Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

osnews.com

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure the IE and Firefox teams get together regularly. I don't think the same sense of comraderie exists between the IE and chrome teams.

Not that I know any of the parties, but what makes you think that?

Perhaps the (formerly) regular release cakes that they exchanged: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firefox#Response_from_Microsoft

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#12
post #10

It's really hard to parse articles from OSNews, Groklaw, and by Redhat employees about Microsoft and Windows 8, specifically, to try and filter out the bias and hate and cut to the chase. First, the very first line. >And thus, Microsoft bites itself in its behind with Metro. Uh what? Putting the supposed conclusion as the first line as if the the headline says everything? (BTW the headline is pretty obtuse, even for…

>Why don't these same people complain about third party browsers being completely banned on the iPad which has a huge share in the tablet market? There are many third party browsers available on the App Store for iPad. I'm not sure where you got the idea that they're "banned"?

Those are Safari skins, not browsers.

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#13
If you want to understand what's going on, then go to the source. Either read the Microsoft documentation or read the documentation coming from an actual browser vendor working on this. At Mozilla, we talk about what we're doing so you're likely to get the best information with us.

http://weblogs.mozillazine.org/asa/archives/2012/02/building... and http://www.brianbondy.com/blog/id/129/

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#14
post #7

It's really hard to parse articles from OSNews, Groklaw, and by Redhat employees about Microsoft and Windows 8, specifically, to try and filter out the bias and hate and cut to the chase. First, the very first line. >And thus, Microsoft bites itself in its behind with Metro. Uh what? Putting the supposed conclusion as the first line as if the the headline says everything? (BTW the headline is pretty obtuse, even for…

I am also having a hard time trying to understand the author. The author seems to think that Firefox is in big trouble in the post-PC world but then tries to blame MS for that, when MS has specifically made allowance for third party browsers? I know MS is the favorite whipping boy in the blogosphere but why does MS deserve blame for Firefox being in trouble?. He seems to realize that Firefox will have a good chance i…

To be fair, IBM and Microsoft didn't invent the open PC market.

Before the IBM PC showed up, there already was a thriving ecosystem of 8-bit PCs running CP/M by Digital Research. These had compatibility on several levels: CPU architecture (Intel 8080 + clones like Zilog Z80), operating system calls (CP/M had a simple API in the form of interrupts), user interface (same CLI everywhere) and also hardware expansion (a standard bus for add-on boards).

The MS-DOS ecosystem largely followed this model. Large parts of MS-DOS, including the API and the CLI style -- those drive letters too -- were in fact borrowed from CP/M to make porting existing software easier. (There was a thriving CP/M productivity software market with apps like WordStar and VisiCalc.)

IBM wasn't really happy that their PC had been cloned and turned into an open market, and a couple of years later they tried to regain control with a semi-closed platform called PS/2. It also included a new OS co-developed with Microsoft called OS/2. The whole strategy never quite came together and eventually Microsoft went their own way.

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#15

If you want to understand what's going on, then go to the source. Either read the Microsoft documentation or read the documentation coming from an actual browser vendor working on this. At Mozilla, we talk about what we're doing so you're likely to get the best information with us. http://weblogs.mozillazine.org/asa/archives/2012/02/building... and http://www.brianbondy.com/blog/id/129/

[author of the OSN article here]

Which is exactly why I always link to the source. Always check the source material, whether you agree with an article or not. Most people on HN (and OSNews) do so, luckily.

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#16
post #10

It's really hard to parse articles from OSNews, Groklaw, and by Redhat employees about Microsoft and Windows 8, specifically, to try and filter out the bias and hate and cut to the chase. First, the very first line. >And thus, Microsoft bites itself in its behind with Metro. Uh what? Putting the supposed conclusion as the first line as if the the headline says everything? (BTW the headline is pretty obtuse, even for…

>Why don't these same people complain about third party browsers being completely banned on the iPad which has a huge share in the tablet market? There are many third party browsers available on the App Store for iPad. I'm not sure where you got the idea that they're "banned"?

Third-party browsers cannot do core things like implement their own JavaScript engine (which is why you're not going to see Firefox or Chrome for iOS unless Apple changes the rules).

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#17
Since the Metro environment imposes numerous restrictions that would hinder the development of a decent browser, Microsoft has created a new application class, called "Metro style enabled desktop browser".

On the one hand the author seems to be criticizing Microsoft for insisting on a set of ecosystem standards, on the other hand the criticism is for creating a kludge.

It's 2012 and the OS is in beta, any comparison of the development of of third party browsers to those of the Netscape days is absurd. These days Microsoft provides a browser to round out their product line and to facilitate the user's ability to engage the internet immediately following a fresh install.

Browsers are so ubiquitous as to appear on feature phones. They are commodities, not strategic tools in the quest for OS market share.

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#18

It's really hard to parse articles from OSNews, Groklaw, and by Redhat employees about Microsoft and Windows 8, specifically, to try and filter out the bias and hate and cut to the chase. First, the very first line. >And thus, Microsoft bites itself in its behind with Metro. Uh what? Putting the supposed conclusion as the first line as if the the headline says everything? (BTW the headline is pretty obtuse, even for…

I don't think any of your responses justify or explain the lack of documentation. MS is inviting developers to their new OS and Win8 now has a customer preview, with the developer one being out for a while. Pointing to a potential situation where MS might be criticised over hypothetical changes still doesn't negate the criticism of the very real problem of missing information right now. I find the idea that this can also be explained away by a desire to surprise/woo customers totally absurd given the release of installable Previews of the entire OS.

Re: Microsoft creates special application class for Windows 8 browsers

#19

Since the Metro environment imposes numerous restrictions that would hinder the development of a decent browser, Microsoft has created a new application class, called "Metro style enabled desktop browser". On the one hand the author seems to be criticizing Microsoft for insisting on a set of ecosystem standards, on the other hand the criticism is for creating a kludge. It's 2012 and the OS is in beta , any comparison…

I agree with you. Browsers are alot like operating system. They are all good for basic tasks but once you get into it, some are good for different tasks.

IE10 metro is fast and has a great UI. But it lacks flash and plugins. Some people will switch to FF to use the plug ins. Some people will use Chrome Metro (They will eventually build one) to use the Google account integration and app store. So at the end of the day Browsers are just like any other app. Whats the big deal?

Post reply on HN