Live data from Hacker News

Speed Test

speed.cloudflare.com

161–170 of 216 posts

Re: Speed Test

#161
post #104

Great, one more speedtest site to pit against all the others. On my gigabyte fibre: Cloudflare: 697 down / 645 up fast.com: 860 down / 440 up Google: 760 down / 347 up Ookla speedtest: 841 down / 827 up Quite a large variability in upload speeds, which isn't all the surprising I guess. Network providers often don't really need to prioritise upload traffic...

> On my gigabyte fibre: *gigabit Get it right already.

I misspoke, but you understood what I meant so no harm was done.

Re: Speed Test

#162
I think this is great service, and here is another one that Netflix provides:

https://fast.com

That one uses Netflix servers, so you get a valid test as long as your ISP isn't throttling Netflix. Of course they created it so that people would call their ISP and complain they aren't getting the speed they pay for, but it turns out it's a pretty good test most of the time.

And most importantly, it isn't prioritized like speedtest.net.

Re: Speed Test

#163
post #157
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cloudflare's speed test doesn't have a graph for latency under load, but it shows those numbers while the test is running. But you can find those graphs in Cloudflare Radar. Half of the https://radar.cloudflare.com/quality section is based on speed test data.

I see a graphical visualization of latency with multiple points and error bars. Maybe "graph" isn't the right technical term? Edit: It's a box and whisker plot: https://www.khanacademy.org/math/statistics-probability/summ...

Ah, sorry. I thought you were asking for something different (more summarized). It does indeed plot latency during downloads and uploads in the same way as it plots unloaded latency (and I'd call those a "graph" too).

Re: Speed Test

#164
post #59

Is there a cli tool for this aswell or just the website? At home I have my server run a speedtest (ookla for now) running every 30 minutes because I do not trust my ISP to keep their end of the deal. I visualize the results with grafana and would love to change over to this. As haivri points out, this is a very detailed report! EDIT: Apparently there is a nodejs module available https://github.com/cloudflare/speedtes…

amazing to see this JS library uses minimal direct dependencies and even a separate devDependencies that are not needed for runtime - https://github.com/cloudflare/speedtest/blob/main/package.js...

Re: Speed Test

#165
Interesting. I get higher speeds on cloudflare in chrome.

603Mbps Cloudflare chrome vs. 600 Mbps Cloudflare firefox

But on fast.com (netflix) it's the opposite:

440 Mbps fast.com Chrome vs. 590 Mbps fast.com firefox.

Re: Speed Test

#166
post #147

The level of detail is very nice, I wish more tools exposed this as easily. That said, please remember this is a test of you through your ISP to a (hopefully) nearby Cloudflare node. It isn't necessarily testing 'the Internet', since Cloudflare sometimes has creative peering relationships to origins that are not being measured here. Also, for the people complaining they only have 300 Mb/s -- unless you are streaming…

> Also, for the people complaining they only have 300 Mb/s -- unless you are streaming multiple 4K movies there is nothing faster about having more bandwidth. You should care about latency, packet loss, and cache hit rate. Haven’t downloaded any 150+ GB games (or patches even these days) off of Steam lately I see

I think the parent comment is still mostly relevant here. 150GB downloads are not common even for those with games that big. A new install is most likely a ~monthly operation and updates that aren’t ready by the time you notice them will be rare.

Sure it would be nice for those few instances, but those are not worth the additional cost for almost any individual or family if they actually work out the time saved waiting.

Re: Speed Test

#167

The interesting thing about this to me is its repeated sampling and reporting of a statistical profile of the link. Showing distributions for latency and speed, not just a single average. Really helpful info on less-consistent connections like Starlink. Example screenshot here: https://postimg.cc/bDTyy8BM

That website is not zoomable on mobile, which is a pretty grave offence for an _image posting site_.

Re: Speed Test

#168

I think this is great service, and here is another one that Netflix provides: https://fast.com That one uses Netflix servers, so you get a valid test as long as your ISP isn't throttling Netflix. Of course they created it so that people would call their ISP and complain they aren't getting the speed they pay for, but it turns out it's a pretty good test most of the time. And most importantly, it isn't prioritized lik…

The prioritization is critical for speedtest.net - it's entire purpose is to provide an assessment of your PHY - not your Network, and certainly not your Internet speed.

speedtest.net should tell you if the physical installation of your cable was done properly - nothing more.

Re: Speed Test

#169
I love the box plots! I wish more sites showed distribution information, including IMDb and Rotten Tomatoes, because I suspect many movies and TV shows have at least bimodal distributions.

Re: Speed Test

#170
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Also, for the people complaining they only have 300 Mb/s -- unless you are streaming multiple 4K movies there is nothing faster about having more bandwidth. You should care about latency, packet loss, and cache hit rate. Haven’t downloaded any 150+ GB games (or patches even these days) off of Steam lately I see

Yeah. Comcast is shorting me by a solid 50Mb/s and this is the reason it's annoying. On top of the fact that their garbage excuse for a website is literally completely broken. Every time I've tried to use it for the past year it just sticks me in a login loop. What a truly miserable company.

I recently discovered that using the Verizon website on Firefox is pretty much impossible, it similarly has nightmarish login/account issues. Whatever issue the browser has with the site even managed to break their new account flow on two installations I've had done in recent months. The installation and appointments were scheduled and performed, but nobody in their support teams can find either account in their systems and I have not received a bill.

1Gb symmetric at both locations in NYC though and a free Xbox One S and $300 Visa giftcard.

They have essentially paid me to use them as my ISP, and contact from their support teams attempting to figure it out is getting increasingly infrequent

Post reply on HN