apartment is extremely hard. And I am still looking for a 5-port switch which would be manageable, support vlans, handle gigabi…

If I hit it big, I'll make an apartment with an attached datacenter and a quarter rack available for colo per unit

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#416
there's no kill like overkill! i thought this was going to be pretty meh, but indeed it was amazing. my favorite:

> Raspberry Pi 3B+ NTP server with GPS/PPS time source

Just one though? I have a triple LeoNTP device. Terminated my own cables to outdoor GPS antennae. Been working on designing my own but it's slow going.

I also have UPS power routed elsewhere in the house. But just to 1 room, where I had a powered ISDN phone. I couldn't find an ISDN phone I liked that took power from the line, if that's even a thing. I don't remember as that's ancient history now and I don't use the remote 240v power at all, just PoE everywhere.

The one thing missing is EPO (Emergency Power Off). I built my data closet into the garage, stealing part of a garage bay. It is the size of a smaller sauna room. I have an EPO on the outside, wired to the UPS.

I added card access to the data closet last year, because I also added it to the outside entries of the house, and I had one controller port left over.

I don't have nearly as much switching, and no fiber. But many servers. I would buy an 0xide rack if they weren't $500k.

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#417
post #397

This is some HW NSFW!! Wow! I’m in a very similar situation when it comes connections, FW and needs. I’m about to get a backup line for internet and it’s between Verizon (just like you) or Spectrum (same price, 500mbit down). What was your reason for VZW? Was ATT your only wired option?

Comcast is available, but it follows the same path as AT&T under the trees, so I figured that makes no sense

Also, the less money I give to Comcast the better.

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#418
post #307

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder how much of the difference is air conditioning?

I don't really think 2x the power usage comes from AC. The US has plenty of areas that only need a bit of AC for only part of the year.

I don't either but certainly it's a big part of it since I rarely have seen a US household without some sort of cooling and of course heating. Add to that we have larger houses than Europe, like larger.

A part time job of mine is helping a buddy's solar company and right now I'm working on a project, for an older couple who are building a 4200sqft house with 4 mini-splits, 2 electric boilers that switch to gas when it's cold, 3 refrigerators, 2 deep freezes and a potential future electric vehicle. There's a pool too but that changes the dynamics of the system greatly but I don't design and quote that unless they really want to spend $$$.

I'm glad they're deciding to go solar but I see this so often it hurts. An older couple without kids in a giant house in the desert that requires immense heating and cooling wants some solar to help offset their gross over consumption. Rather than scale down to a, still large, 2000sqft high efficiency house they go with cheap construction so they have more than enough space for the one time a year all the family shows up. Oh yah then they fill it with crap that's rarely if ever used.

There's no judgement thrown to the customer as this is the reality of the world we live in, but I see this as seriously problematic. Especially going forward as these older individuals die. Can a family of 4 or 6 afford that place? Do they even want a place so large which requires such an inordinate amount of maintenance? Three 1400sqft high efficiency homes could be built on approximately that same space bringing down the price of the home, reducing maintenance and providing more than one couple space to live.

Sorry, that was more of a rant than anything. Europe is not the promised land but the US really has some screwy priorities when it comes to housing.

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#419
post #397

This is some HW NSFW!! Wow! I’m in a very similar situation when it comes connections, FW and needs. I’m about to get a backup line for internet and it’s between Verizon (just like you) or Spectrum (same price, 500mbit down). What was your reason for VZW? Was ATT your only wired option?

Comcast is available, but it follows the same path as AT&T under the trees, so I figured that makes no sense Also, the less money I give to Comcast the better.

Lol, I hear you on that. I’m fortunate to not have Comcast as my second option.

Re: My Overkill Home Network

#420

Come on, let's admit it fellow HNers... Most of us are jealous/envious of this network setup and would love to have the money and time needed in order to own something similar. Extra points for powering all these from solar panels and also for all the "little" gizmos (ADB, NTP, LoRa, TinyPilot, MQTT and temp/humidity/power monitoring). @monstermunch You're living the dream :-)

I'm more interested in my colocation setup than my home setup. I have 2x1u in two different data centres. Just built one of my new servers (Cisco UCS 220 M5) with 2x 4TB Enterprise NVMe drives, 4x 2TB enterprise SAS SSD drives and 4x 2TB SSD drives, 256GB of ram and 2x Intel Gold 6230 (20cores). I don't even need this, I just want it. Just deciding on if to keep with FreeBSD and bHyve which I love, or go with VMware.…

Go with Proxmox, you'll love it even more
Post reply on HN