Earlier quoted context omitted.
Now try that on this problem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_hypothesis
This one is true though.
Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
21–30 of 107 posts
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#22A lot of recent math discoveries seem to be geometrical: circle packing, infinitely tiling patterns, neighbor coloring theorem, ... I don't seem to see as much discoveries in other areas like number theory, calculus, algebra etc... Is this a bias of what gets covered on HN, or are this type of geometrical problems the currently most active field of mathematics?
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#23Earlier quoted context omitted.
Counterpoint: am American and I read it exactly as intentioned the first time. It didn't even occur to me to read it in the context you did until you mentioned it. I don't watch network news though.
I don’t watch network news either and had the same reaction as OP reading “two students shoot down” A better headline could be “Widely Believed Math Conjecture shot down by two students.”
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#24A lot of recent math discoveries seem to be geometrical: circle packing, infinitely tiling patterns, neighbor coloring theorem, ... I don't seem to see as much discoveries in other areas like number theory, calculus, algebra etc... Is this a bias of what gets covered on HN, or are this type of geometrical problems the currently most active field of mathematics?
And then, Calculus took about 3 years for me to begin to scratch the surface... and realise I will never need it as numeric methods took over completely with the advent of cheap compute.
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#25Would their summer research be an utter failure? Would they be unimpressive mathematicatians?
How much of math success is being lucky enough to stumble upon a tractable problem?
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#26A lot of recent math discoveries seem to be geometrical: circle packing, infinitely tiling patterns, neighbor coloring theorem, ... I don't seem to see as much discoveries in other areas like number theory, calculus, algebra etc... Is this a bias of what gets covered on HN, or are this type of geometrical problems the currently most active field of mathematics?
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#27A lot of recent math discoveries seem to be geometrical: circle packing, infinitely tiling patterns, neighbor coloring theorem, ... I don't seem to see as much discoveries in other areas like number theory, calculus, algebra etc... Is this a bias of what gets covered on HN, or are this type of geometrical problems the currently most active field of mathematics?
I'd say that HN posts a lot of quanta articles, and quanta has a "bias" towards results that can be explained to a semi-lay audience. You really don't want to know enough about modular elliptic curves to understand Wiles' proof of Fermat's conjecture. But sometimes number theory proofs come up here too.
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#28Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#29What would happen if the conjecture happened to be true, and they did their data collection/computation, and got a bunch of data (called "0%" in mathematics) consistent with the conjecture? Would their summer research be an utter failure? Would they be unimpressive mathematicatians? How much of math success is being lucky enough to stumble upon a tractable problem?
Re: Students’ insight proves that the local-global conjecture doesn’t hold
#30A lot of recent math discoveries seem to be geometrical: circle packing, infinitely tiling patterns, neighbor coloring theorem, ... I don't seem to see as much discoveries in other areas like number theory, calculus, algebra etc... Is this a bias of what gets covered on HN, or are this type of geometrical problems the currently most active field of mathematics?
Aren't all those things the same ultimately?