Live data from Hacker News

Robbie Robertson has died

nytimes.com

21–30 of 57 posts

Re: Robbie Robertson has died

#22

Sad. If I had to choose the greatest song ever written, I would not hesitate to go with The Weight. The version [0] from The Waltz is especially brilliant. [0] - https://youtu.be/q-w9OclUnns

in Once Were Brothers they said when they played it for Dylan he looked at Robbie, disbelieving, and says, "You wrote that?"

Re: Robbie Robertson has died

#23
Played The Band's Academy of Music performance [0] last night when I got the news. It's right up there with The Last Waltz. Great and timeless music. Hell some of my favorite Grateful Dead performances were covers of his music. RIP Robbie. Enjoy your weekends fellow heady folks (~);)

[0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNtcW2LqveU&list=OLAK5uy_khf...

Re: Robbie Robertson has died

#25
post #16

my fav era with him was with Bob Dylan, 1966 - here’s a pretty niche video with both of them playing a Dylan song that never made an official album release On A Rainy Afternoon https://youtu.be/qE3owtjQmSc awesome guitarist / RIP

Bob Dylan talked about how he loved working with him because he’s the rare guitarist that had all the chops but didn’t need to show them off.

As an example, here’s a clip of him playing with Clapton. He takes over right when Clapton’s strap slips off his guitar and they go back and forth shredding.

https://youtu.be/1WDmMWF83x4

However, if you listen to him with Dylan or The Band, the guitar parts are always simple and about fitting the song.

Re: Robbie Robertson has died

#26

Played The Band's Academy of Music performance [0] last night when I got the news. It's right up there with The Last Waltz. Great and timeless music. Hell some of my favorite Grateful Dead performances were covers of his music. RIP Robbie. Enjoy your weekends fellow heady folks (~);) [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNtcW2LqveU&list=OLAK5uy_khf...

My favorite music lore is the Dead, The Band, Dylan and Lennon interplayed.

- the The Dead covering Dylan live consistently

- the Dead’s weight covers over the years. I’m fairly Brent Mydland’s last-ish live song was the Weight and he sang the “I’ve gotta go but my friends can stick around” verse. Chilling but feels right.

- Jerry and the Dead supporting Dylan with a joint tour in the 80’s when Dylan was a washed up alcoholic

- Jerry’s got a great Dear Prudence cover that I believe yoko said it was how the song was meant to be played. Plus a bunch of other JCB/Dylan covers.

True musicians!

Re: Robbie Robertson has died

#27
post #20

Sad. If I had to choose the greatest song ever written, I would not hesitate to go with The Weight. The version [0] from The Waltz is especially brilliant. [0] - https://youtu.be/q-w9OclUnns

No better clapping than Mavis'

She also does an awesome version of For What It’s Worth

Re: Robbie Robertson has died

#29

Sad. If I had to choose the greatest song ever written, I would not hesitate to go with The Weight. The version [0] from The Waltz is especially brilliant. [0] - https://youtu.be/q-w9OclUnns

His first solo album is one of my favorites.

His solo debut and Storyville are a perfect one-two punch.

Re: Robbie Robertson has died

#30
> his biological father was a Jewish professional gambler named Alexander David Klegerman, who had been killed in a hit-and-run accident before she met James Robertson

Killing someone and fleeing the scene isn't something that happens by accident.

Post reply on HN