Live data from Hacker News

Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

news.ku.dk

121–130 of 356 posts

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#121

Would it theoreticaly possible to find frozen animals 120.000 years old with still intact DNA?

Not an animal, icecore, or that old, but ancient plants has been grown from seeds from permafrost.[0] So who knows what might be found and analyzed from all the icecores.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/feb/21/russian-scient...

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#122

This is a very important project. There is a joke in here about "why not wait 2 years for the ice to melt off if you wanted to look at the mud underneath?" But as the article states, "'This will change climate models because it redefines our basic understanding of how ice moves,' explains Dorthe Dahl-Jensen." Much, if not the majority, of climate science is the creation of models (differential equations mostly) that…

As a "cloud person", I just want to add a few things to the description of how clouds affect the climate (and why high clouds have a wamring effect).

All clouds are white, so they all reflect sunlight back into space (during the day), cooling the Earth.

All clouds are (almost) black in the infra-red, meaning the amount of energy they emit in the infra-red is determined by their temperature. Colder clouds emit less energy.

Almost all clouds are colder than the surface beneath them, which means they emit less infra-red energy to space than a clear day would. This reduces the amount of energy the Earth emits to space, so warming the climate.

High clouds are colder than low clouds, so have a stronger warming effect.

In summary:

Low clouds - Reflect sunlight (cooling), don't trap much infra-red (little warming)- Net: Cooling effect

High clouds - Reflect sunlight (cooling), trap lots of infra-red (stronger warming) - Net: Warming effect

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#123
post #68
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, DNA in ice has a half-life of a million years. Seems very much possible.

Where are you getting that figure? Everything I had ever read on the subject puts the half-life at more like 500 (five-hundred) years. While doing a quick double-check for this comment, it seems there was one sample with the unexpectedly long observed half-life of 15,000 years, still a couple orders of magnitude less than a million years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_DNA#Non-human_aDNA

I'm not an expert in this area but I do know a fair amount on the subject. I believe the section you linked is out of date.

The DNA we get back from old situations typically was preserved, by dryness/freezing, and it's still quite fragmentary. The actual "half life" of DNA is not that interesting- its the details of the DNA remnants that matter.

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ice cores are a few inches across. The photo at the top of the article is not of the drill hole but of the hole they had to dig in the snow to get to the ice they actually drilled. See the photo of the final ice core [1] to see how miniscule the actual drill hole is. [1] https://science.ku.dk/english/press/news/2023/pay-dirt-for-i...

The article definitely makes it sound like they had “boots on the ground”. There’s a picture of muddy boots and the caption says they are covered in ancient mud.

That mud came up with the last core.

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#125
post #109

I love humans. They somehow decided to start drilling, and not give up & get funding for 7 years. We are a crazy but exciting bunch of organisms.

> We are a crazy but exciting bunch of organisms.

I read this as "crazy but extinct bunch of organisms"

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ice cores are a few inches across. The photo at the top of the article is not of the drill hole but of the hole they had to dig in the snow to get to the ice they actually drilled. See the photo of the final ice core [1] to see how miniscule the actual drill hole is. [1] https://science.ku.dk/english/press/news/2023/pay-dirt-for-i...

The article definitely makes it sound like they had “boots on the ground”. There’s a picture of muddy boots and the caption says they are covered in ancient mud.

You need to clear a lot of snow before you can stand on the ice that you're drilling in (You can't drill straight if your rig's sitting on snow, you need to dig until you hit solid ground, and in this case the ground is ice). That's the "boots on the ground" part. They were physically there to do the drilling (as opposed to giant automated core drillers such as DISC[1], which don't require "boots on the ground" so much as they just require one or more operators to oversee operation)

The ancient mud's from hauling up the ice cores, not from standing 3 kilometers deep in a giant hole.

[1] https://icedrill.org/equipment/deep-ice-sheet-coring-drill

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#127

That's a rate of about 4.3 centimeters per hour. Can anybody elaborate as to why this process takes so long?

As the hole gets deeper, the amount of time to bring up core sections and send the drill back down become significant. That combined with the previously mentioned short field season. Drilling more than a few hundred meters becomes very difficult logistically as well, especially in such a remote setting.

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#129
post #68
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, DNA in ice has a half-life of a million years. Seems very much possible.

Where are you getting that figure? Everything I had ever read on the subject puts the half-life at more like 500 (five-hundred) years. While doing a quick double-check for this comment, it seems there was one sample with the unexpectedly long observed half-life of 15,000 years, still a couple orders of magnitude less than a million years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_DNA#Non-human_aDNA

Preservation conditions might have some bearing.

This recent news article suggests nematodes actually surviving after 46K years in permafrost. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/46-000-year-old-w...

Re: Ice core scientists in East Greenland reach bedrock

#130
post #7

Interesting: "Towards the base, the ice is more than 120,000 years old and dates back to the last interglacial period, a time when the atmospheric temperature above Greenland was 5°C warmer than today."

I'm not a scientist so I'm curious why this is interesting.

It's interesting because the whole ice cap as we know it is around 120k years ago which I don't consider the long ago on human development scale. This also appears to mean that in the past 120K there wasn't a polar ice cap. I read that as the worst case scenario we should be using for long term planning. This also may help determine how fast the ice was built and how fast it will melt.

I'm completely an armchair ponderer.

Post reply on HN