Live data from Hacker News

Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

syzito.xyz

141–150 of 241 posts

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#141

A part of me really hopes that Musks' seemingly-incompetent handling of Twitter does sort of legitimize Mastodon (and other Fediverse projects) to the public. I set up a mastodon server a few weeks ago out of boredom, and I finally get the appeal of tweeting, and have been using it regularly, and it makes me happy that I get to own all the hardware powering it.

Twitter was already confusing. Mastodon more so.

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#142
post #130
post #126

The post includes innecessary resentment against billionaire owned platforms, sadly it does not take the opportunity to promote Mastodon or other technologies with that post success.

>billionaire owned platforms Do not refer to them as 'billionaires' since they're oligarchs. I have expunged the word 'billionaire' from my vocabulary.

I agree, but they're effectively equivalent.

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#144

The most interesting part of this are the Mastodon posts underneath the initial one that insult this Vaught's integrity for not taking the handle repossession personally.

I kind of get that. I would take it personally. Violations of trust should be punished, regardless of whether the rest of the world thinks I was stupid to trust in the first place.

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#145
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it's similar to some users believing they have a right to privacy or a right to "their" data on platforms like Facebook. Use at your own risk because they're not free services; they have a profit motive by nature of what they are.

People gotta quit bitchin' about Twitter and just move to Mastodon, Bluesky, Threads or whatever. Bankruptcy is the one language that Elon Musk will understand and it's absolutely necessary because his behavior is contagious. Donald Trump set a precedent for him and Scott Adams, only their destruction will send a message this behavior is just not cool.

Bluesky is busy Google+ing themselves with the eternal invite system.

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Discord kinda had that with username#1234 (4 digits). But that's being phase out.

Is there an explanation anywhere of their reason for doing the phase out? Very curious!

User confusion.basically

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#147
There is no such thing as true digital ownership for things built on anyone else’s platform. If you want to truly own something you need to use open protocols - like websites and bespoke software. If you build on someone’s API, or rely on “owning” a Twitter account which you literally have zero right to and is at the whim of the platform’s owner, don’t be shocked when it’s taken from you.

Of course, you can always use Bitcoin / Ethereum and the Ethereum Name Service which is true, legitimate digital ownership. But few on HN like that. There is a lot of cognitive dissonance when arguing that blockchain has literally zero use cases and then being angry when Twitter or Facebook or Google rugs you.

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#148

What if Google took your 16 year old email address? Corporate cloud is an absolute trap. A prison. You cannot trust these companies with your important digital belongings. Free, libre, open source software, peer to peer networks, and citizen run communications infrastructure are the only viable way forward if we don't to live in a rental society where none of your belongings belong to you, not even your identity.

What about ARIN and IANA? Eventually there is some central authority associated with the internet, IP address blocks and DNS root servers.

This is why I was very careful to include "citizen run communications infrastructure". We need public antennas, public access points. Publicly run physical infrastructure.

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a good excuse to never build anything ... on closed platforms. Open and censorship-resistant protocols do not have have this risk, Free Software does not have this risk. So, yes, if in 2023 you are still building things on closed platforms despite all the cautionary tales, you deserve all the snark you'll get.

What are some open censorship-resistant protocols? Email?

Http works fine. The risk of a revoked domain name is minuscule in comparison to “whenever we feel like it”.

Re: Jeremy Vaught spent 16 years to build @music on Twitter, then X took it away

#150

This is the consequence of lack of self-sovereignty, along with the lack of an agreed universal naming system. That said, I’m not sure that first-come-first-wins is simultaneously fair, in such a universal environment. Nor, really, do I want it to be a “whoever can pay most gets the desirable names”, like DNS works. I don’t have a better solution right now, but acknowledge that there’s a problem with the combination/…

A mandatory random set of numbers at the end of every name is an approach I quite like. Not only does it directly make every name available to 10,000 people, it should reduce the demand for these desirable names in the first place since you have to share them with thousands of other people. Platforms should also consider accommodations for trademark holders. Most have some sort of program, but it seems to be a mess.…

Beyond making each name available to 10,000 (or more) people, randomizing the numbers puts everyone on a playing field. It’s an elegant solution—and why it’s such a baffling shame that Discord recently abandoned it for the terrible, outmoded “one unique username for everyone” approach.
Post reply on HN