Live data from Hacker News

The Alexander Piano

alexanderpiano.nz

91–100 of 103 posts

Re: The Alexander Piano

#91
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I helped a friend make his. He got this insanely hard piece of wood for the neck and we spent a good couple of days shaping that. I'm pretty sure that if you were to look closely at that attic today you'd find that dust unchanged, that wood will never rot. It was also very heavy, a small off-cut would not float. I have no idea where he got that wood, I really should ask him because that probably makes for an interest…

How did the blade of your plane handle that wood?

Very badly. In fact all my normal (woodworking) tools went blunt without much progress. Eventually we settled on doing it like this: use a very thin saw to mark out the stations every 2 cm or so for depth + 1 mm, then use a belt sander (graciously borrowed to us by the father of a friend) to take it down to the marks, then endless hand sanding until it was good. It looked absolutely gorgeous when it was done. I don't remember what kind of wood it was though, the amount of dust was staggering. On one day I accidentally left the door to my attic bedroom open and everything inside was covered in dust. That beltsander did a great job though, and I don't think we'd have pulled that off without it.

If I had to do this today I'd use a metalworking mill. There is no point in trying to work wood that hard with regular wood tools, they just won't keep an edge.

Re: The Alexander Piano

#92
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Note the ratio. I wouldn't bet on the 'always'.

I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm not even sure you're less correct than I am. There sure are a lot of assholes around. I'm just saying that in a story that goes "Things were bad, people helped and I worked hard, now things are good", it's sad getting stuck focusing on the first part.

I don't think I'm stuck on anything, I just noticed that bit and mentioned it.

Re: The Alexander Piano

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't believe that's it. The problem of tuning higher notes to the stretched harmonics of lower notes would still be present even in a piano tuned using just intonation. Suppose for instance the 2nd harmonic of C2 is 2 cents sharp of where it "ought" to be (which is twice the frequency of C2 itself). Then if you tune C3 (the C in the next octave) to be similarly 2 cents sharp of where it ought to be, it will not cl…

While it is true that the harmonics will be off for any tuning system, octave stretching is relatively new and arises only on equal tempered instruments because it needs to be applied equally to every note, so it sounds terrible if you apply it to unequal tunings where (for example) the distance between C2 and G3 can be 20 cents different than the distance between C#2 and G#3. In equal temperament, the distance is ~2…

12-edo's approximation to the 5th harmonic (a.k.a. 4th overtone) is 14 cents sharp, not flat -- it's at 400 cents plus two octaves, whereas the 5th harmonic is at 386 cents plus two octaves.

I admit to being unfamiliar with unequal temperaments. As a jazz player they seems like a complete bummer to me, as I love to transpose on a whim and don't want the intervallic structure to depend on what key I'm in.

Re: The Alexander Piano

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While it is true that the harmonics will be off for any tuning system, octave stretching is relatively new and arises only on equal tempered instruments because it needs to be applied equally to every note, so it sounds terrible if you apply it to unequal tunings where (for example) the distance between C2 and G3 can be 20 cents different than the distance between C#2 and G#3. In equal temperament, the distance is ~2…

12-edo's approximation to the 5th harmonic (a.k.a. 4th overtone) is 14 cents sharp , not flat -- it's at 400 cents plus two octaves, whereas the 5th harmonic is at 386 cents plus two octaves. I admit to being unfamiliar with unequal temperaments. As a jazz player they seems like a complete bummer to me, as I love to transpose on a whim and don't want the intervallic structure to depend on what key I'm in.

Yeah, I had a sign error in my head there (unequal major thirds are the relatively flat ones).

I know that there is some unequal tempered jazz out there from very early recordings, and I assume they thought the different character of the keys added extra character and possibly some extra "grunge," but it would be interesting to compare the improvisational style to equal tempered jazz.

Re: The Alexander Piano

#96
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No degree here, but I spend a lot of time doing sound design and love low frequencies and I agree completely. Those bass notes just cut through the mix and are so delightfully zingy. It's so much easier to hear the pitch on them. It's an amazing sounding instrument.

Hi Bob, I'm honored to have you reply to my silly post. I love your work. Cheers!

Haha, thanks! :D "Crispy" is such a perfect adjective to describe the bass strings on this piano. They are delightful.

Re: The Alexander Piano

#97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

400v? what that what your mains was packing?

No, mains runs at 230V in Europe, but as said by sibling comments, after the power transformer and rectification, HT1 (the primary high tension power bus, usually feeding the tubes in the power section) can get in the 300-500V range in some amp designs. I knew from schematics and calculations it'd be about this high, but seeing the actual 400V value on my cheap multimeter sent shivers down my spine. Also I remember a…

Wait until you touch a live anode, that will send shivers down your spine ;)

Re: The Alexander Piano

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think he's a independent musician! Sometimes make woodwork, and instruments still, maybe more for hobby. He still plays folk music, and regularly play at a Viking (Scandinavian) restaurant named Aifur in Stockholm. It's a cool restaurant worth visiting if you're going there one day =)

Aifur can be fun. Go with a small group if you can. If you're picked to do the "drink from a horn" contest, there's a trick to it. If you know the trick (and can shoot a beer), you'll win almost instantly. If I remember right, Glassbar ice cream a few steps away is pretty good. If you're in Stockholm and interested in Viking things, take a trip to Birka. There's a ferry from Stockholm. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B…

What’s the trick?

Re: The Alexander Piano

#100

Oh man this fills me with nostalgia. In (public) Suburb middle school I had a friend who played folk music as a hobby, and also made his own instruments. Mostly violin and hurdy-gurdy [1], probably because his parents were farmers in the suburb and owned a smith/wood workshop. His unique hobbies made him a bit of an outcast and people made fun of him in school, but I was in to classic music so we got along well. A ye…

> There was only one school in the entire country

If you don't mind, what country was this?

Post reply on HN