Live data from Hacker News

When did Postgres become cool?

crunchydata.com

51–60 of 182 posts

Re: When did Postgres become cool?

#51

I see a lot of comment reflecting on MySQL and oracle vs postgresql. Anyone with experience of MSSQL and PostgreSQL who'd like to comment on how it they compare?

My experience says that PG wins in the SQL language feature department.

However IMHO MySQL still wins in operational efficiency and performance. These are things that only start to matter when you scale your database and most people never actually reach those sizes.

Re: When did Postgres become cool?

#52

Was it that Postgres became cool or that MySQL became unreliable post-Oracle and developers were looking for an alternative?

Developers were afraid it would become a tool for Oracle to monetize and trap people in their ecosystem. That never really happened and they have actually done some really good development work on it.

Re: When did Postgres become cool?

#55
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was way before that - it was when people got fed up with the string handling and implicit type casting stupidity of MySQL

This is also my opinion and I think before that MySQL was known for fast and Postgres for features and correctness. I think the change went both ways, people realized that MySQL's casual approach only got them so far and at the same time Postgres focused more on performance without giving up its existing qualities. I think Postgres became cool when it became fast (too).

The last straw was when Oracle bought MySQL, and it was forked to MariaSQL. Postgres went from the nerdy awkward kid to the nerdy cool kid, while MySQL started drinking, getting split personalities, and living off his past fame.

Re: When did Postgres become cool?

#56
post #44

When MySQL was purchased by Oracle. For a time, MariaDB was the new option, but its commitment to binary compatibility with MySQL made it feel bogged down. Fun fact: Julian Assange contributed code to PostgreSQL a long time ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18464671

MariaDB doesn't have a commitment to binary compatibility with MySQL, though. For a time it was marketed as a drop-in replacement, but that has been increasingly untrue for over a decade now.

Re: When did Postgres become cool?

#57
post #18

Postgres became cool when the scales fell off peoples eyes and they realized that very few use cases necessitate or even benefit from "NoSQL" databases.

You get JSON types with postgres. If you aren't sharing data between tables then json is fine

Re: When did Postgres become cool?

#58
I first started noticing that apparently lots of people had begun to find it cool some five or eight years ago... So, given how incredibly hip and well-connected and "with it" I am, presumably at least some five (or perhaps ten) years before that.

So ca 2010, maybe just a little earlier?

Re: When did Postgres become cool?

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is also my opinion and I think before that MySQL was known for fast and Postgres for features and correctness. I think the change went both ways, people realized that MySQL's casual approach only got them so far and at the same time Postgres focused more on performance without giving up its existing qualities. I think Postgres became cool when it became fast (too).

The last straw was when Oracle bought MySQL, and it was forked to MariaSQL. Postgres went from the nerdy awkward kid to the nerdy cool kid, while MySQL started drinking, getting split personalities, and living off his past fame.

> MariaSQL

MariaDB.

Post reply on HN